Title: Heterogeneous Patterns of Aged Organic Carbon Export Driven by Hydrologic Flow Paths, Soil Texture, Fire, and Thaw in Discontinuous Permafrost Headwaters
Abstract Climate change is thawing and potentially mobilizing vast quantities of organic carbon (OC) previously stored for millennia in permafrost soils of northern circumpolar landscapes. Climate‐driven increases in fire and thermokarst may play a key role in OC mobilization by thawing permafrost and promoting transport of OC. Yet, the extent of OC mobilization and mechanisms controlling terrestrial‐aquatic transfer are unclear. We demonstrate that hydrologic transport of soil dissolved OC (DOC) from the active layer and thawing permafrost to headwater streams is extremely heterogeneous and regulated by the interactions of soils, seasonal thaw, fire, and thermokarst. Repeated sampling of streams in eight headwater catchments of interior Alaska showed that the mean age of DOC for each stream ranges widely from modern to ∼2,000 years B.P. Together, an endmember mixing model and nonlinear, generalized additive models demonstrated that Δ14C‐DOC signature (and mean age) increased from spring to fall, and was proportional to hydrologic contributions from a solute‐rich water source, related to presumed deeper flow paths found predominantly in silty catchments. This relationship was correlated with and mediated by catchment properties. Mean DOC ages were older in catchments with >50% burned area, indicating that fire is also an important explanatory variable. These observations underscore the high heterogeneity in aged C export and difficulty of extrapolating estimates of permafrost‐derived DOC export from watersheds to larger scales. Our results provide the foundation for developing a conceptual model of permafrost DOC export necessary for advancing understanding and prediction of land‐water C exchange in changing boreal landscapes.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1820883
PAR ID:
10478687
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
American Geophysical Union
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Global Biogeochemical Cycles
Volume:
36
Issue:
4
ISSN:
0886-6236
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract The consequences of climate change on boreal ecosystems are evident in declining permafrost extent, amplifying positive climate feedback loops, and altering the timing and intensity of hydrologic events. Thawing permafrost in the discontinuous permafrost zone could affect carbon and nutrient cycling in stream ecosystems. We examined stream chemistry and climate trends over a 20+‐year period across catchments in the Caribou Poker Creeks Research Watershed underlain with varying extents of permafrost (4%–53%). The study aimed to evaluate patterns in dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC,pCO2), dissolved organic carbon (DOC), nitrogen (Dissolved organic nitrogen, and NO3), geochemical solutes (Ca2+, Mg2+, SO42−), and discharge to determine how altered terrestrial flowpaths and climate change‐related trends in temperature and precipitation have transformed solute transport in high‐latitude watersheds during the ice‐free season. We analyzed long‐term trends in stream chemistry using Thiel‐Sen analysis and a mixed effects model to quantify the influence of abiotic factors on solute concentrations. Results indicate significant declines in DOC (−109.0 to −169.9 μg L−1 yr−1) andpCO2(−24.1 ppmv yr−1) in higher permafrost extent sub‐catchments. The highest permafrost catchment is experiencing the greatest amount of change, contrasting sharply with opposite to fewer trends in the catchments with lower permafrost extent. Model results indicate the importance of moisture conditions and discharge (p < 0.05), especially for changes in organic solutes. As climate change progresses, the role of these abiotic factors and permafrost thaw will remain important for solute transport dynamics in boreal headwater streams, with consequences for in‐stream communities and downstream solute yields. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract Headwater catchments have strong impacts on downstream waterways, near‐shore ecosystems, and the quality of water available for growing human populations. Thus, understanding how water and solutes are exported through these upland landscapes is critically important. A growing body of literature highlights the interaction of topography, climate, and the critical zone structure as a key control on streamflow and chemical export. However, more focused work is needed to pinpoint how variability in subsurface structure across lithologically complex regions impacts streamflow and chemical signals at catchment outlets. Here, we aim to better understand how lithology and subsurface critical zones modulate streamflow response and solute export patterns in two central coastal California headwater catchments that are similar in topography, vegetation, and climate but have different lithologies. We monitored streamflow and collected surface water samples at the catchment outlets for dissolved major ions and organic carbon (DOC) for two consecutive water years. The catchment with mélange bedrock displayed much flashier hydrologic behavior with 7.8 times higher peak flow values and 1.9 times higher mean event concentrations of DOC, suggesting shorter and shallower hydrologic flow paths that likely arise from regions of shallower bedrock. Despite distinct hydrologic behavior and DOC export, dissolved major ion concentrations were broadly similar and chemostatic, which may be driven by rapid chemical reactions in the critical zone of both catchments. Our work contributes to building an integrated understanding of how subtle differences in catchment structure can have profound impacts on how water and solutes are routed through headwater catchments. