Sodium-containing batteries have the potential to address many of the challenges faced in the ongoing development
of enhanced energy storage devices. Sodium is inexpensive and earth abundant, and aprotic Na−O2 batteries, in particular, have gravimetric energy densities significantly exceeding those of Li-ion devices. However, poor functional cell lifespans present a significant obstacle to the development of Na−O2 cells, with parasitic side reactions involving the NaO2 discharge products, leading to a rapid decline in cell performance. These parasitic reactions are hypothesized to occur through two main pathways: (i) deleterious dissolution of NaO2 into the electrolyte during periods of cell idling and (ii) disproportionation of NaO2 in the near-surface region to form Na-rich species (Na1+xO2) on the cathode. To formulate practical strategies to suppress these processes, in turn, the development of fundamental, molecular-level mechanistic understanding is essential. In this contribution, such mechanistic insights are elucidated by coupling density functional theory calculations with experimental observations to study the surface chemistry of the NaO2 discharge product. First, a series of ab initio surface phase diagrams are constructed to determine the structure of the NaO2 surfaces under realistic operating conditions, whereby an inverse relationship between surface coordination and surface energy is determined. Next, a molecular surface dissolution analysis is performed for the identified surface terminations, demonstrating a further inverse relationship between surface energy and the thermodynamic barrier for dissolution. Finally, a study of the thermodynamics of thin-film formation of sodium oxides over the NaO2 discharge product is carried out and suggests that an electrochemical reduction reaction, rather than an inherent chemical disproportionation, forms the observed Na-rich species in the near-surface region under high discharge overpotentials. From these insights, we suggest future studies that may yield practical design changes to improve stability and extend the lifespan of Na−O2 batteries.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on August 8, 2024
Elucidation of Parasitic Reaction Mechanisms at Interfaces in Na–O 2 Batteries
Sodium-containing batteries have the potential to address many of the challenges faced in the ongoing development
of enhanced energy storage devices. Sodium is inexpensive and earth abundant, and aprotic Na−O2 batteries, in particular, have gravimetric energy densities significantly exceeding those of Li-ion devices. However, poor functional cell lifespans present a significant obstacle to the development of Na−O2 cells, with parasitic side reactions involving the NaO2 discharge products, leading to a rapid decline in cell performance. These parasitic reactions are hypothesized to occur through two main pathways: (i) deleterious dissolution of NaO2 into the electrolyte during periods of cell idling and (ii) disproportionation of NaO2 in the near-surface region to form Na-rich species (Na1+xO2) on the cathode. To formulate practical strategies to suppress these processes, in turn, the development of fundamental, molecular-level mechanistic understanding
is essential. In this contribution, such mechanistic insights are elucidated by coupling density functional theory calculations with experimental observations to study the surface chemistry of the NaO2 discharge product. First, a series of ab initio surface phase diagrams are constructed to determine the structure of the NaO2 surfaces under realistic operating conditions, whereby an inverse relationship between surface coordination and surface energy is determined. Next, a molecular surface dissolution analysis is performed for the identified surface terminations, demonstrating a further inverse relationship between surface energy and the thermodynamic barrier for dissolution. Finally, a study of the thermodynamics of thin-film formation of sodium oxides over the NaO2 discharge product is carried out and suggests that an electrochemical reduction reaction, rather than an inherent chemical disproportionation, forms the observed Na-rich species in the near-surface region under high discharge overpotentials. From these insights, we suggest future studies that may yield practical design changes to improve stability and extend the lifespan of Na−O2 batteries.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2312634
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10482973
- Publisher / Repository:
- ACS
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Chemistry of Materials
- Volume:
- 35
- Issue:
- 15
- ISSN:
- 0897-4756
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 5945 to 5952
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Alkali metal–O2 batteries (i.e., Li/Na–O2) with high specific energies are promising alternatives to state-of-the-art metal-ion batteries. However, they are plagued by challenges arising from the underlying redox chemistry, resulting in reduced efficiencies. These challenges for Li/Na–O2 batteries stem from the nature of the interface between solid discharge product(s) and either (i) the aprotic electrolyte or (ii) the solid cathode. In the former, the reactive nature of the solid/liquid interface leads to chemical disproportionation of the discharge product(s) and the electrolyte, while in the latter, the presence/lack of atomistic interactions at the solid–solid interface leads to large overpotential losses (>1 V) during charging. Approaches to overcome these challenges would involve decoupling these factors. For instance, the use of inert aprotic electrolytes would facilitate catalytically driven, surface-mediated discharge product(s) growth, providing avenues to use cathode surface modifications as levers to enhance voltaic efficiency and discharge product stability, resulting in improved performance.more » « less
-
