An official website of the United States government
Sodium-containing batteries have the potential to address many of the challenges faced in the ongoing development of enhanced energy storage devices. Sodium is inexpensive and earth abundant, and aprotic Na−O2 batteries, in particular, have gravimetric energy densities significantly exceeding those of Li-ion devices. However, poor functional cell lifespans present a significant obstacle to the development of Na−O2 cells, with parasitic side reactions involving the NaO2 discharge products, leading to a rapid decline in cell performance. These parasitic reactions are hypothesized to occur through two main pathways: (i) deleterious dissolution of NaO2 into the electrolyte during periods of cell idling and (ii) disproportionation of NaO2 in the near-surface region to form Na-rich species (Na1+xO2) on the cathode. To formulate practical strategies to suppress these processes, in turn, the development of fundamental, molecular-level mechanistic understanding is essential. In this contribution, such mechanistic insights are elucidated by coupling density functional theory calculations with experimental observations to study the surface chemistry of the NaO2 discharge product. First, a series of ab initio surface phase diagrams are constructed to determine the structure of the NaO2 surfaces under realistic operating conditions, whereby an inverse relationship between surface coordination and surface energy is determined. Next, a molecular surface dissolution analysis is performed for the identified surface terminations, demonstrating a further inverse relationship between surface energy and the thermodynamic barrier for dissolution. Finally, a study of the thermodynamics of thin-film formation of sodium oxides over the NaO2 discharge product is carried out and suggests that an electrochemical reduction reaction, rather than an inherent chemical disproportionation, forms the observed Na-rich species in the near-surface region under high discharge overpotentials. From these insights, we suggest future studies that may yield practical design changes to improve stability and extend the lifespan of Na−O2 batteries.
more »
« less
Elucidation of Parasitic Reaction Mechanisms at Interfaces in Na–O 2 Batteries
Sodium-containing batteries have the potential to address many of the challenges faced in the ongoing development of enhanced energy storage devices. Sodium is inexpensive and earth abundant, and aprotic Na−O2 batteries, in particular, have gravimetric energy densities significantly exceeding those of Li-ion devices. However, poor functional cell lifespans present a significant obstacle to the development of Na−O2 cells, with parasitic side reactions involving the NaO2 discharge products, leading to a rapid decline in cell performance. These parasitic reactions are hypothesized to occur through two main pathways: (i) deleterious dissolution of NaO2 into the electrolyte during periods of cell idling and (ii) disproportionation of NaO2 in the near-surface region to form Na-rich species (Na1+xO2) on the cathode. To formulate practical strategies to suppress these processes, in turn, the development of fundamental, molecular-level mechanistic understanding is essential. In this contribution, such mechanistic insights are elucidated by coupling density functional theory calculations with experimental observations to study the surface chemistry of the NaO2 discharge product. First, a series of ab initio surface phase diagrams are constructed to determine the structure of the NaO2 surfaces under realistic operating conditions, whereby an inverse relationship between surface coordination and surface energy is determined. Next, a molecular surface dissolution analysis is performed for the identified surface terminations, demonstrating a further inverse relationship between surface energy and the thermodynamic barrier for dissolution. Finally, a study of the thermodynamics of thin-film formation of sodium oxides over the NaO2 discharge product is carried out and suggests that an electrochemical reduction reaction, rather than an inherent chemical disproportionation, forms the observed Na-rich species in the near-surface region under high discharge overpotentials. From these insights, we suggest future studies that may yield practical design changes to improve stability and extend the lifespan of Na−O2 batteries.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2312634
- PAR ID:
- 10482973
- Publisher / Repository:
- ACS
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Chemistry of Materials
- Volume:
- 35
- Issue:
- 15
- ISSN:
- 0897-4756
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 5945 to 5952