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract Metabolism in stream ecosystems alters the fate of organic carbon (OC) received from surrounding landscapes, but our understanding of in‐stream metabolic processes in boreal ecosystems remains limited. Determining the factors that regulate OC metabolism will help predict how the C balance of boreal streams may respond to future environmental change. In this study, we addressed the question: what controls OC metabolism in boreal headwater streams draining catchments with discontinuous permafrost? We hypothesized that metabolism is collectively regulated by OC reactivity, phosphorus availability, and temperature, with discharge modulating each of these conditions. We tested these hypotheses using a combination of laboratory experiments and whole‐stream ecosystem metabolism measurements throughout the Caribou‐Poker Creeks Research Watershed (CPCRW) in Interior Alaska, USA. In the laboratory experiments, respiration and dissolved OC (DOC) removal were both co‐limited by the supply of reactive C and phosphorus, but temperature and residence time acted as stronger controls of DOC removal. Ecosystem respiration (ER) was largely predicted by discharge and site, with some variance explained by gross primary production (GPP) and temperature. Both ER and GPP varied inversely with watershed permafrost extent, with an inverse relationship between temperature and permafrost extent providing one plausible explanation. Our results provide some of the first evidence of a functional response to permafrost thaw in stream ecosystems and suggest the role of metabolism in landscape C cycling may increase as climate change progresses. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract The thawing of ancient organic carbon stored in arctic permafrost soils, and its oxidation to carbon dioxide (CO2, a greenhouse gas), is predicted to amplify global warming. However, the extent to which organic carbon in thawing permafrost soils will be released as CO2is uncertain. A critical unknown is the extent to which dissolved organic carbon (DOC) from thawing permafrost soils is respired to CO2by microbes upon export of freshly thawed DOC to both dark bottom waters and sunlit surface waters. In this study, we quantified the radiocarbon age and13C composition of CO2produced by microbial respiration of DOC that was leached from permafrost soils and either kept in the dark or exposed to ultraviolet and visible wavelengths of light. We show that permafrost DOC most labile to microbial respiration was as old or older (ages 4,000–11,000 a BP) and more13C‐depleted than the bulk DOC in both dark and light‐exposed treatments, likely indicating respiration of old,13C‐depleted lignin and lipid fractions of the permafrost DOC pool. Light exposure either increased, decreased, or had no effect on the magnitude of microbial respiration of old permafrost DOC relative to respiration in the dark, depending on both the extent of DOC oxidation during exposure to light and the wavelength of light. Together, these findings suggest that photochemical changes affecting the lability of permafrost DOC during sunlight exposure are an important control on the magnitude of microbial respiration of permafrost DOC in arctic surface waters. 
    more » « less
  5. Coarse particulate organic matter (CPOM; organic matter 1–100 mm in diameter, excluding small wood) stored in streams provides an important energy source for aquatic ecosystems, and CPOM transport provides downstream energy subsidies and is a pathway for watershed carbon export. However, we lack understanding of the magnitude of and processes influencing CPOM storage and transport in headwater streams. We assessed how geomorphic complexity and hydrologic regime influence CPOM transport and storage in the Colorado Front Range, USA. We compared CPOM transport during snowmelt in a stream reach with high retentive feature (e.g., wood, cobbles, and other features) frequency to a reach with low retentive feature frequency, assessing how within-a-reach geomorphic context influences CPOM transport. We also compared CPOM transport in reaches with differing valley geometry (two confined reaches versus a wide, multi-thread river bead) to assess the influence of geomorphic variations occurring over larger spatial extents. Additionally, we compared CPOM storage in accumulations in reaches (n= 14) with flowing water or dry conditions in late summer and investigated how small pieces of organic matter [e.g., woody CPOM and small wood (>1 min length and 0.05–1 min diameter or 0.5–1 min length and >0.1 min diameter)] influence CPOM storage. We found that within-a-reach retentive feature frequency did not influence CPOM transport. However, valley geometry influenced CPOM transport, with a higher CPOM transport rate (median: 1.53 g min−1) downstream of a confined stream reach and a lower CPOM transport rate (median: 0.13 g min−1) downstream of a low gradient, multi-thread river bead. Additionally, we found that particulate organic carbon (POC) export (0.063 Mg C) in the form of CPOM was substantially lower than dissolved organic carbon (DOC) export (12.3 Mg C) in one of these headwater streams during the 2022 water year. Dry reaches stored a higher volume of CPOM (mean = 29.18 m3ha−1) compared to reaches with flowing water (15.75 m3ha−1), and woody CPOM pieces trapped 37% of CPOM accumulations. Our results demonstrate that the influence of geomorphic context on CPOM transport depends on the scale and type of geomorphic complexity, POC may be lower than DOC export in some headwater streams, and small woody organic material is important for trapping CPOM small streams. 
    more » « less