An official website of the United States government
Real-time hybrid simulation (RTHS) divides a structural system into analytical and experimental substructures that are coupled through their common degrees of freedom. This paper introduces a framework to enable RTHS to be performed on 3D nonlinear models of tall buildings with rate dependent nonlinear response modification devices, where the structure is subjected to multi-directional wind and earthquake natural hazards. A 40-story tall building prototype with damped outriggers is selected as a case study. The analytical substructure for the RTHS consists of a 3-D nonlinear model of the structure, where each member in the building is discretely modeled in conjunction with the use of a super element. The experimental substructure for the RTHS consists of a full-scale rate-dependent nonlinear viscous damper that is physically tested in the lab, with the remaining dampers in the outrigger system modeled analytically. The analytically modeled dampers use a stable explicit non-iterative element with an online model updating algorithm, by which the covariance matrix of the damper model’s state variables does not become ill-conditioned. The damper model parameters can thereby be updated in real-time using measured data from the experimental substructure. The explicit MKR-α method is optimized and used in conjunction with the super element to efficiently integrate the condensed equations of motion of a large complex model having more than 1000 nonlinear elements, thus enabling multi-axis earthquake and wind hybrid nonlinear simulations to be performed in real-time. An adaptive servo-hydraulic actuator control scheme is used to enable precise real-time actuator displacements in the experimental substructure to be achieved that match the target displacements during a RTHS. The IT real-time architecture for integrating the components of the framework is described. To assess the framework, 3D RTHS of the 40-story structure were performed involving multi-axis translational and torsional response to multi-directional earthquake and wind natural hazards. The RTHS technique was applied to perform half-power tests to experimentally determine the amount of supplemental damping provided by the damped outrigger system for translational and torsional modes of vibration of the building. The results from the study presented herein demonstrate that RTHS can be applied to large nonlinear large structural systems involving multi-axis response to multi-directional excitation.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on December 1, 2025
Real‐time hybrid simulation of structural systems with soil‐foundation interaction effects using neural networks
Abstract Real‐time hybrid simulation (RTHS) involves dividing a structural system into numerical and experimental substructures. The experimental substructure is challenging to model analytically and is therefore modeled physically in the laboratory. Analytical substructures are conventionally modeled using the finite element method. The two substructures are kinematically linked, and the governing equations of motion are solved in real‐time. Thus, the state determination of the analytical substructure needs to occur within the timestep, which is of the order of a few milliseconds. All structural systems are supported by a soil‐foundation system and any evaluation of the efficacy of response modification devices placed in the structure should consider soil‐foundation structure interaction (SFSI) effects. SFSI adds compliance to a structural system, thereby altering the natural frequencies. Additionally, nonlinear behavior in the soil can result in residual deformations in the foundation and structure, as well as provide added damping. These effects can occur under both wind and earthquake loading. To overcome the barrier of the large computational effort required to model SFSI effects in real‐time using the conventional finite element approach, a neural network (NN) model is combined with an explicit‐based analytical substructure and experimental substructure with dampers to create a framework for performing RTHS with SFSI effects. The framework includes a block of long‐short term memory (LSTM) layers that is combined with a parallel rectified linear unit (ReLU) to form a NN model of the soil‐foundation system. RTHS of a tall 40‐story steel building equipped with nonlinear viscous dampers and subjected to a windstorm are performed to illustrate the framework. It was found that a number of factors have an effect on the quality of RTHS results. These include: (i) the discretization of the wind loading into bins of basic wind speed; (ii) the extent of the NN model training as determined by the root mean square error (RMSE); (iii) noise in the restoring forces produced by the NN model and its interaction with the integration algorithm; and, (iv) the bounding of outliers of the NN model's output. Guidelines for extending the framework for the RTHS of structures subjected to seismic loading are provided.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2037771
- PAR ID:
- 10562127
- Publisher / Repository:
- Wiley
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics
- Volume:
- 53
- Issue:
- 15
- ISSN:
- 0098-8847
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 4688 to 4718
