An official website of the United States government
Abstract Understanding controls on solute export to streams is challenging because heterogeneous catchments can respond uniquely to drivers of environmental change. To understand general solute export patterns, we used a large‐scale inductive approach to evaluate concentration–discharge (C–Q) metrics across catchments spanning a broad range of catchment attributes and hydroclimatic drivers. We leveraged paired C–Q data for 11 solutes from CAMELS‐Chem, a database built upon an existing dataset of catchment and hydroclimatic attributes from relatively undisturbed catchments across the contiguous USA. Because C–Q relationships with Q thresholds reflect a shift in solute export dynamics and are poorly characterized across solutes and diverse catchments, we analysed C–Q relationships using Bayesian segmented regression to quantify Q thresholds in the C–Q relationship. Threshold responses were rare, representing only 12% of C–Q relationships, 56% of which occurred for solutes predominantly sourced from bedrock. Further, solutes were dominated by one or two C–Q patterns that reflected vertical solute–source distributions. Specifically, solutes predominantly sourced from bedrock had diluting C–Q responses in 43%–70% of catchments, and solutes predominantly sourced from soils had more enrichment responses in 35%–51% of catchments. We also linked C–Q relationships to catchment and hydroclimatic attributes to understand controls on export patterns. The relationships were generally weak despite the diversity of solutes and attribute types considered. However, catchment and hydroclimatic attributes in the central USA typically drove the most divergent export behaviour for solutes. Further, we illustrate how our inductive approach generated new hypotheses that can be tested at discrete, representative catchments using deductive approaches to better understand the processes underlying solute export patterns. Finally, given these long‐term C–Q relationships are from minimally disturbed catchments, our findings can be used as benchmarks for change in more disturbed catchments.
more »
« less
Revisiting the Origins of the Power‐Law Analysis for the Assessment of Concentration‐Discharge Relationships
Key Points We re‐evaluate equations proposed by Francis Hall to assess concentration‐discharge ( C ‐ Q ) relationships using newly available long‐term and high‐frequency data sets Across time steps we find that log‐log and log‐linear models perform equally well to describe C ‐ Q relationships Parametrization of storage‐discharge relationships via recession analyses provides additional insight to C ‐ Q relationships
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10440113
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Water Resources Research
- Volume:
- 59
- Issue:
- 8
- ISSN:
- 0043-1397
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Concentration-discharge (C-Q) relationships of total suspended solids (TSS), total dissolved solids (TDS), particulate organic carbon (POC), and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) were investigated in the tributaries and main-stems of two mountainous river systems with distinct watershed characteristics (Eel and Umpqua rivers) in Northern California and central Oregon (USA). Power-law (C = a × Q b) fits to the data showed strong transport-limited behavior (b > 1) by TSS and POC, moderate transport limitation of DOC (b > 0.3) and chemostatic behavior (b < 0) by TDS in most streams. These contrasts led to significant compositional differences at varying discharge levels, with particle-bound constituents becoming increasingly important (relative abundances of 50% to >90%) at high-flow conditions. Organic carbon contents of TSS displayed marked decreases with discharge whereas they increased in TDS during high-flow conditions. Daily and cumulative material fluxes for different coastal streams were calculated using the C-Q relationships and showed that the delivery of transport-limited constituents, such as TSS and POC (and DOC to a lesser degree), was closely tied to high-discharge events and occurred primarily during the winter season. The coherence between winter fluxes and high wave-southerly wind conditions along the coast highlights how seasonal and inter-annual differences in fluvial discharge patterns affect the fate of land-derived materials delivered to coastal regions.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)This study determines the relationships between water flow and water quality in three types of channels in southern Florida, USA: Shark River Slough, Peace River, and Hillsboro Canal. Peace River most resembles a natural channel with floodplain connectivity, sinuosity, and uninhibited flow. Shark River Slough has a natural, shallow channel with sheet flow, while the Hillsboro Canal is the most modified channel due to dredging, straightening, and regulated flow. Hydrologic indices for each channel were estimated to characterize flow regimes and flow variability, while concentration–discharge (C–Q) relationships were determined to quantify the impact of flow regime on water quality. The greatest variability in flow occurred at the Hillsboro Canal, followed by Peace River and Shark River Slough. Connectivity to floodplains and long durations of low and high flow pulses at Peace River and Shark River Slough contributed to the dilution of water quality constituent concentrations at higher flows. Conversely, the channelized characteristics of the Hillsboro Canal resulted in an enrichment of constituents, especially during high flows. This study suggests that C–Q relationships can be used in canal discharge management to prevent water quality degradation of sensitive downstream wetland and aquatic ecosystems.more » « less
-
Abstract Processes that drive variability in catchment solute sourcing, transformation, and transport can be investigated using concentration–discharge (C–Q) relationships. These relationships reflect catchment and in‐stream processes operating across nested temporal scales, incorporating both short and long‐term patterns. Scientists can therefore leverage catchment‐scale C–Q datasets to identify and distinguish among the underlying meteorological, biological, and geological processes that drive solute export patterns from catchments and influence the shape of their respective C–Q relationships. We have synthesized current knowledge regarding the influence of biological, geological, and meteorological processes on C–Q patterns for various solute types across diel to decadal time scales. We identify cross‐scale linkages and tools researchers can use to explore these interactions across time scales. Finally, we identify knowledge gaps in our understanding of C–Q temporal dynamics as reflections of catchment and in‐stream processes. We also lay the foundation for developing an integrated approach to investigate cross‐scale linkages in the temporal dynamics of C–Q relationships, reflecting catchment biogeochemical processes and the effects of environmental change on water quality. This article is categorized under:Science of Water > Hydrological ProcessesScience of Water > Water QualityScience of Water > Water and Environmental Changemore » « less
-
Abstract Intermittent streams that regularly dry up constitute over half of the world's river network. They exhibit biogeochemical processes distinct from those of continuously flowing perennial rivers. In perennial rivers, discharge is often perceived as predominantly driving water chemistry, as demonstrated by the widespread use of concentration–discharge (CQ) relationships. Does discharge similarly drive water chemistry in intermittent streams? Given its extended periods of no flow, we hypothesized that stream chemistry depends less on discharge alone but more on the granularity of dry‐wet transitions, including their direction (drying or rewetting), history (antecedent conditions), and intermittency. We tested this hypothesis by analyzing three decades of streamflow and solute chemistry data from an intermittent stream (N04D) in the Konza Prairie Biological Station, a Long‐Term Ecological Research site in Kansas, USA. Results showed that concentrations are generally higher at no flow compared to flow conditions and depend on dry‐wet transitions. Geogenic solutes were predominantly chemostatic (relatively constantCwithoutQdependence), contrasting primarily dilution patterns (decreasingCwithQ) in perennial rivers. Biogenic solutes did not exhibit pronounced discharge‐dependent patterns commonly observed in perennial rivers at decadal scale; at monthly scale, however, they exhibited a transition from highly variableCQpatterns at low flows to consistent flushing patterns (increasingCwithQ) at flows higher than 2.5–5 mm/day. These observations support our hypothesis of weaker chemistry dependence on discharge in intermittent streams. We further hypothesize that the emerging discharge thresholds signal a tipping point at which intermittent streams switch from a dry state governed by intermittency‐driven biogeochemistry to a wet, discharge‐driven state resembling perennial rivers. The hypothesis calls for intensive data collection at dry‐wet transitions to develop theories and models for intermittent streams that have become increasingly prevalent globally.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1029/2023WR034910
