Abstract Computation of binding constants from spectrophotometric titration data is a very popular application of chemometric hard modeling. However, the calculated values are misleading if the correct binding model is not used. Given that many supramolecular systems of interest feature unknown speciation, a priori determination of binding stoichiometry constitutes an important unsolved problem in chemometrics. We present a new and reliable algorithm for accomplishing this task, implemented using a hybrid particle swarm optimization technique. Simultaneous optimization of stoichiometry ratios and binding constants allows the optimal binding model to be calculated in just a few minutes for systems with up to four reactions. Simulated data studies demonstrate that the algorithm finds the correct stoichiometry with up to nine reactions in the absence of noise, including accurately determining species with unusual stoichiometry, such as H2G5. Application to four experimental datasets shows the algorithm is robust to experimental errors for a variety of chemical systems and binding models. This algorithm will facilitate the discovery of complex binding models, increase efficiency in titration analysis, and avert incorrect stoichiometry models, thereby improving the reliability of binding constant information in spectrophotometric titrations.
more »
« less
Driving to K-town: the quest for quality binding constants
Binding constants (K) are foundational to supramolecular chemistry and quantified by modelling spectroscopic (NMR, UV-vis) titration data according to chemical equilibria. Spurred by growth in data science, the tools and methods for determining K values have accelerated in recent years. To share these advances, we provided a Workshop on Quantifying Binding Constants at ISMSC 2023 in Iceland and herein share the objectives, processes, and recommendations. We framed this short course in terms of learning to drive, from the basics ‘under the hood’, to ‘behind the wheel’, and navigating ‘the open road’. These steps are crucial in the ‘drive to K-town’, where participants appreciate the importance of building, analysing, and comparing models. K-town is where they assess the hazards of incomplete models, inaccurate K values, and incorrect uncertainty assessment. We conclude with the Supramolecular Chemist’s Pledge as a starting point for considering quality control in determining K values.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2004005
- PAR ID:
- 10550432
- Publisher / Repository:
- Taylor & Francis
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Supramolecular Chemistry
- Volume:
- 34
- Issue:
- 9-10
- ISSN:
- 1061-0278
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 320 to 325
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
The solution phase anion binding behavior of a water-stable bidentate pnictogen bond donor was studied. A modest change in the visible absorption spectrum allowed for the determination of the binding constants. High binding constants were observed with cyanide, cyanate, and acetate, and these were corroborated with density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The receptor could be recovered free from the anion following treatment with methyl triflate, confirming that it remains intact. The tight binding of cyanide and water stability were exploited to use this system as a supramolecular catalyst in a phase-transfer Strecker reaction, further demonstrating the utility of pnictogen bonding as a tool in noncovalent catalysis.more » « less
-
Synthetic supramolecular receptors have been widely used to study reversible solution binding of anions; however, few systems target highly-reactive species. In particular, the hydrochalcogenide anions hydrosulfide (HS − ) and hydroselenide (HSe − ) have been largely overlooked despite their critical roles in biological systems. Herein we present the first example of reversible HSe − binding in two distinct synthetic supramolecular receptors, using hydrogen bonds from N–H and aromatic C–H moieties. The arylethynyl bisurea scaffold 1tBu achieved a binding affinity of 460 ± 50 M −1 for HSe − in 10% DMSO- d 6 /CD 3 CN, whereas the tripodal-based receptor 2CF3 achieved a binding affinity of 290 ± 50 M −1 in CD 3 CN. Association constants were also measured for HS − , Cl − , and Br − , and both receptors favored binding of smaller, more basic anions. These studies contribute to a better understanding of chalcogenide hydrogen bonding and provide insights into further development of probes for the reversible binding, and potential quantification, of HSe − and HS − .more » « less
-
EmrE is anEscherichia colimultidrug efflux pump and member of the small multidrug resistance (SMR) family that transports drugs as a homodimer by harnessing energy from the proton motive force. SMR family transporters contain a conserved glutamate residue in transmembrane 1 (Glu14 in EmrE) that is required for binding protons and drugs. Yet the mechanism underlying proton-coupled transport by the two glutamate residues in the dimer remains unresolved. Here, we used NMR spectroscopy to determine acid dissociation constants (pKa) for wild-type EmrE and heterodimers containing one or two Glu14 residues in the dimer. For wild-type EmrE, we measured chemical shifts of the carboxyl side chain of Glu14 using solid-state NMR in lipid bilayers and obtained unambiguous evidence on the existence of asymmetric protonation states. Subsequent measurements of pKavalues for heterodimers with a single Glu14 residue showed no significant differences from heterodimers with two Glu14 residues, supporting a model where the two Glu14 residues have independent pKavalues and are not electrostatically coupled. These insights support a transport pathway with well-defined protonation states in each monomer of the dimer, including a preferred cytoplasmic-facing state where Glu14 is deprotonated in monomer A and protonated in monomer B under pH conditions in the cytoplasm ofE. coli. Our findings also lead to a model, hop-free exchange, which proposes how exchangers with conformation-dependent pKavalues reduce proton leakage. This model is relevant to the SMR family and transporters comprised of inverted repeat domains.more » « less
-
Abstract To implement equilibrium hard‐modeling of spectroscopic titration data, the analyst must make a variety of crucial data processing choices that address negative absorbance and molar absorptivity values. The efficacy of three such methodological options is evaluated via high‐throughput Monte Carlo simulations, root‐mean‐square error surface mapping, and two mathematical theorems. Accuracy of the calculated binding constant values constitutes the key figure of merit used to compare different data analysis approaches. First, using singular value decomposition to filter the raw absorbance data prior to modeling often reduces the number of negative values involved but has little effect on the calculated binding constant despite its ability to address spectrometer noise. Second, both truncation of negative molar absorptivity values and the fast nonnegative least squares algorithms are superior to unconstrained regression because they avoid local minima; however, they introduce bias into the calculated binding constants in the presence of negative baseline offsets. Finally, we establish two theorems showing that negative values are best addressed when all the chemical solutions leading to the raw absorbance data are the result of mixing exactly two distinct stock solutions. This allows the raw absorbance data to be shifted up, eliminating negative baseline offsets, without affecting the concentration matrix, residual matrix, or calculated binding constants. Otherwise, the data cannot be safely upshifted. A comprehensive protocol for analyzing experimental absorbance datasets with is included.more » « less
An official website of the United States government

