skip to main content


Title: Reciprocal swimming at intermediate Reynolds number
In Stokes flow, Purcell's scallop theorem forbids objects with time-reversible (reciprocal) swimming strokes from moving. In the presence of inertia, this restriction is eased and reciprocally deforming bodies can swim. A number of recent works have investigated dimer models that swim reciprocally at intermediate Reynolds numbers ${\textit Re} \approx 1$ –1000. These show interesting results (e.g. switches of the swim direction as a function of inertia) but the results vary and seem to be case specific. Here, we introduce a general model and investigate the behaviour of an asymmetric spherical dimer of oscillating length for small-amplitude motion at intermediate ${\textit {Re}}$ . In our analysis we make the important distinction between particle and fluid inertia, both of which need to be considered separately. We asymptotically expand the Navier–Stokes equations in the small-amplitude limit to obtain a system of linear partial differential equations. Using a combination of numerical (finite element) and analytical (reciprocal theorem, method of reflections) methods we solve the system to obtain the dimer's swim speed and show that there are two mechanisms that give rise to motion: boundary conditions (an effective slip velocity) and Reynolds stresses. Each mechanism is driven by two classes of sphere–sphere interactions, between one sphere's motion and (1) the oscillating background flow induced by the other's motion, and (2) a geometric asymmetry induced by the other's presence. We can thus unify and explain behaviours observed in other works. Our results show how sensitive, counterintuitive and rich motility is in the parameter space of finite inertia of particles and fluid.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1753148
NSF-PAR ID:
10412701
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Fluid Mechanics
Volume:
952
ISSN:
0022-1120
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    Using extensive numerical simulation of the Navier–Stokes equations, we study the transition from the Darcy’s law for slow flow of fluids through a disordered porous medium to the nonlinear flow regime in which the effect of inertia cannot be neglected. The porous medium is represented by two-dimensional slices of a three-dimensional image of a sandstone. We study the problem over wide ranges of porosity and the Reynolds number, as well as two types of boundary conditions, and compute essential features of fluid flow, namely, the strength of the vorticity, the effective permeability of the pore space, the frictional drag, and the relationship between the macroscopic pressure gradient$${\varvec{\nabla }}P$$Pand the fluid velocityv. The results indicate that when the Reynolds number Re is low enough that the Darcy’s law holds, the magnitude$$\omega _z$$ωzof the vorticity is nearly zero. As Re increases, however, so also does$$\omega _z$$ωz, and its rise from nearly zero begins at the same Re at which the Darcy’s law breaks down. We also show that a nonlinear relation between the macroscopic pressure gradient and the fluid velocityv, given by,$$-{\varvec{\nabla }}P=(\mu /K_e)\textbf{v}+\beta _n\rho |\textbf{v}|^2\textbf{v}$$-P=(μ/Ke)v+βnρ|v|2v, provides accurate representation of the numerical data, where$$\mu$$μand$$\rho$$ρare the fluid’s viscosity and density,$$K_e$$Keis the effective Darcy permeability in the linear regime, and$$\beta _n$$βnis a generalized nonlinear resistance. Theoretical justification for the relation is presented, and its predictions are also compared with those of the Forchheimer’s equation.

     
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    We investigate the self-propulsion of an inertial swimmer in a linearly density stratified fluid using the archetypal squirmer model which self-propels by generating tangential surface waves. We quantify swimming speeds for pushers (propelled from the rear) and pullers (propelled from the front) by direct numerical solution of the Navier–Stokes equations using the finite volume method for solving the fluid flow and the distributed Lagrange multiplier method for modelling the swimmer. The simulations are performed for Reynolds numbers ( $Re$ ) between 5 and 100 and Froude numbers ( $Fr$ ) between 1 and 10. We find that increasing the fluid stratification strength reduces the swimming speeds of both pushers and pullers relative to their speeds in a homogeneous fluid. The increase in the buoyancy force experienced by these squirmers due to the trapping of lighter fluid in their respective recirculatory regions as they move in the heavier fluid is one of the reasons for this reduction. With increasing the stratification, the isopycnals tend to deform less, which offers resistance to the flow generated by the squirmers around them to propel themselves. This resistance increases with stratification, thus, reducing the squirmer swimming velocity. Stratification also stabilizes the flow around a puller keeping it axisymmetric even at high $Re$ , thus, leading to stability which is otherwise absent in a homogeneous fluid for $Re$ greater than $O(10)$ . On the contrary, a strong stratification leads to instability in the motion of pushers by making the flow around them unsteady and three-dimensional, which is otherwise steady and axisymmetric in a homogeneous fluid. A pusher is a more efficient swimmer than a puller owing to efficient convection of vorticity along its surface and downstream. Data for the mixing efficiency generated by individual squirmers explain the trends observed in the mixing produced by a swarm of squirmers. 