Metal-ion batteries (e.g., lithium and sodium ion batteries) are the promising power sources for portable electronics, electric vehicles, and smart grids. Recent metal-ion batteries with organic liquid electrolytes still suffer from safety issues regarding inflammability and insufficient lifetime.1 As the next generation energy storage devices, all-solid-state batteries (ASSBs) have promising potentials for the improved safety, higher energy density, and longer cycle life than conventional Li-ion batteries.2 The nonflammable solid electrolytes (SEs), where only Li ions are mobile, could prevent battery combustion and explosion since the side reactions that cause safety issues as well as degradation of the battery performance are largely suppressed. However, their practical application is hampered by the high resistance arising at the solid–solid electrode–electrolyte interface (including cathode-electrolyte interface and anode-electrolyte interface).3 Several methods have been introduced to optimize the contact capability as well as the electrochemical/chemical stability between the metal anodes (i.e.: Li and Na) and the SEs, which exhibited decent results in decreasing the charge transfer resistance and broadening the range of the stable energy window (i.e., lowing the chemical potential of metal anode below the highest occupied molecular orbital of the SEs).4 Nevertheless, mitigation for the cathode in ASSB is tardily developed because: (1) the porous structure of the cathode is hard to be infiltrated by SEs;5 (2) SEs would be oxidized and decomposed by the high valence state elements at the surface of the cathode at high state of charge.5 Herein, we demonstrate a universal cathode design strategy to achieve superior contact capability and high electrochemical/chemical stability with SEs. Stereolithography is adopted as a manufacturing technique to realize a hierarchical three-dimensional (HTD) electrode architecture with micro-size channels, which is expected to provide larger contact areas with SEs. Then, the manufactured cathode is sintered at 700 °C in a reducing atmosphere (e.g.: H2) to accomplish the carbonization of the resin, delivering sufficiently high electronic conductivity for the cathode. To avoid the direct exposure of the cathode active materials to the SEs, oxidative chemical vapor deposition technique (oCVD) is leveraged to build conformal and highly conducting poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) (PEDOT) on the surface of the HTD cathode.6 To demonstrate our design strategy, both NCM811 and Na3V2(PO4)3 is selected as active materials in the HTD cathode, then each cathode is paired with organic (polyacrylonitrile-based) and inorganic (sulfur-based) SEs assembled into two batteries (total four batteries). SEM and TEM reveal the micro-size HTD structure with built-in channels. Featured by the HTD architecture, the intrinsic kinetic and thermodynamic conditions will be enhanced by larger surface contact areas, more active sites, improved infusion and electrolyte ion accessibility, and larger volume expansion capability. Disclosed by X-ray computed tomography, the interface between cathode and SEs in the four modified samples demonstrates higher homogeneity at the interface between the cathode and SEs than that of all other pristine samples. Atomic force microscopy is employed to measure the potential image of the cross-sectional interface by the peak force tapping mode. The average potential of modified samples is lower than that of pristine samples, which confirms a weakened space charge layer by the enhanced contact capability. In addition, through Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy coupled with Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy, the preserved interface between HTD cathode and SE is identified; however, the decomposing of the pristine cathode is clearly observed. In addition, Finite element method simulations validate that the diffusion dynamics of lithium ions is favored by HTD structure. Such a demonstrated universal strategy provides a new guideline to engineer cathode electrolyte interface by reconstructing electrode structures that can be applicable to all solid-state batteries in a wide range of chemical conditions.more » « less
-
more » « less
Abstract NASICON‐type sodium vanadium phosphate (Na3V2(PO4)3, or NVP) cathode materials have great potential for fast charging and long cycling sodium‐ion batteries (SIBs) similar to lithium iron phosphate (LiFePO4, or LFP) cathode materials used in lithium‐ion batteries (LIBs). However, the cycle life and energy density in the full cell using NVP materials need to be significantly improved. This paper investigates the degradation mechanisms of NVP‐based SIBs and identifies the Na loss from the cathode to the anode solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) reactions as the main cause of capacity degradation. A new Na‐rich NVP cathode (e.g., Na4V2(PO4)3, or Na4VP) is developed to address the Na loss problem. Conventional NVP can be easily transformed into the Na4VP by a facile and fast chemical solution treatment (30 s). Na‐free‐anode Na4VP and hard carbon‐Na4VP full cells are assembled to evaluate the electrochemical properties of the Na‐rich NVP cathode. The Na4VP cathode provides excess Na to compensate for the Na loss, resulting much longer cycle life in the full cells (>400 cycles) and a high specific energy and power density. Good low‐temperature performance is also observed.
-
more » « less
Abstract The rechargeable K‐O2battery is recognized as a promising energy storage solution owing to its large energy density, low overpotential, and high coulombic efficiency based on the single‐electron redox chemistry of potassium superoxide. However, the reactivity and long‐term stability of potassium superoxide remains ambiguous in K‐O2batteries. Parasitic reactions are explored and the use of ion chromatography to quantify trace amounts of side products is demonstrated. Both quantitative titrations and differential electrochemical mass spectrometry confirm the highly reversible single‐electron transfer process, with 98 % capacity attributed to the formation and decomposition of KO2. In contrast to the Na‐O2counterparts, remarkable shelf‐life is demonstrated for K‐O2batteries owing to the thermodynamic and kinetic stability of KO2, which prevents the spontaneous disproportionation to peroxide. This work sheds light on the reversible electrochemical process of K++e−+O2↔KO2.
