An official website of the United States government
Lacustrine halite deposits have long been utilized for interrogating past climate conditions. In particular, microthermometry performed on fluid inclusions in halite crystals has been used to interpret lake water temperatures from ancient deposits. One notable obstacle in performing microthermometry in halite fluid inclusions is the lack of a vapour bubble in the single-phase liquid brine. Isochoric cooling of the inclusions to high negative pressures far below the homogenization temperature has commonly been used to provoke spontaneous vapor bubble nucleation in the metastable liquid. In a host minerals like halite, however, internal tensile stress may result in plastic deformation of the inclusion walls and typically a wide scatter of measured homogenization temperatures. Nucleation-assisted microthermometry, in contrast, employs single ultra-short laser pulses provided by a femtosecond laser to stimulate vapour bubble nucleation in metastable single-phase liquid inclusions slightly below the expected homogenization temperature. This technique allows for repeated vapour bubble nucleation in fluid inclusions without damaging the inclusion walls, yielding highly precise and accurate paleotemperatures from halite fluid inclusions. Moreover, the highly selective nature of nucleation-assisted microthermometry allows for a higher degree of quality control compared to the previous standard method. In this study, we tested the precision and accuracy of nucleation-assisted microthermometry for use in paleoclimate reconstruction utilizing modern halites precipitated in the laboratory under controlled and monitored conditions, Pleistocene halite samples from Death Valley, and varved halites precipitated in the 1980s in the Dead Sea.
more »
« less
Nucleation-assisted microthermometry: A novel application to fluid inclusions in halite
Halite deposits have long been utilized for interrogating past climate conditions. Microthermometry on halite fluid inclusions has been used to determine ancient water temperatures. One notable obstacle in performing microthermometric measurements, however, is the lack of a vapor bubble in the single-phase liquid inclusions at room temperature. (Pseudo-) isochoric cooling of the inclusions to high negative pressures, far below the homogenization temperature, has commonly been needed to provoke spontaneous vapor bubble nucleation in the liquid. High internal tensile stress in soft host minerals like halite, however, may induce plastic deformation of the inclusion walls, resulting in a wide scatter of measured homogenization temperatures. Nucleation-assisted (NA) microthermometry, in contrast, employs single ultra-short laser pulses provided by a femtosecond laser to stimulate vapor bubble nucleation in metastable liquid inclusions slightly below the expected homogenization temperature. This technique allows for repeated vapor bubble nucleation in selected fluid inclusions without affecting the volumetric properties of the inclusions, and yields highly precise and accurate homogenization temperatures. In this study, we apply, for the first time, NA microthermometry to fluid inclusions in halite and we evaluatethe precision and accuracy of this thermometer utilizing (i) synthetic halite crystals precipitated under controlled laboratory conditions, (ii) modern natural halite that precipitated in the 1980s in the Dead Sea, and (iii) Late Pleistocene halite samples from a sediment core from Death Valley, CA. Our results demonstrate an unprecedented accuracy and precision of the method that provides a new opportunity to reconstruct reliable quantitative temperature records from evaporite archives.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1812741
- PAR ID:
- 10554056
- Publisher / Repository:
- Chemical Geology
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Chemical Geology
- Volume:
- 667
- Issue:
- C
- ISSN:
- 0009-2541
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 122318
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- Geochemistry Aqueous geochemistry Paleothermometry Paleolimnology Lakes Evaporites Halite Fluid inclusions Microthermometry Salt Dead Sea Death Valley Chemical sediments Sedimentology Paleoclimate Paleoclimate proxies
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Femtosecond lasers, fired in short pulses, can induce bubble cavitation in single-phase liquid fluid inclusions at temperatures near the inclusion homogenization temperature. By coupling femtosecond laser-induced cavitation with microthermometry, paleotemperatures can be extracted from fluid inclusions in primary halite crystals. This technique minimizes plastic deformation of halite by not subjecting samples to extreme temperatures during vapor bubble nucleation. The resultant homogenization temperatures are precise and reproducible. We applied this technique to Eocene Green River Formation primary bottom-growth halites from the Piceance Creek Basin in Colorado. Samples from the basin-center Savage 24-1 core yield average bottom water temperatures of 27.0 ± 1.3 ºC and 20.1 ± 1.2 ºC for the Upper and Lower Salt intervals, respectively. Average bottom water temperatures from modern perennial hypersaline lakes have been shown to reflect the local mean annual air temperature. Therefore, homogenization temperatures from primary bottom-growth halite fluid inclusions are a proxy for mean annual air temperature. These results agree with regional Early Eocene mean annual air temperature estimate ranges from other mineralogical and biochemical proxies, bolstering the reliability of temperature estimates obtained using this technique. Additionally, the highly selective nature of laser induced cavitation microthermometry allows for a higher degree of quality control compared to standard microthermometry, yielding more reproducible and precise results.more » « less