    more » « less
  3. We examine the linear stability of a homogeneous gas–solid suspension of small Stokes number particles, with a moderate mass loading, subject to a simple shear flow. The modulation of the gravitational force exerted on the suspension, due to preferential concentration of particles in regions of low vorticity, in response to an imposed velocity perturbation, can lead to an algebraic instability. Since the fastest growing modes have wavelengths small compared with the characteristic length scale ( $U_{g}/{\it\Gamma}$ ) and oscillate with frequencies large compared with ${\it\Gamma}$ , $U_{g}$ being the settling velocity and ${\it\Gamma}$ the shear rate, we apply the WKB method, a multiple scale technique. This analysis reveals the existence of a number density mode which travels due to the settling of the particles and a momentum mode which travels due to the cross-streamline momentum transport caused by settling. These modes are coupled at a turning point which occurs when the wavevector is nearly horizontal and the most amplified perturbations are those in which a momentum wave upstream of the turning point creates a downstream number density wave. The particle number density perturbations reach a finite, but large amplitude that persists after the wave becomes aligned with the velocity gradient. The growth of the amplitude of particle concentration and fluid velocity disturbances is characterised as a function of the wavenumber and Reynolds number ( $\mathit{Re}=U_{g}^{2}/{\it\Gamma}{\it\nu}$ ) using both asymptotic theory and a numerical solution of the linearised equations. 
    more » « less
  4. A new continuum perspective for phoretic motion is developed that is applicable to particles of any shape in ‘microstructured’ fluids such as a suspension of solute or bath particles. Using the reciprocal theorem for Stokes flow it is shown that the local osmotic pressure of the solute adjacent to the phoretic particle generates a thrust force (via a ‘slip’ velocity) which is balanced by the hydrodynamic drag such that there is no net force on the body. For a suspension of passive Brownian bath particles this perspective recovers the classical result for the phoretic velocity owing to an imposed concentration gradient. In a bath of active particles that self-propel with characteristic speed $U_0$ for a time $\tau _R$ and then change direction randomly, taking a step of size $\ell = U_0 \tau _R$ , at high activity the phoretic velocity is $\boldsymbol {U} \sim - U_0 \ell \boldsymbol {\nabla } \phi _b$ , where $\phi _b$ is a measure of the ‘volume’ fraction of the active bath particles. The phoretic velocity is independent of the size of the phoretic particle and of the viscosity of the suspending fluid. Because active systems are inherently out of equilibrium, phoretic motion can occur even without an imposed concentration gradient. It is shown that at high activity when the run length varies spatially, net phoretic motion results in $\boldsymbol {U} \sim - \phi _b U_0 \boldsymbol {\nabla } \ell$ . These two behaviours are special cases of the more general result that phoretic motion arises from a gradient in the swim pressure of active matter. Finally, it is shown that a field that orients (but does not propel) the active particles results in a phoretic velocity $\boldsymbol {U} \sim - \phi _b U_0 \ell \boldsymbol {\nabla }\varPsi$ , where $\varPsi$ is the (non-dimensional) potential associated with the field. 
    more » « less
  5. This paper presents a theory to obtain the force per unit length acting on a slender filament with a non-circular cross-section moving in a fluid at low Reynolds number. Using a regular perturbation of the inner solution, we show that the force per unit length has $O(1/\ln (2A))+O(\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}/\ln ^{2}(2A))$ contributions driven by the relative motion of the particle and the local fluid velocity and an $O(\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}/(\ln (2A)A))$ contribution driven by the gradient in the imposed fluid velocity. Here, the aspect ratio ( $A=l/a_{0}$ ) is defined as the ratio of the particle size ( $l$ ) to the cross-sectional dimension ( $a_{0}$ ) and $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}$ is the amplitude of the non-circular perturbation. Using thought experiments, we show that two-lobed and three-lobed cross-sections affect the response to relative motion and velocity gradients, respectively. A two-dimensional Stokes flow calculation is used to extend the perturbation analysis to cross-sections that deviate significantly from a circle (i.e. $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}\sim O(1)$ ). We demonstrate the ability of our method to accurately compute the resistance to translation and rotation of a slender triaxial ellipsoid. Furthermore, we illustrate novel dynamics of straight rods in a simple shear flow that translate and rotate quasi-periodically if they have two-lobed cross-section, and rotate chaotically and translate diffusively if they have a combination of two- and three-lobed cross-sections. Finally, we show the remarkable ability of our theory to accurately predict the motion of rings, retaining great accuracy for moderate aspect ratios ( ${\sim}10$ ) and cross-sections that deviate significantly from a circle, thereby making our theory a computationally inexpensive alternative to other Stokes flow solvers. 
    more » « less