An official website of the United States government
Abstract Here we use Richards Equation models of variably saturated soil and bedrock groundwater flow to investigate first‐order patterns of the coupling between soil and bedrock flow systems. We utilize a Monte Carlo sensitivity analysis to identify important hillslope parameters controlling bedrock recharge and then model the transient response of bedrock and soil flow to seasonal precipitation. Our results suggest that hillslopes can be divided into three conceptual zones of groundwater interaction, (a) the zone of lateral unsaturated soil moisture accumulation (upper portion of hillslope), (b) the zone of soil saturation and bedrock recharge (middle of hillslope) and (c) the zone of saturated‐soil lateral flow and bedrock groundwater exfiltration (bottom of hillslope). Zones of groundwater interaction expand upslope during periods of precipitation and drain downslope during dry periods. The amount of water partitioned to the bedrock groundwater system a can be predicted by the ratio of bedrock to soil saturated hydraulic conductivity across a variety of hillslope configurations. Our modelled processes are qualitatively consistent with observations of shallow subsurface saturation and groundwater fluctuation on hillslopes studied in our two experimental watersheds and support a conceptual model of tightly coupled shallow and deep subsurface circulation where groundwater recharge and discharge continuously stores and releases water from longer residence time storage.
more »
« less
Sensitivity of Simulated Mountain Block Hydrology to Subsurface Conceptualization
Abstract Mountain block systems are critical to water resources and have been heavily studied and modeled in recent decades. However, due to lack of field data, there is little consistency in how models represent the mountain block subsurface. While there is a large body of research on subsurface heterogeneity, few studies have evaluated the effect that common conceptual choices modelers make in mountainous systems have on simulated hydrology. Here we simulate the hydrology of a semi‐idealized headwater catchment using six common conceptual models of the mountain block subsurface. These scenarios include multiple representations of hydraulic conductivity decaying with depth, changes in soil depth with topography, and anisotropy. We evaluate flow paths, discharge, and water tables to quantify the impact of subsurface conceptualization on hydrologic behavior in three dimensions. Our results show that adding higher conductivity layers in the shallow subsurface concentrates flow paths near the surface and increases average saturated flow path velocities. Increasing heterogeneity by adding additional layers or introducing anisotropy increases the variance in the relationship between the age and length of saturated flow paths. Discharge behavior is most sensitive to heterogeneity in the shallow subsurface layers. Water tables are less sensitive to layering than they are to the overall conductivity in the domain. Anisotropy restricts flow path depths and controls discharge from storage but has little effect on governing runoff. Differences in the response of discharge, water table depth, and residence time distribution to subsurface representation highlight the need to consider model applications when determining the level of complexity that is needed.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1806383
- PAR ID:
- 10448445
- Publisher / Repository:
- DOI PREFIX: 10.1029
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Water Resources Research
- Volume:
- 56
- Issue:
- 10
- ISSN:
- 0043-1397
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract Physics‐based distributed hydrological models that include groundwater are widely used to understand and predict physical and biogeochemical processes within watersheds. Typically, due to computational limitations, watershed modelers minimize the number of elements used in domain discretization, smoothing or even ignoring critical topographic features. We use an idealized model to investigate the implications of mesh refinement along streams and ridges for modeling three‐dimensional groundwater flow and transport in mountainous watersheds. For varying degrees of topographic complexity level (TCL), which increases with the level of mesh refinement, and geological heterogeneity, we estimate and compare steady state baseflow discharge, mean age, and concentration of subsurface weathering products. Results show that ignoring lower‐order streams or ridges diminishes flow through local flow paths and biases higher the contribution of intermediate and regional flow paths, and biases baseflow older. The magnitude of the bias increases for systems where permeability rapidly decreases with depth and is dominated by shallow flow paths. Based on a simple geochemical model, the concentration of weathering products is less sensitive to the TCL, partially due to the thermodynamic constraints on chemical reactions. Our idealized model also reproduces the observed emergent scaling relationship between the groundwater contribution to streamflow and drainage area, and finds that this scaling relationship is not sensitive to mesh TCL. The bias effects have important implications for the use of hydrological models in the interpretation of environmental tracer data and the prediction of biogeochemical evolution of stream water in mountainous watersheds.more » « less
-
