skip to main content


Title: Type II Germanium Clathrates from Zintl Phase Precursor Na 4 Ge 4 : Understanding Desodiation Processes and Sodium Migration Using First-Principles Calculations
Type II germanium clathrates have recently been investigated for potential applications as anodes in batteries due to their cage-like structures that can accommodate electrochemical insertion of guest ions. To synthesize type II Ge clathrates (Ge136), several experimental routes use thermal or electrochemical desodiation of the Zintl phase compound Na4Ge4. However, the mechanism by which Na atoms are removed from the precursor to form clathrates is not well understood. Herein, we use first-principles density functional theory and nudged elastic band calculations to understand the reaction mechanism and formation energies of the products typically observed in the synthesis, namely, NaδGe136 (0 < δ < 24) type II clathrates and hexagonal phase Na1–xGe3+z. Specifically, we confirm the energetic feasibility of Na vacancy formation in Na4Ge4 and find that the barrier for Na vacancy migration is only 0.37 eV. This relatively low energy barrier is consistent with the ease with which Na4Ge4 can be desodiated to form the products. We also discuss the energetics, sodium migration pathways, and potential electrochemical performance of Ge136 as anode material for Na-ion batteries. Overall, this study highlights how first-principles calculations can be used to understand the synthesis mechanism and desodiation processes in clathrate materials and will help guide researchers in the design and evaluation of new open framework compounds as viable materials for energy storage applications.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2004514 1710017
NSF-PAR ID:
10429253
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
The Journal of Physical Chemistry C
ISSN:
1932-7447
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Clathrates of Tetrel elements (Si, Ge, Sn) have attracted interest for their potential use in batteries and other applications. Sodium-filled silicon clathrates are conventionally synthesized through thermal decomposition of the Zintl precursor Na4Si4, but phase selectivity of the product is often difficult to achieve. Herein, we report the selective formation of the type I clathrate Na8Si46using electrochemical oxidation at 450 °C and 550 °C. A two-electrode cell design inspired by high-temperature sodium-sulfur batteries is employed, using Na4Si4as working electrode, Naβ″-alumina solid electrolyte, and counter electrode consisting of molten Na or Sn. Galvanostatic intermittent titration is implemented to observe the oxidation characteristics and reveals a relatively constant cell potential under quasi-equilibrium conditions, indicating a two-phase reaction between Na4Si4and Na8Si46. We further demonstrate that the product selection and morphology can be altered by tuning the reaction temperature and Na vapor pressure. Room temperature lithiation of the synthesized Na8Si46is evaluated for the first time, showing similar electrochemical characteristics to those in the type II clathrate Na24Si136. The results show that solid-state electrochemical oxidation of Zintl phases at high temperatures can lead to opportunities for more controlled crystal growth and a deeper understanding of the formation processes of intermetallic clathrates.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Manganese‐rich layered oxide materials hold great potential as low‐cost and high‐capacity cathodes for Na‐ion batteries. However, they usually form a P2 phase and suffer from fast capacity fade. In this work, an O3 phase sodium cathode has been developed out of a Li and Mn‐rich layered material by leveraging the creation of transition metal (TM) and oxygen vacancies and the electrochemical exchange of Na and Li. The Mn‐rich layered cathode material remains primarily O3 phase during sodiation/desodiation and can have a full sodiation capacity of ca. 220 mAh g−1. It delivers ca. 160 mAh g−1specific capacity between 2–3.8 V with >86 % retention over 250 cycles. The TM and oxygen vacancies pre‐formed in the sodiated material enables a reversible migration of TMs from the TM layer to the tetrahedral sites in the Na layer upon de‐sodiation and sodiation. The migration creates metastable states, leading to increased kinetic barrier that prohibits a complete O3‐P3 phase transition.

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Manganese‐rich layered oxide materials hold great potential as low‐cost and high‐capacity cathodes for Na‐ion batteries. However, they usually form a P2 phase and suffer from fast capacity fade. In this work, an O3 phase sodium cathode has been developed out of a Li and Mn‐rich layered material by leveraging the creation of transition metal (TM) and oxygen vacancies and the electrochemical exchange of Na and Li. The Mn‐rich layered cathode material remains primarily O3 phase during sodiation/desodiation and can have a full sodiation capacity of ca. 220 mAh g−1. It delivers ca. 160 mAh g−1specific capacity between 2–3.8 V with >86 % retention over 250 cycles. The TM and oxygen vacancies pre‐formed in the sodiated material enables a reversible migration of TMs from the TM layer to the tetrahedral sites in the Na layer upon de‐sodiation and sodiation. The migration creates metastable states, leading to increased kinetic barrier that prohibits a complete O3‐P3 phase transition.

     
    more » « less
  4. α-NaFeO 2 shares a structure similar to many layered electrode materials in Li-ion and Na-ion batteries. In this work, first-principles calculations are carried out to gain atomistic understanding of structural evolution, ion transport and oxygen stability in NaFeO 2 . Based on the calculation results, we provide an atomistic description of phase transition and structural changes during the charging process. Meanwhile, we identify a di-vacancy assisted diffusion mechanism for Na ions and estimate the diffusion barrier that agrees with experimental data. Furthermore, we reveal that lattice strains could modulate both ion transport and oxygen stability in NaFeO 2 . A moderate 3% tension in the out-of-plane direction could render the ion diffusion barrierless. Moreover, it is predicted that in-plane compressions can stabilize oxygen and suppress oxygen evolution at high potentials. Thus, a combination of the out-of-plane tension with the in-plane compression is expected to reduce the diffusion barrier and stabilize oxygen simultaneously. 
    more » « less
  5. Sodium-containing batteries have the potential to address many of the challenges faced in the ongoing development of enhanced energy storage devices. Sodium is inexpensive and earth abundant, and aprotic Na−O2 batteries, in particular, have gravimetric energy densities significantly exceeding those of Li-ion devices. However, poor functional cell lifespans present a significant obstacle to the development of Na−O2 cells, with parasitic side reactions involving the NaO2 discharge products, leading to a rapid decline in cell performance. These parasitic reactions are hypothesized to occur through two main pathways: (i) deleterious dissolution of NaO2 into the electrolyte during periods of cell idling and (ii) disproportionation of NaO2 in the near-surface region to form Na-rich species (Na1+xO2) on the cathode. To formulate practical strategies to suppress these processes, in turn, the development of fundamental, molecular-level mechanistic understanding is essential. In this contribution, such mechanistic insights are elucidated by coupling density functional theory calculations with experimental observations to study the surface chemistry of the NaO2 discharge product. First, a series of ab initio surface phase diagrams are constructed to determine the structure of the NaO2 surfaces under realistic operating conditions, whereby an inverse relationship between surface coordination and surface energy is determined. Next, a molecular surface dissolution analysis is performed for the identified surface terminations, demonstrating a further inverse relationship between surface energy and the thermodynamic barrier for dissolution. Finally, a study of the thermodynamics of thin-film formation of sodium oxides over the NaO2 discharge product is carried out and suggests that an electrochemical reduction reaction, rather than an inherent chemical disproportionation, forms the observed Na-rich species in the near-surface region under high discharge overpotentials. From these insights, we suggest future studies that may yield practical design changes to improve stability and extend the lifespan of Na−O2 batteries. 
    more » « less