skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Variability in membrane behavior of geosynthetic clay liners
Geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs) comprising sodium bentonite (NaB) have been shown to exhibit significant membrane behavior, whereby contaminants are restricted from passing through the clay due to electrostatic repulsion, potentially enhancing long-term containment performance. Recent membrane behavior research has focused on evaluating membrane efficiency () of enhanced bentonites (e.g., bentonite polymer composites) and testing under more complex conditions (e.g., elevated temperatures, unsaturated conditions), often drawing comparisons with earlier published data on NaB-GCLs. However, the validity of comparing NaB-GCL results across studies and from earlier work remains unclear. No prior study has evaluated the variability in reported  values for the same type of NaB-GCL manufactured in different years. In this study, multistage membrane behavior tests were performed on specimens of the same NaB-GCL type manufactured at different dates. One specimen (GCL1) was taken from a NaB-GCL roll manufactured in the last five years. Another specimen (GCL2) was taken from a NaB-GCL roll that had been stored in a laboratory since 2005. Values of  were measured for both specimens, and also compared to results reported in 2002 for the same type of NaB-GCL (GCL3). To support interpretation of the results, cation exchange capacity, mass per unit area, and swell index tests also were performed. For the same salt solution concentrations, GCL2 exhibited significantly lower  than GCL1 and GCL3. Lower values of  corresponded to lower bentonite mass per unit area. The results have important implications regarding limitations in comparing results of current membrane behavior research on enhanced materials and testing conditions to commonly cited literature data.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2143145
PAR ID:
10522157
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
ASCE
Date Published:
ISSN:
DOI 10.1061/9780784485323.03
Format(s):
Medium: X
Location:
Vancouver, Canada
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Geosynthetic clay liners (GCLs) used in waste and chemical containment applications exhibit high swell and low hydraulic conductivity to water (e.g., k < 10−10 m/s), such that diffusion dominates contaminant transport occurring through the barrier. Thus, knowledge of expected diffusion coefficients for GCLs under relevant environmental conditions is required for performance-based design and accurate assessment of the barrier system. Unfortunately, diffusion testing for bentonites can be challenging and time consuming, limiting data availability for GCL diffusion coefficients. The dialysis leaching test (DLT) method has been utilized in recent studies for simple, time-efficient diffusion measurements for bulk sodium bentonites (NaB), enhanced bentonites, and NaB pastes. This study used a new, modified version of the DLT method for measuring diffusion in GCLs comprising NaB. Diffusion tests were performed using dilute (20 mM) and aggressive (100 mM) calcium chloride (CaCl2) solutions to measure apparent diffusion coefficients (Da) for chloride for the GCLs. Values of Da were in the range of 10−10 m2/s, consistent with expectations from the literature for longer-term traditional testing. Diffusion coefficients increased as CaCl2 concentration increased, as expected due to cation exchange and suppression of the diffuse double layer in the bentonite in the GCL. The results of the study demonstrate the potential use of a new, time-efficient test method for assessing diffusion properties of GCLs, further improving our ability to predict contaminant transport through barrier systems. 
    more » « less
  2. Currently, verifying additively manufactured (AM) parts requires time consuming and expensive nondestructive evaluation (NDE) processes such as computed tomography (CT) x-ray scanning. While such methods provide details on flaw type and location, they require significant cost and time. Often, in production environments, significant value is gained by rapidly screening part specimens for flaws at all. Cost-effective per-specimen testing for production runs of AM parts is important for their use to be economically justified. In this work, Northrop Grumman Corporation and Virginia Tech explored impedance-based testing as a means to evaluate AM titanium specimens. Specimens with and without manually-designed flaws were fabricated through a metal- based AM process and evaluated using the impedance-based technique. CT scans confirmed that the intended flaws in the experimental specimens were present. Impedance-based examination also showed the presence of unintended defects. After machining away the unintended defective regions, the flaw-containing defective specimen had a clearly different impedance ‘signature’ than non-flawed baseline specimens. Additional analysis confirmed that the impedance test method required cheaper capital equipment and required less technician time to examine test results. Taken together, this means that the impedance-based this method can reduce the total cost of utilizing AM for metal part manufacturing. 
    more » « less
  3. In this paper, small blocks of 17-4 PH stainless steel were manufactured via extrusion-based bound powder extrusion (BPE)/atomic diffusion additive manufacturing (ADAM) technology in two different orientations. Ultrasonic bending-fatigue and uniaxial tensile tests were carried out on the test specimens prepared from the AM blocks. Specifically, a recently-introduced small-size specimen design is employed to carry out time-efficient fatigue tests. Based on the results of the testing, the stress–life (S-N) curves were created in the very high-cycle fatigue (VHCF) regime. The effects of the printing orientation on the fatigue life and tensile strength were discussed, supported by fractography taken from the specimens’ fracture surfaces. The findings of the tensile test and the fatigue test revealed that vertically-oriented test specimens had lower ductility and a shorter fatigue life than their horizontally-oriented counterparts. The resulting S-N curves were also compared against existing data in the open literature. It is concluded that the large-sized pores (which originated from the extrusion process) along the track boundaries strongly affect the fatigue life and elongation of the AM parts. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract In vitro mechanical testing of intervertebral discs is crucial for basic science and pre‐clinical testing. Generally, these tests aim to replicate in vivo conditions, but simplifications are necessary in specimen preparation and mechanical testing due to complexities in both structure and the loading conditions required to replicate in vivo conditions. There has been a growing interest in developing a consensus of testing protocols within the spine community to improve comparison of results between studies. The objective of this study was to perform axial compression experiments on bovine bone‐disc‐bone specimens at three institutions. No differences were observed between testing environment being air, with PBS soaked gauze, or a PBS bath (P > .206). A 100‐fold increase in loading rate resulted in a small (2%) but significant increase in compressive mechanics (P < .017). A 7% difference in compressive stiffness between Labs B and C was eliminated when values were adjusted for test system compliance. Specimens tested at Lab A, however, were found to be stiffer than specimens from Lab B and C. Even after normalizing for disc geometry and adjusting for system compliance, an ∼35% difference was observed between UK based labs (B and C) and the USA based lab (A). Large differences in specimen stiffness may be due to genetic differences between breeds or in agricultural feed and use of growth hormones; highlighting significant challenges in comparing mechanics data across studies. This research provides a standardized test protocol for the comparison of spinal specimens and provides steps towards understanding how location and test set‐up may affect biomechanical results. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract In this research, a room temperature multicycle nanoindentation technique was implemented to evaluate the effects of the laser peening (LP) process on the surface mechanical behavior of additively manufactured (AM) Inconel 625. Repetitive deformation was introduced by loading-unloading during an instrumented nanoindentation test on the as-built (No LP), 1-layer, and 4-layer laser peened (1LP and 4LP) conditions. It was observed that laser-peened specimens had a significantly higher resistance to penetration of the indenter and lower permanent deformation. This is attributed to the pre-existing dislocation density induced by LP in the material which affects the dislocation interactions during the cyclic indentation. Moreover, high levels of compressive stresses, which are greater in the 4LP specimen than the 1LP specimen, lead to more effective improvement of surface fatigue properties. The transition of the material response from elastic-plastic to almost purely elastic in 4LP specimens was initiated much earlier than it did in the No LP, and 1LP specimens. In addition to the surface fatigue properties, hardness and elastic modulus were also evaluated and compared. 
    more » « less