How does the physical and chemical structure of the Critical Zone (CZ), defined as the zone from treetops to the bottom of groundwater, govern its hydro-biogeochemical functioning? Multiple lines of evidence from past and newly emerging research have prompted the shallow and deep partitioning concentration-discharge (C-Q) hypothesis. The hypothesis states that in-stream C-Q relationships are shaped by distinct source waters from flow paths at different depths. Base flows are often dominated by deep groundwater and mostly reflect groundwater chemistry, whereas high flows are often dominated by shallow soil water and thus mostly reflect soil water chemistry. The contrasts between shallow soil water versus deeper groundwater chemistry shape stream solute export patterns. In this context, the vertical connectivity that regulates the shallow and deep flow partitioning is essential in determining chemical contrasts, biogeochemical reaction rates in soils and parent rocks, and ultimately solute export patterns. This talk will highlight insights gleaned from multiple lines of recent studies that include collation of water chemistry data from soils, rocks, and streams in intensively monitored watersheds, meta-analysis of stream chemistry data at the continental scale, and integrated reactive transport modeling at the hillslope and watershed scales. The hypothesis underscores the importance of subsurface vertical structure and connectivity relative to the extensively studied horizontal connectivity. It also alludes to the potential of using streams as mirrors for subsurface water chemistry, and the potential of using C-Q relationships to infer flow paths and biogeochemical reaction rates and the response of earth’s subsurface to climate and human perturbations. Broadly, this simple conceptual framework links CZ subsurface structure to its functioning under diverse climate, geology, and land cover conditions.more » « less
-
Abstract Dissolved organic and inorganic carbon (DOC and DIC) influence water quality, ecosystem health, and carbon cycling. Dissolved carbon species are produced by biogeochemical reactions and laterally exported to streams via distinct shallow and deep subsurface flow paths. These processes are arduous to measure and challenge the quantification of global carbon cycles. Here we ask: when, where, and how much is dissolved carbon produced in and laterally exported from the subsurface to streams? We used a catchment‐scale reactive transport model, BioRT‐HBV, with hydrometeorology and stream carbon data to illuminate the “invisible” subsurface processes at Sleepers River, a carbonate‐based catchment in Vermont, United States. Results depict a conceptual model where DOC is produced mostly in shallow soils (3.7 ± 0.6 g/m2/yr) and in summer at peak root and microbial respiration. DOC is flushed from soils to the stream (1.0 ± 0.2 g/m2/yr) especially during snowmelt and storms. A large fraction of DOC (2.5 ± 0.2 g/m2/yr) percolates to the deeper subsurface, fueling deep respiration to generate DIC. DIC is exported predominantly from the deeper subsurface (7.1 ± 0.4 g/m2/yr, compared to 1.3 ± 0.3 g/m2/yr from shallow soils). Deep respiration reduces DOC and increases DIC concentrations at depth, leading to commonly observed DOC flushing (increasing concentrations with discharge) and DIC dilution patterns (decreasing concentrations with discharge). Surprisingly, respiration processes generate more DIC than weathering in this carbonate‐based catchment. These findings underscore the importance of vertical connectivity between the shallow and deep subsurface, highlighting the overlooked role of deep carbon processing and export.more » « less
-
ABSTRACT The importance of subsurface water dynamics, such as water storage and flow partitioning, is well recognised. Yet, our understanding of their drivers and links to streamflow generation has remained elusive, especially in small headwater streams that are often data‐limited but crucial for downstream water quantity and quality. Large‐scale analyses have focused on streamflow characteristics across rivers with varying drainage areas, often overlooking the subsurface water dynamics that shape streamflow behaviour. Here we ask the question:What are the climate and landscape characteristics that regulate subsurface dynamic storage, flow path partitioning, and dynamics of streamflow generation in headwater streams?To answer this question, we used streamflow data and a widely‐used hydrological model (HBV) for 15 headwater catchments across the contiguous United States. Results show that climate characteristics such as aridity and precipitation phase (snow or rain) and land attributes such as topography and soil texture are key drivers of streamflow generation dynamics. In particular, steeper slopes generally promoted more streamflow, regardless of aridity. Streams in flat, rainy sites (< 30% precipitation as snow) with finer soils exhibited flashier regimes than those in snowy sites (> 30% precipitation as snow) or sites with coarse soils and deeper flow paths. In snowy sites, less weathered, thinner soils promoted shallower flow paths such that discharge was more sensitive to changes in storage, but snow dampened streamflow flashiness overall. Results here indicate that land characteristics such as steepness and soil texture modify subsurface water storage and shallow and deep flow partitioning, ultimately regulating streamflow response to climate forcing. As climate change increases uncertainty in water availability, understanding the interacting climate and landscape features that regulate streamflow will be essential to predict hydrological shifts in headwater catchments and improve water resources management.more » « less