-
Lacustrine evaporites have potential to document ancient terrestrial climates, including temperatures and their seasonal variations, and atmospheric pCO2. The sodium carbonate mineral nahcolite (NaHCO3) in the early Eocene Parachute Creek Member, Green River Formation, Piceance subbasin, indicates elevated pCO2 concentrations (> 680 ppm) in the water column and in the atmosphere if in contact with brine. These data support a causal connection between elevated atmospheric pCO2 and global warmth during the early Eocene Climatic Optimum. Trona (Na2CO3⋅NaHCO3⋅2H2O), not nahcolite, is the dominant sodium carbonate mineral in the coeval Wilkins Peak Member in the Bridger subbasin, which may be explained by interbasin variations in (1) brine chemistry, (2) temperature, and (3) pCO2. These interpretations are based on equilibrium thermodynamics and simulations that evaporate lake water, but they ignore seasonal changes in water column temperature and pCO2. Winter cooling, rather than evaporative concentration, best explains the fine-scale alternations of nahcolite, halite (NaCl), and nahcolite + halite in the Parachute Creek Member. Simulated evaporation of alkaline source waters from the paleo Aspen River at temperatures between 15⁰ and 27⁰ C and pCO2 at or below 1200 ppm produces the observed mineral sequence in the Wilkins Peak Member: gaylussite (Na2CO3⋅CaCO3⋅5H2O) at temperatures < 27⁰ C and pirssonite (Na2CO3⋅CaCO3⋅2H2O) > 27⁰ C (both now replaced by shortite Na2CO3·2CaCO3), then northupite (Na3Mg(CO3)2Cl), trona, and halite. The challenge of determining paleo-lake temperatures in the Bridger and Piceance subbasins using microthermometry has now been solved using femtosecond lasers that promote nucleation of vapor bubbles in brine inclusions without deforming the halite host crystal. This method shows general agreement with thermodynamic-based calculations and will be used to document mean annual temperatures in the Greater Green River Basin.more » « less
-
Abstract Bubble nucleation was investigated in a 20-mm-long, wickless heat pipe on the International Space Station. Over 20 h of running experiments using pentane as the working fluid, more than 100 nucleation events were observed. Bubble nucleation at the heater end temporarily boosted peak pressures and vapor temperatures in the device. At the moment of nucleation, the heater wall temperature significantly decreased due to increased evaporation and the original vapor bubble collapsed due to increased pressure. A thermal model was developed and using the measured temperatures and pressures, heat transfer coefficients near the heater end of the system were extracted. Peak heat transfer coefficients during the nucleation event were over a factor of three higher than at steady-state. The heat transfer coefficient data were all collapsed in the form of a single, linear correlation relating the Nusselt number to the Ohnesorge number.more » « less
-
Abstract The application of melt inclusions (MI) to infer magmatic processes assumes the MI have remained as constant mass, constant volume systems since the time of trapping. Understanding the effects of both compositional and volumetric re‐equilibration is key for the interpretation of MI data. Although the re‐equilibration behavior MI in quartz and olivine has been studied in some detail, the process is less understood for other MI host phases such as plagioclase, a common phase in igneous rocks. A MI can re‐equilibrate when it experiences pressure and temperature (PT) conditions that differ from formation PT conditions. During laboratory heating, irreversible MI expansion may occur. As a result, the internal pressure within the MI decreases, resulting in chemical and structural changes to the MI and host. We present results of heating experiments on plagioclase‐hosted MI designed to induce volumetric re‐equilibration. The experiments consisted of incrementally heating the MI to temperatures above the homogenization temperatures. At ∼40°C above, the temperature at which the daughter minerals melted, irreversible volume expansion lowered the pressure in the MI, and led to exsolution of CO2into vapor bubbles. With each additional few degrees of heating, additional episodes of CO2exsolution, bubble nucleation and expansion of the vapor bubblesoccurred. Re‐equilibration of MI in plagioclase occurred through a combination of ductile and brittle deformation of the host surrounding the MI, whereas previous studies have shown that MI in olivine re‐equilibrate dominantly through ductile deformation associated with movement along dislocations. This behavior is consistent with the differing rheological properties of these phases.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemgeo.2024.122318
