skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Every contact leaves a trace: Documenting contamination in lithic residue studies at the Middle Palaeolithic sites of Lusakert Cave 1 (Armenia) and Crvena Stijena (Montenegro)
Investigations of organic lithic micro-residues have, over the last decade, shifted from entirely morphological observations using visible-light microscopy to compositional ones using scanning electron microscopy and Fourier-transform infrared microspectroscopy, providing a seemingly objective chemical basis for residue identifications. Contamination, though, remains a problem that can affect these results. Modern contaminants, accumulated during the post-excavation lives of artifacts, are pervasive, subtle, and even “invisible” (unlisted ingredients in common lab products). Ancient contamination is a second issue. The aim of residue analysis is to recognize residues related to use, but other types of residues can also accumulate on artifacts. Caves are subject to various taphonomic forces and organic inputs, and use-related residues can degrade into secondary compounds. This organic “background noise” must be taken into consideration. Here we show that residue contamination is more pervasive than is often appreciated, as revealed by our studies of Middle Palaeolithic artifacts from two sites: Lusakert Cave 1 in Armenia and Crvena Stijena in Montenegro. First, we explain how artifacts from Lusakert Cave 1, despite being handled following specialized protocols, were tainted by a modern-day contaminant from an unanticipated source: a release agent used inside the zip-top bags that are ubiquitous in the field and lab. Second, we document that, when non-artifact “controls” are studied alongside artifacts from Crvena Stijena, comparisons reveal that organic residues are adhered to both, indicating that they are prevalent throughout the sediments and not necessarily related to use. We provide suggestions for reducing contamination and increasing the reliability of residue studies. Ultimately, we propose that archaeologists working in the field of residue studies must start with the null hypothesis that miniscule organic residues reflect contamination, either ancient or modern, and systematically proceed to rule out all possible contaminants before interpreting them as evidence of an artifact’s use in the distant past.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2011401
PAR ID:
10411324
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Editor(s):
Peresani, Marco
Date Published:
Journal Name:
PLOS ONE
Volume:
17
Issue:
4
ISSN:
1932-6203
Page Range / eLocation ID:
e0266362
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract Over the last decade, several hyper-scale data center companies such as Google, Facebook, and Microsoft have demonstrated the cost-saving capabilities of airside economization with direct/indirect heat exchangers by moving to chiller-less air-cooled data centers. Under pressure from data center owners, information technology equipment OEMs like Dell and IBM are developing information technology equipment that can withstand peak excursion temperature ratings of up to 45 °C, clearly outside the recommended envelope, and into ASHRAEs A4 allowable envelope. As popular and widespread as these cooling technologies are becoming, airside economization comes with its challenges. There is a risk of premature hardware failures or reliability degradation posed by uncontrolled fine particulate and gaseous contaminants in presence of temperature and humidity transients. This paper presents an in-depth review of the particulate and gaseous contamination-related challenges faced by the modern-day data center facilities that use airside economization. This review summarizes specific experimental and computational studies to characterize the airborne contaminants and associated failure modes and mechanisms. In addition, standard lab-based and in-situ test methods for measuring the corrosive effects of the particles and the corrosive gases, as the means of testing the robustness of the equipment against these contaminants, under different temperature and relative humidity conditions are also reviewed. It also outlines the cost-sensitive mitigation techniques like improved filtration strategies and methods that can be utilized for efficient implementation of airside economization. 
