Engineering technology education often struggles to help students connect abstract energy concepts to authentic design contexts. This study examines the integration of an AI-supported scaffold within a first-year energy-efficiency design challenge. Students used a simulation tool to optimize a solar-powered house affected by tree shading, balancing technical, economic, and environmental constraints. A large language model served as a conversational design counterpart under two conditions: a scaffolded model that prompted evidence-based argumentation and a non-technical model that engaged in open-ended dialogue. Pre- and post-test results indicated significant gains in conceptual knowledge and self-reported decision-making confidence. Student reflections suggested that AI-supported dialogue encouraged clearer justification of design choices and deeper consideration of trade-offs. Rather than isolating specific causal mechanisms, this study characterizes the overall impact of embedding AI-driven scaffolding within simulation-based learning. Findings suggest that structured AI interaction can support reflective reasoning and evidence-based design thinking in early engineering technology education.
more »
« less
Using artificial intelligence teaching assistants to guide students in solar energy engineering design
Engineering projects, such as designing a solar farm that converts solar radiation shined on the Earth into electricity, engage students in addressing real-world challenges by learning and applying geoscience knowledge. To improve their designs, students benefit from frequent and informative feedback as they iterate. However, teacher attention may be limited or inadequate, both during COVID-19 and beyond. We present Aladdin, a web-based computer-aided design (CAD) platform for engineering design with a built-in artificial intelligence teaching assistant (AITA). We also present two curriculum units (Solar Energy Science and Solar Farm Design), where students explore the Sun-Earth relationship and optimize the energy output and yearly profit of a solar farm with the help of the AITA. We tested the software and curriculum units with over 100 students in two Midwestern high schools. Pre- and post-survey data showed improvements in understanding of science concepts and self-efficacy in engineering design. Pre-post analysis of design performance gains reveals that AI helped lower achievers more than higher achievers. Interviews revealed students’ values and preferences when receiving feedback. Our findings suggest that AITAs may be helpful as an additional feedback mechanism for geoscience and engineering education. Future efforts should focus on improving the usability of the software and providing multiple types of feedback to promote inclusive and equitable use of AI in education.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10530861
- Publisher / Repository:
- Taylor & Francis
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of Geoscience Education
- ISSN:
- 1089-9995
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 1 to 20
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Engineering technology education often struggles to help students connect abstract energy concepts to authentic design contexts. This study examines the integration of an AI-supported scaffold within a first-year energy-efficiency design challenge. Students used a simulation tool to optimize a solar-powered house affected by tree shading, balancing technical, economic, and environmental constraints. A large language model served as a conversational design counterpart under two conditions: a scaffolded model that prompted evidence-based argumentation and a non-technical model that engaged in open-ended dialogue. Pre- and post-test results indicated significant gains in conceptual knowledge and self-reported decision-making confidence. Student reflections suggested that AI-supported dialogue encouraged clearer justification of design choices and deeper consideration of trade-offs. Rather than isolating specific causal mechanisms, this study characterizes the overall impact of embedding AI-driven scaffolding within simulation-based learning. Findings suggest that structured AI interaction can support reflective reasoning and evidence-based design thinking in early engineering technology education.more » « less
-
Engineering design education is an effective instructional approach for enhancing students’ motivation, interest, and creativity while introducing them to the engineering design process (EDP). However, there is limited knowledge on how to integrate the EDP into robotics education, particularly AI-robotics, and how students experience AI-enabled robotics project-based learning grounded in an EDP. This pre-/posttest embedded mixed-methods study adds to the scarce body of literature on interdisciplinary education in engineering design, robotics, and AI. This project developed, implemented, and evaluated a project-based engineering design AI-robotics curriculum that introduced novice Computer Science (CS) high school students to robotics, machine learning, and AI. Students’ collaborative robotics projects were grounded in an EDP to introduce the students to engineering practices and promote engagement and interest through design-based, hands-on learning. An analysis of quantitative and qualitative data revealed an improvement in students’ CS attitudes, collaboration, and social interactions after participating in the curriculum. Recommendations for designing AI-robotics projects grounded in an EDP are discussed.more » « less
-
As science teachers, you observe excitement among your middle school students when they build things, tinker with materials, and work together. The engineering design practices included in the K–12 Framework for Science Education (NRC 2012) are an attempt to harness this excitement and enthusiasm for science and engineering. Integrating engineering design into your laboratory science teaching is an engaging way to support students in learning mathematics and science concepts (Katehi, Pearson, and Feder 2009). This article describes how the three of us (an education professor, a middle school teacher who implements engineering design activities as part of a green STEM curriculum, and an engineering professor) built on student thinking to design a weeklong unit on solar energy that supported mathematics and science learning. The lesson included students designing and redesigning a model solar car and culminated in a model-solar-car race.more » « less
-
Systems thinking is a foundational cognitive skillset to advance sustainability education but has not been well examined for learners prior to higher education. This case study research performed in rural middle schools in the Midwestern U.S. examines the system thinking outcomes of a place-based energy literacy unit focused on energy efficient building design. The unit employs the science of energy-efficient, green buildings to illuminate the important ways in which energy flows between natural and built environments. Focus is centered on electrical, light, and thermal energy systems and the ways these systems interact to create functional and energy-efficient classroom buildings. The unit pre and post assessment utilized the pedagogical strategy of systems models to encourage students to display their mental models of the systems through drawings, annotations, and writings. This study focuses on three case study classrooms where students across schools (n=33) completed pre and post unit assessment models. From pre to post, growth was observed in both identification of system elements and linkages between elements. Areas of growth built off classroom elements in student mental models such as windows, lights, and temperature control, suggesting that units rooted in place-based teaching may support systems thinking skills. Implications for curriculum design are discussed, and the presentation will conclude with a preview of digital tools currently being developed to enhance systems thinking for sustainability education.more » « less
An official website of the United States government

