An official website of the United States government
Students in Appalachia have a heritage of problem-solving. We explore how computational thinking (CT) relates to and complements this heritage by analyzing 34 local ingenuity stories, and perspectives from 35 community members about the relevance of CT. We found the two problem-solving approaches are meaningfully different, but can be used in concert. Since equating them could contribute to confusion and cultural erasure, researchers and educators bringing CT as a problem solving strategy into rural and other resourceful cultures must clarify what they mean by “CT helps problem solving.” In these cultures, CT skills are better introduced as new tools to expand students’ problem-solving toolkits, rather than tools that are identical to or better than those traditionally used in their culture.
more »
« less
Community healing in Appalachia: Narrative development through K-8 CT/STEAM initiatives in Eastern Kentucky
The NSF-funded “Tough as Nails, Nimble Fingers: Developing a K-8 Coding Pathway for Kentucky Appalachia” project, might have been an education initiative where “experts” flew in from cities, taught the latest trends in science, technology, engineering, art and mathematics (STEAM) education, and called it a success. It also could have been a project that dissipated under the pressures and limitations of the COVID-19 pandemic. Instead, our K-8 computational thinking (CT) and STEAM education initiative in Kentucky Appalachia, which began in fall 2019, has turned into a vehicle of community collaboration and healing, owned and co-operated by community members. This paper focuses on how the teacher training evolved over time to promote narrative development and healing. The economic hardship and correlative social fracturing, from which Eastern Kentucky wishes to heal, is not obvious from a casual visit to their beautiful mountain community. We rarely speak about it in project-related meetings, even four years into a trusted partnership. Illustratively articulated in Appalachian Ingenuity (Bit Source, 2018) and elsewhere (Keefe, 2005), the struggle is of a longstanding nature, largely stemming from the collapse of the coal mining industry, associated with losses of well-paying jobs, friends and family leaving the area in droves, and mental health issues related to perceived hopelessness and loss of dignity. This is atop at least six decades of struggle to combat negative stereotypes about the region, perpetuated by politicians and media (Bowler 1985; Newman, 2019). Our very first summer teacher training (2020) was focused on teaching introductory CT and broader STEAM lessons, and garnering teacher buy-in and enthusiasm, especially with a pivot to an online format due to the pandemic. The positive participant evaluations gave us confidence that the teachers would benefit from knowing how their CT lessons can contribute beyond their classroom, to the healing and empowerment of the greater community. Therefore, for summer 2021, we dedicated a day for reflection and celebration (“Inspire Friday”), and included a panel discussion by local workforce representatives to convey three important points: (1) there is a lot of ingenuity among Appalachian people (and CT overlaps with this), (2) it is important to share stories of success and hope, (3) educators play an essential role in community revitalization. The appreciation that the teachers expressed about this workforce panel was very positive (e.g., “I truly loved this portion of this week. It allowed us to evaluate how education is an important piece of the larger work that is going on in our region.”) that it emboldened us to further revise the training for 2022. We had daily “Inspire talks” representing multiple local industries (e.g., telecommunications, music), that exemplified Appalachian ingenuity and emphasized the importance of CT competencies. We also added leadership training (e.g., storytelling and “what is CT?”) that provided frameworks for educators to become agents of change beyond their classroom. We also arranged a field trip to a local software development company, where teachers interacted with staff (former coal miners) about skills they look for in employees. The evaluations and subsequent conversations with educators strongly suggested that the workshop contributed to healing, hope and a new culturally responsive vision for CT education in Appalachia.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1923314
- PAR ID:
- 10568305
- Publisher / Repository:
- Digital Promise
- Date Published:
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
null (Ed.)Through school-university partnerships that situate learning within culturally relevant educational experiences, faculty, preservice teachers, and school-based educators are able to co-construct and share scientific knowledge. This knowledge consists of pedagogical content knowledge and funds of knowledge that include both knowledge and skills developed in cultural context that have evolved historically. In early childhood education, culturally relevant Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts, and Mathematics (STEAM) learning experiences are particularly important for young children's cognitive and social emotional development. This paper describes how intentional co-planning and collaboration to celebrate the US Read across America Day provided over 100 preschool children in eight classrooms with access to STEAM lessons virtually led by university preservice teachers in partnership with educators in the school. These activities engaged children in exploring art, computer science, physical science, engineering, and mathematics within the context of a culturally relevant version of the fairy tale Goldilocks and the Three Bears. Lessons implemented as part of school-university partnerships support Black and Latinx children's development of a sense of belonging in STEAM. Further, these experiences enhance teacher candidates' abilities to engage in culturally responsive STEAM teaching while receiving ongoing guidance and education from university faculty and school-based educators. Teacher education programs within higher education institutions should embrace school- university partnerships as contexts for the development of shared scientific knowledge and discourse since the benefits are twofold. First, children and teachers gain access to, and engage with, innovative STEAM experiences. Second, preservice teachers learn culturally relevant research-based instructional strategies through university coursework situated in authentic learning experiences; thus, their learning as teacher candidates is enhanced through planning, implementation, evaluation, and critical reflection.more » « less
-
For many rural teachers and students, the notion of “computational thinking” sounds like a novelty and nice-to-have from far away cities, rather than an essential competency relevant to their local context. However, two Appalachian school districts, in a research practice partnership, have begun to look for connections between rural heritage stories and computational thinking, to help students grow as community problem solvers. The team has collected several local “ingenuity stories” and began to analyze what the local flavor of ingenuity is, and direct tie-ins to computational thinking. The stories have been inspiring, but it takes some thoughtful interviewing to identify the exact connections to computational thinking. Come hear about the first round of research findings, and think with us about ways to move forward so we can ground computing education in local rural contexts.more » « less
-
In this presentation, Emi Iwatani shares how the "Tough As Nails, Nimble Fingers: Developing a K-8 Coding Pathway for Kentucky Appalachia" was conceptualized to explore the idea of "cultural fit" of computational thinking and computer science education in Eastern Kentucky. It also shares project activities and findings related to that topic, and comments on the potential relevance of Emi's personal cultural (Japanese) background to project conception and execution.more » « less
-
Gresalfi, M. and (Ed.)The importance of integrating computational thinking (CT) into existing school structures, like core content domains, has emerged from efforts to improve computer science education in the U.S. In the past, computer science has often been treated as an elective or enrichment activity, which limits students’ exposure to foundational computing ideas, especially in underserved schools. However, given the ubiquity technology plays in our lives, it is imperative that all students have access to CT. Few studies have focused on how pre-service teachers (PSTs) learn about CT. Some researchers argue that CT integration into K-12 education belongs in teacher preparation programs and that teacher educators should develop courses aimed at supporting PSTs’ understanding of CT in the context of schools. This paper explores the ways in which PSTs begin to understand CT and how they work to integrate CT into their core subject areas.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- The DOI is not currently available.
