More Like this

1. Paleomagnetic evidence for modern-like plate motion velocities at 3.2 Ga

   https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aaz8670  

   Brenner, Alec R.; Fu, Roger R.; Evans, David A.D.; Smirnov, Aleksey V.; Trubko, Raisa; Rose, Ian R. (April 2020, Science Advances)

   null (Ed.)

   The mode and rates of tectonic processes and lithospheric growth during the Archean [4.0 to 2.5 billion years (Ga) ago] are subjects of considerable debate. Paleomagnetism may contribute to the discussion by quantifying past plate velocities. We report a paleomagnetic pole for the ~3180 million year (Ma) old Honeyeater Basalt of the East Pilbara Craton, Western Australia, supported by a positive fold test and micromagnetic imaging. Comparison of the 44°±15° Honeyeater Basalt paleolatitude with previously reported paleolatitudes requires that the average latitudinal drift rate of the East Pilbara was ≥2.5 cm/year during the ~170 Ma preceding 3180 Ma ago, a velocity comparable with those of modern plates. This result is the earliest unambiguous evidence yet uncovered for long-range lithospheric motion. Assuming this motion is due primarily to plate motion instead of true polar wander, the result is consistent with uniformitarian or episodic tectonic processes in place by 3.2 Ga ago. 

   more » « less
2. The Paleogeography of Laurentia in Its Early Years: New Constraints From the Paleoproterozoic East‐Central Minnesota Batholith

   https://doi.org/10.1029/2021TC006751  

   Swanson‐Hysell, Nicholas L.; Avery, Margaret S.; Zhang, Yiming; Hodgin, Eben B.; Sherwood, Robert J.; Apen, Francisco E.; Boerboom, Terrence J.; Keller, C. Brenhin; Cottle, John M. (May 2021, Tectonics)

   Abstract Theca. 1.83 Ga Trans‐Hudson orogeny resulted from collision of an upper plate consisting of the Hearne, Rae, and Slave provinces with a lower plate consisting of the Superior province. While the geologic record ofca. 1.83 Ga peak metamorphism within the orogen suggests that these provinces were a single amalgamated craton from this time onward, a lack of paleomagnetic poles from the Superior province following Trans‐Hudson orogenesis has made this coherency difficult to test. We develop a high‐quality paleomagnetic pole for northeast‐trending diabase dikes of the post‐Penokean orogen East‐Central Minnesota Batholith (pole longitude: 265.8°; pole latitude: 20.4°; A₉₅: 4.5°; K: 45.6 N: 23) whose age we constrain to be 1,779.1 ± 2.3 Ma (95% CI) with new U‐Pb dates. Demagnetization and low‐temperature magnetometry experiments establish dike remanence be held by low‐Ti titanomagnetite. Thermochronology data constrain the intrusions to have cooled below magnetite blocking temperatures upon initial emplacement with a mild subsequent thermal history within the stable craton. The similarity of this new Superior province pole with poles from the Slave and Rae provinces establishes the coherency of Laurentia following Trans‐Hudson orogenesis. This consistency supports interpretations that older discrepant 2.22–1.87 Ga pole positions between the provinces are the result of differential motion through mobile‐lid plate tectonics. The new pole supports the northern Europe and North America connection between the Laurentia and Fennoscandia cratons. The pole can be used to jointly reconstruct these cratonsca. 1,780 Ma strengthening the paleogeographic position of these major constituents of the hypothesized late Paleoproterozoic supercontinent Nuna. 

   more » « less
3. Internal structure of the Paleoarchean Mt Edgar dome, Pilbara Craton, Western Australia

   https://doi.org/10.1016/j.precamres.2021.106163  

   Roberts, Nicholas M; Tikoff, Basil (January 2021, Precambrian research)

   null (Ed.)

   The Paleoarchean East Pilbara Terrane of Western Australia is a dome-and-keel terrane that is often highlighted as recording a vertically convective tectonic regime in the early Earth. In this model, termed ’partial convective overturn’, granitic domes diapirically rose through a dense, foundering mafic supracrustal sequence. The applicability of partial convective overturn to the East Pilbara Terrane and to other Archean dome-and-keel terranes is widely debated and has significant implications for early Earth geodynamics. A critical data gap in the East Pilbara Terrane is the internal structure of the granitic domes. We present field-based, microstructural, and anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility (AMS) data collected within the Mt Edgar dome to understand its internal structure and assess its compatibility with existing dome formation models. Field and microstructural observations suggest that most fabric development occurred under submagmatic and high-temperature solid- state conditions. The AMS results reveal a coherent, dome-wide structural pattern: 1) Sub-vertical lineations plunge radially inward towards the center of the dome and foliations across much of the dome consistently strike northwest; 2) Shallowly plunging lineations define an arch that extends from the center of the dome to the southwest margin; and 3) Migmatitic gneisses, which represent the oldest granitic component of the dome, are folded and flattened against the margin of the dome in two distinct lobes. The structural relationships between rocks of different ages indicate that units of different crystallization ages deformed synchronously during the last major pulse of granitic magmatism. These data are broadly consistent with a vertical tectonics model, and we synthesize our structural results to propose a three-stage diapiric evolution of the Mt Edgar dome. The critical stage of dome development was between 3.3 and 3.2 Ga, when widespread, melt-assisted flow of the deep crust led to the formation of a steep-walled, composite dome. These data suggest that diapiric processes were important for the formation of dome-and-keel terranes in the Paleoarchean. 