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Yang, J (Ed.)Real-time Hybrid Simulation (RTHS) is a technique wherein a structural system is divided into an analytical and an experimental substructure. The former is modeled numerically while the latter is physically present in the laboratory. The two substructures are kinematically linked together at their interface degrees of freedom (DOFs) and the equations of motion are solved in real-time to determine the structure’s response. One of the main challenges of RTHS is to include the effects of soil–foundation–structure interaction (SFSI), which can have a substantial effect on the overall response. The soil domain cannot be modeled experimentally due to the large payload size. On the other hand, modeling the soil domain numerically, using a continuum-based approach, in real-time is challenging due to the associated computational cost. To address these issues, this paper presents a framework for seismic RTHS of SFSI systems using a Neural Network (NN)-based macroelement model of the soil–foundation system. A coupled SFSI model is used to train the NN model and the loss function is based on dynamic equilibrium at the interface between the foundation and the structure. The framework is demonstrated using a three-story building with the lateral load resisting system comprised of moment resisting and damped brace frames. The proposed framework ensures a stable and accurate RTHS, accounting for SFSI by incorporating: (a) spring elements at the output DOFs of the NN model to remove rigid body modes; (b) dashpot elements at the output DOFs of the NN model to mitigate spurious higher frequencies of vibration; and (c) regularization in the NN model’s architecture with data augmentation to reduce overfitting.more » « less
-
Large-scale multi-directional real-time hybrid simulations (RTHS) are used to assess the maximum considered earthquake (MCE) seismic performance of a 40-story steel building equipped with supplemental nonlinear viscous dampers. These dampers are placed between outrigger trusses and the perimeter columns of a building that was part of the inventory for the California Tall Building Initiative (TBI) PEER study. The analytical substructure for the RTHS consists of a 3-D nonlinear model of the building while the experimental substructure consists of a full scale nonlinear viscous damper. Other dampers in the structure are analytically modelled using an online explicit model updating scheme where the physical damper is used to obtain the parameters of the analytical damper models during the RTHS. The displacement, residual drift, and ductility demand are found to be reduced by adding the dampers to the outrigger, but only in the direction of the plane of the outriggers. Higher modes, including torsional modes, contribute to the 3-D seismic response.more » « less
-
Protecting both the essential building contents and the structural system—as well as facilitating and accelerating the post-event functionality of business operations—is a major concern during natural hazards. Floor isolation systems (FIS) with rolling pendulum bearings along with nonlinear fluid viscous dampers (NFVD) have been proposed to mitigate damage and enhance the resiliency of non-structural and structural systems, respectively. These devices are designed to decrease vibrations under dynamic loading conditions. In this poster, we introduce research using tridimensional nonlinear cyber-physical experimental testing (i.e., real-time hybrid simulations) to validate the performance of these response modification devices placed in structural systems under wind and earthquake loading conditions. The effects of soil-structure-foundation and fluid-structure interactions were also accounted for. The novelty of the project is the use of multi-directional large-scale real-time hybrid simulations of complex nonlinear systems under wind and earthquake demands to combine experimental structural modification passive devices with analytical multi-story buildings considering soil-foundation interaction via neural network. Results show that the FIS and NFVD can significantly reduce the demand on non-structural and structural systems of buildings subjected to natural hazards whose response can be also significantly affected by soil-foundation-structure interaction. A product of this research is the data (which is linked in Related Works), which can be used to compare with new studies using the same experimental techniques and structural modification devices or with alternative approaches. Researchers interested in multi-natural hazards resilience and mitigation, state-of-the-art structural experimental techniques, and the use of machine learning as a tool to improve modeling efficiency will benefit from its results. Also, companies dedicated to the commercial development of structural response modification devices, as well as policymakers working or with interest in economic and social resilience.more » « less
-
Recent earthquakes in many parts of the world have resulted in damage to the civil infrastructure, resulting in fatalities and economic loss. This experience has resulted in stake holders demanding a more resilient infrastructure and the mitigation of earthquake hazards to minimize their impact on society. Researchers have developed concepts for structural steel systems to promote resilient performance. Real-time hybrid simulation (RTHS) provides an experimental technique to meet the need to validate new concepts. RTHS enables a complete structural system, including the soil and foundation to be considered in a simulation, interaction effects and rate dependency in component and system response to be accounted for, and realistic demand imposed onto the system for prescribed hazard levels. This paper presents the concept of RTHS and developments achieved at the Lehigh NHERI Experimental Facility that have advanced RTHS to enable accurate large-scale, multidirectional simulations involving multi-natural hazards to be performed. The role that hybrid simulation has played in these developments and how its use has enabled a deeper understanding of structural system behavior under seismic and wind loading will be discussed. Examples include self-centering steel moment resisting frame systems, braced frame systems with nonlinear viscous, and tall buildings with outriggers that are outfitted with nonlinear viscous.more » « less