    more » « less
  2. Isotopic analysis of phosphate oxygen from bones and teeth (18Op/16Op, δ18Op) is a common tool used to investigate modern and ancient ecosystems and their climate. However, existing methods have expanded to use pretreatments for organic removal, require large sample sizes, or require extended precipitation timing. All together, these factors could affect accuracy and precision of δ18Op measurement by promoting the formation of oxygen-bearing or nitrogen-rich contaminants. However, the nature and occurrence of contamination are not fully explored. Here we sought to develop a method of silver phosphate precipitation that tests the effect of different sample treatments and reduced sample sizes while preserving sample isotopic composition. Our protocol (SPORA) precipitates Ag3PO4 crystals from ∼1.5 mg of starting material while purifying phosphate from contaminants, like nitrogen or carbonate. Isolation and purification of phosphate are achieved with an anion exchange resin, followed by precipitation of silver phosphate using an updated silver ammine solution that targets small amounts of phosphate in solution. We used a variety of phosphate oxygen reference materials and biogenic apatite materials, such as modern and fossil specimens with varying collagen content, to test the SPORA protocol and its effects on the resultant phosphate oxygen isotopic composition. Results were then compared to those from another published silver phosphate precipitation method (i.e., Rapid University of Chicago Dilute, Rapid UC). Overall, δ18Op values of standards and biogenic apatites were similar between protocols (R2 = 0.99, p << 0.05). In addition to isotope composition comparisons, UV–Vis spectroscopy and Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) analyses discerned phosphate recovery and material composition of crystals precipitated via different protocols, respectively. We found that the resin i) may retain ∼10% of phosphate with no isotopic effects and ii) the SPORA protocol produces Ag3PO4 with more accurate δ18Op measurements by preventing the formation of contaminant oxygen phases, silver oxide (Ag2O) and silver carbonate (Ag2CO3), that confound the phosphate oxygen isotope composition. The SPORA Ag3PO4 precipitation procedure overcomes analytical limitations such as sample size and collagen contamination, conditions that other procedures for δ18Op analysis cannot address simultaneously. The SPORA protocol can be used on a large array of bioapatite materials for paleoecological, paleoclimatic, and archeological applications, while reducing the required sample size and ensuring pure Ag3PO4 for isotopic analysis. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract Increasingly researchers have employed confocal microscopy and 3D surface texture analysis to assess bone surface modifications in an effort to understand ancient behavior. However, quantitative comparisons between the surfaces of purported archaeological bone tools and experimentally manufactured and used bones are complicated by taphonomic processes affecting ancient bone. Nonetheless, it may be reasonable to assume that bones within the same deposits are altered similarly and thus these alterations are quantifiable. Here we show how unworked bones can be used to quantify the taphonomic effect on bone surfaces and how this effect can then be controlled for and incorporated into an analysis for evaluating the modified surfaces of purported bone tools. To assess the baseline taphonomy of Middle Paleolithic archaeological deposits associated with typologically identified bone artifacts, specifically lissoirs , we directly compare the surface textures of ancient and modern unworked ribs. We then compare the ancient unworked ribs and lissoirs to assess their differences and predict the ancient artifacts’ original surface state using a multilevel multivariate Bayesian model. Our findings demonstrate that three of five tested surface texture parameters ( Sa , Spc , and IsT ) are useful for distinguishing surface type. Our model predictions show that lissoirs tend to be less rough, have more rounded surface peaks, and exhibit more directionally oriented surfaces. These characteristics are likely due to anthropogenic modifications and would have been more pronounced at deposition. Quantifying taphonomic alterations moves us one step closer to accurately assessing how bone artifacts were made and used in the ancient past. 
    more » « less
  4. A lab-on-a-smartphone (LOS) presents a portable environmental sensing tool that enables the monitoring of water quality by performing various detection techniques such as smartphone-integrated fluorescence microscopy and portable loop-mediated amplification (LAMP) assays. The LOS can conduct multiple laboratory functions and has experimentally demonstrated (1) automated on-chip water sample processing, (2) on-site fluorescent detection of harmful algae cells, and (3) fecal contamination of water through LAMP assays. The LOS can overcome conventional labor-intensive and time-consuming techniques for the monitoring of microbiological contaminants in environment waters. 
    more » « less
  5. AbstractIn recent years, concerns have been raised regarding the contamination of grapes with pesticide residues. As consumer demand for safer food products grows, regular monitoring of pesticide residues in food has become essential. This study sought to develop a rapid and sensitive technique for detecting two specific pesticides (phosmet and paraquat) present on the grape surface using the surface‐enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) method. Gold nanostars (AuNS) particles were synthesized, featuring spiky tips that act as hot spots for localized surface plasmon resonance, thereby enhancing Raman signals. Additionally, the roughened surface of AuNS increases the surface area, resulting in improved interactions between the substrate and analyte molecules. Prominent Raman peaks of mixed contaminants were acquired and used to characterize and quantify the pesticides. It was observed that the SERS intensity of the Raman peaks changed in proportion to the concentration ratio of phosmet and paraquat. Moreover, AuNS exhibited superior SERS enhancement compared to gold nanoparticles. The results demonstrate that the lowest detectable concentration for both pesticides on grape surfaces is 0.5 mg/kg. These findings suggest that SERS coupled with AuNS constitutes a practical and promising approach for detecting and quantifying trace contaminants in food. Practical ApplicationThis research established a novel surface‐enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) method coupled with a simplified extraction protocol and gold nanostar substrates to detect trace levels of pesticides in fresh produce. The detection limits meet the maximum residue limits set by the EPA. This substrate has great potential for rapid measurements of chemical contaminants in foods. 
    more » « less