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Alkali metal–O2 batteries (i.e., Li/Na–O2) with high specific energies are promising alternatives to state-of-the-art metal-ion batteries. However, they are plagued by challenges arising from the underlying redox chemistry, resulting in reduced efficiencies. These challenges for Li/Na–O2 batteries stem from the nature of the interface between solid discharge product(s) and either (i) the aprotic electrolyte or (ii) the solid cathode. In the former, the reactive nature of the solid/liquid interface leads to chemical disproportionation of the discharge product(s) and the electrolyte, while in the latter, the presence/lack of atomistic interactions at the solid–solid interface leads to large overpotential losses (>1 V) during charging. Approaches to overcome these challenges would involve decoupling these factors. For instance, the use of inert aprotic electrolytes would facilitate catalytically driven, surface-mediated discharge product(s) growth, providing avenues to use cathode surface modifications as levers to enhance voltaic efficiency and discharge product stability, resulting in improved performance.more » « less
-
Room-temperature sodium-sulfur (RT Na-S) batteries have attracted ever-increasing attention because of their enhanced energy density and low price. Although the performance of RT Na-S batteries is obtained in many other research, the basic mechanism and kinetics have not involved yet, especially in discharge product growth, which affects electrochemical performance. Meanwhile, designed additional redox activities (in the presence of oxygen) could simultaneously suppress sodium polysulfide shuttling and enhance energy density according to our group reported. However, the kinetic study of the intermediate has not been explored. In this work, we discussed the deposition of low-order sodium polysulfide (Na2Sx, x ≤ 2) in different potentials and types of glyme-solvents in Na-S and Na/(O2)-S system. The results show that the morphology of deposition Na2Sx(x ≤ 2) is affected by interfacial energy barrier controlled by overpotentials and the radius of sodium ions, which produced the precipitation of particle shape rather than film. Potentiostatic experiments show the kinetics are elevated in the presence of oxygen. In addition, the exchange current density of different sodium polysulfides was studied. The high-order sodium polysulfide has a lower exchange current density than that of low-order sodium polysulfide in Na-S system, requiring greater driving force, while transformation of the intermediate from high-order oxy-sulfur to low-order oxy-sulfur species require less impulse in Na/(O2)-S systems. This paper provides new understandings of the deposition mechanism and kinetics of Na2Sx(x ≤ 2) Na-S and Na/(O2)-S system in and to choose the appropriate solvent and potential.more » « less
-
Abstract Nonaqueous sodium-based batteries are ideal candidates for the next generation of electrochemical energy storage devices. However, despite the promising performance at ambient temperature, their low-temperature (e.g., < 0 °C) operation is detrimentally affected by the increase in the electrolyte resistance and solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) instability. Here, to circumvent these issues, we propose specific electrolyte formulations comprising linear and cyclic ether-based solvents and sodium trifluoromethanesulfonate salt that are thermally stable down to −150 °C and enable the formation of a stable SEI at low temperatures. When tested in the Na||Na coin cell configuration, the low-temperature electrolytes enable long-term cycling down to −80 °C. Via ex situ physicochemical (e.g., X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, cryogenic transmission electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy) electrode measurements and density functional theory calculations, we investigate the mechanisms responsible for efficient low-temperature electrochemical performance. We also report the assembly and testing between −20 °C and −60 °C of full Na||Na 3 V 2 (PO 4 ) 3 coin cells. The cell tested at −40 °C shows an initial discharge capacity of 68 mAh g −1 with a capacity retention of approximately 94% after 100 cycles at 22 mA g −1 .more » « less
-
Sodium- and potassium-ion batteries are one of the most promising electrical energy storage devices at low cost, but their inferior rate and capacity have hampered broader applications such as electric vehicles and grids. Carbon nanomaterials have been demonstrated to have ultrafast surface-dominated ion uptake to drastically increase the rate and capacity, but trial-and-error approaches are usually used to find desired anode materials from numerous candidates. Here, we developed guiding principles to rationally screen pseudocapacitive anodes from numerous candidate carbon materials to create ultrafast Na- and K-ion batteries. The transition from pseudocapacitive to metal-battery mechanisms on heteroatom-doped graphene in charging process was revealed by the density functional theory methods. The results show that the graphene substrate can guide the preferential growth of K and Na along graphene plane, which inhibits dendrite development effectively in the batteries. An intrinsic descriptor is discovered to establish a volcano-shaped relationship that correlates the capacity with the intrinsic physical qualities of the doping structures, from which the best anode materials could be predicted. The predictions are in good agreement with the experimental results. The strategies for enhancing both the power and energy densities are proposed based on the predictions and experiments for the batteries.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.chemmater.3c00850
