skip to main content


This content will become publicly available on June 18, 2024

Title: Can we still measure circular dichroism with circular dichroism spectrometers: The dangers of anisotropic artifacts
Abstract

Chiral materials with strong linear anisotropies are difficult to accurately characterize with circular dichroism (CD) because of artifactual contributions to their spectra from linear dichroism (LD) and birefringence (LB). Historically, researchers have used a second‐order Taylor series expansion on the Mueller matrix to model the LDLB interaction effects on the spectra in conventional materials, but this approach may no longer be sufficient to account for the artifactual CD signals in emergent materials. In this work, we present an expression to model the measured CD using a third‐order expansion, which introduces “pairwise interference” terms that, unlike the LDLB terms, cannot be averaged out of the signal. We find that the third‐order pairwise interference terms can make noticeable contributions to the simulated CD spectra. Using numerical simulations of the measured CD across a broad range of linear and chiral anisotropy parameters, the LDLB interactions are most prominent in samples that have strong linear anisotropies (LD, LB) but negligible chiral anisotropies, where the measured CD strays from the chirality‐induced CD by factors greater than 103. Additionally, the pairwise interactions are most significant in systems with moderate‐to‐strong chiral and linear anisotropies, where the measured CD is inflated twofold, a figure that grows as linear anisotropies approach their maximum. In summary, media with moderate‐to‐strong linear anisotropy are in great danger of having their CD altered by these effects in subtle manners. This work highlights the significance of considering distortions in CD measurements through higher‐order pairwise interference effects in highly anisotropic nanomaterials.

 
more » « less
Award ID(s):
2003431
NSF-PAR ID:
10441929
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley Blackwell (John Wiley & Sons)
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Chirality
Volume:
35
Issue:
11
ISSN:
0899-0042
Format(s):
Medium: X Size: p. 846-855
Size(s):
["p. 846-855"]
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Post-synthetic phase transfer ligand exchange has been established as a simple, reliable, and versatile method for the synthesis of chiral, optically active colloidal nanocrystals displaying circular dichroism (CD) and circularly polarized luminescence (CPL). Herein we present a water-free and purification-free cyclohexane → methanol ligand exchange system that led to the synthesis of stable, non-aggregating chiral and fluorescent cadmium sulfide quantum dots (CdS QDs). Absorption and emission studies revealed that the carboxylate capping ligands can tune the band gap by up to 65 meV as well as control the band gap and deep trap emission pathways. The CD data revealed that the addition of a 2nd stereogenic center did not automatically lead to an increase of the CD anisotropy of QDs, but rather match/mismatch cooperativity effects must be considered in the transfer of the chirality from the capping ligands to the achiral nanocrystals. Variation in position of the functional groups as well as the chemical identity of the functional groups impacted both the shape and anisotropy of the induced CD spectra and revealed the importance of the functional groups’ coordination and polarity on the binding geometry and induced chiroptical properties. Finally, we describe the first example where CD spectra of QDs capped with the same ligand and dissolved in the same solvent displayed very different spectral profiles. This work provides deeper insight into induced CD of QDs and paves the path to rational design of chiral nanomaterials. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Introducing chirality into organic/inorganic hybrid materials can impart chiroptical properties such as circular dichroism. The ability to tune chiroptical properties in self‐assembled materials can have important implications for spintronic and optoelectronic applications. Here, a chiral organic cation, (R/S)‐4‐methoxy‐α‐methylbenzylammonium, is incorporated to synthesize the bismuth‐based hybrid organic–inorganic metal halide semiconductor, (R/S‐MeOMePMA)BiI4. Thin films of this Bi‐based compound demonstrate large chiroptical responses, with circular dichroism anisotropy (gCD) values up to ≈0.1, close to the highest value observed in another chiral metal‐halide semiconductor, (R‐MBA2CuCl4). Detailed investigation reveals that this large gCDin (R/S‐MeOMePMA)BiI4is caused by the apparent CD effect. Careful selection of deposition conditions and the concomitant thin‐film orientation enables the control of gCD, with maximum value observed when its thin film has a well‐crystallized preferred (001) orientation parallel to the substrate. The results support a growing body of evidence that low symmetry plays an important role in achieving unusually large gCDin these chiral metal–halide materials and provides design rules for achieving large chiroptical response via morphology control.

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Gyroid optical metamaterials consist of triply periodic chiral networks that are attractive photonic structures due to the combination of intriguing optical properties and spontaneous self‐assembly‐based fabrication routes using materials such as block copolymers. A previous experimental investigation found that gyroid metamaterials support strong circular dichroism, beyond what simulations only considering bulk interactions predict. In this work, simulations are used to unravel the contributions of bulk and surface interactions on the circular dichroism spectra of silver‐infilled gyroid metamaterial films. It is found that surface interactions have a significant, often dominating, contribution to circular dichroism. The relative strength of bulk and surface contributions can be tuned by controlling the crystallographic orientation, termination plane of the film, thickness, metal volume fraction, and defect density. Importantly, the dominance of surface interactions allows double gyroids, which are achiral in the bulk, to support strong circular dichroism responses withg‐factor magnitudes as large as 0.25.

     
    more » « less
  4. Core-resonant circular dichroism (CD) signals are induced by molecular chirality and vanish for achiral molecules and racemic mixtures. The highly localized nature of core excitations makes them ideal probes of local chirality within molecules. Simulations of the circular dichroism spectra of several molecular families illustrate how these signals vary with the electronic coupling to substitution groups, the distance between the X-ray chromophore and the chiral center, geometry, and chemical structure. Clear insight into the molecular structure is obtained through analysis of the X-ray CD spectra. 
    more » « less
  5. UV circular dichroism (UVCD) spectroscopy is a prominent tool for exploring secondary structures of polypeptides and proteins. In the unfolded state of these biomolecules, most of the individual residues primarily sample a conformation called polyproline II. Its CD spectrum contains a negatively biased positive couplet with a pronounced negative maximum below and a weak positive maximum above 200 nm. It is traditionally rationalized in terms of an excitonic coupling mechanism augmented by polarization effects. In this work, we carry out new time-dependent density functional theory calculations on the cationic tripeptide GAG in implicit and explicit water to determine the transitions that give rise to the observed CD signals of polyproline II and β-strand conformations. Our results reveal a plethora of electronic transitions that are governed by configurational interactions between multiple molecular orbital transitions of comparable energy. We also show that reproducing the CD spectra of polyproline II and β-strand conformations requires the explicit consideration of water molecules. The structure dependence of delocalized occupied orbitals contributes to the experimentally-observed invalidation of Flory's isolated pair hypothesis. 
    more » « less