   more » « less
4. Statistical reanalysis of Archean zircon paleointensities: No evidence for stagnant-lid tectonics

   https://doi.org/10.1016/j.epsl.2024.118679  

   Fu, Roger R; Drabon, Nadja; Weiss, Benjamin P; Borlina, Cauê; Kirkpatrick, Heather (May 2024, Earth and Planetary Science Letters)

   The initiation of mobile-lid plate tectonics on Earth represented a critical transition towards a more familiar world in terms of surface temperature stabilization, biogeochemical cycling, topography creation, and other processes. Zircon-based estimates of the geomagnetic field intensity have recently been cited as providing evi- dence for the lack of mobile-lid motion between 3.9 and 3.4 billion years ago (Ga). We reanalyze the published dataset of 91 zircon paleointensities from the Jack Hills (Australia) and Green Sandstone Bed (GSB; South Africa) localities within this time interval and, using both analytical and bootstrap resampling approaches, show that the small number of samples result in large uncertainties in implied paleolatitude. Specifically, in more likely sce- narios that do not assume coherent motion for both localities, all latitudinal displacements on Earth are permitted within the 95 % confidence interval. We also examine the less likely scenario that the two landmasses shared a motion history, which increases the data density and presents the best-case scenario for constraining latitudinal motion. In this case, the 95 % confidence interval of the zircon paleointensity data is compatible with the displacements of between 35 % and 52 % of modern continental localities, all of which experience mobile-lid tectonics. Finally, generating expected paleointensity time series for modern continents undergoing mobile-lid motion shows that about two-thirds of these motions would not be resolved by zircon paleointensities, even in the best-case scenario of combining Jack Hills and GSB datasets. All of these analyses assume that these zircons retain a primary paleomagnetic signal, an assertion which is opposed by a number of published zircon magnetism studies. We conclude that Archean zircon paleointensities do not provide evidence for or against mobile-lid plate tectonics prior to 3.4 Ga. Future paleomagnetic investigation of tectonic regime on the early Earth should therefore focus on magnetization directions in well-preserved, oriented whole rocks. 

   more » « less
5. Hadaean to Palaeoarchaean stagnant-lid tectonics revealed by zircon magnetism

   https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-06024-5  

   Tarduno, John A.; Cottrell, Rory D.; Bono, Richard K.; Rayner, Nicole; Davis, William J.; Zhou, Tinghong; Nimmo, Francis; Hofmann, Axel; Jodder, Jaganmoy; Ibañez-Mejia, Mauricio; et al (June 2023, Nature)

   Plate tectonics is a fundamental factor in the sustained habitability of Earth, but its time of onset is unknown, with ages ranging from the Hadaean to Proterozoic eons1–3. Plate motion is a key diagnostic to distinguish between plate and stagnant-lid tectonics, but palaeomagnetic tests have been thwarted because the planet’s oldest extant rocks have been metamorphosed and/or deformed4. Herein, we report palaeointensity data from Hadaean-age to Mesoarchaean-age single detrital zircons bearing primary magnetite inclusions from the Barberton Greenstone Belt of South Africa5. These reveal a pattern of palaeointensities from the Eoarchaean (about 3.9 billion years ago (Ga)) to Mesoarchaean (about 3.3 Ga) eras that is nearly identical to that defined by primary magnetizations from the Jack Hills (JH; Western Australia)6,7, further demonstrating the recording fidelity of select detrital zircons. Moreover, palaeofield values are nearly constant between about 3.9 Ga and about 3.4 Ga. This indicates unvarying latitudes, an observation distinct from plate tectonics of the past 600 million years (Myr) but predicted by stagnant-lid convection. If life originated by the Eoarchaean8, and persisted to the occurrence of stromatolites half a billion years later9, it did so when Earth was in a stagnant-lid regime, without plate-tectonics-driven geochemical cycling. 

   more » « less