An official website of the United States government
Abstract This study implemented and evaluated a prediction-driven nurse staffing framework in a large adult emergency department. The framework leveraged a two-stage prediction model that forecasted patient volume and guided staffing decisions. Using a pre-post study design, we compared patient throughput (measured by door-to-evaluation time, active treatment time, boarding time, length of stay, and left-without-being-seen rate) and cost outcomes (measured as hourly nurse staffing costs) before and after implementation. The model achieved an RMSE of 11.261 and MAPE of 13.414% at the base stage, and an RMSE of 9.973 and MAPE of 12.126% at the surge stage. The framework reduced hourly staffing costs by $162.04 without negatively affecting throughput. Reducing one nurse per hour from the recommended level increased wait times by two minutes, with an additional 2.3-min increase when staffing dropped below 20% of recommendations. These findings highlight the potential of prediction-driven staffing to reduce costs while maintaining patient throughput.
more »
« less
Prediction-Driven Surge Planning with Application to Emergency Department Nurse Staffing
Determining emergency department (ED) nurse staffing decisions to balance quality of service and staffing costs can be extremely challenging, especially when there is a high level of uncertainty in patient demand. Increasing data availability and continuing advancements in predictive analytics provide an opportunity to mitigate demand uncertainty by using demand forecasts. In this work, we study a two-stage prediction-driven staffing framework where the prediction models are integrated with the base (made weeks in advance) and surge (made nearly real-time) nurse staffing decisions in the ED. We quantify the benefit of having the ability to use the more expensive surge staffing and identify the importance of balancing demand uncertainty versus system stochasticity. We also propose a near-optimal two-stage staffing policy that is straightforward to interpret and implement. Last, we develop a unified framework that combines parameter estimation, real-time demand forecasts, and nurse staffing in the ED. High-fidelity simulation experiments for the ED demonstrate that the proposed framework has the potential to reduce annual staffing costs by 10%–16% ($2 M–$3 M) while guaranteeing timely access to care. This paper was accepted by David Simchi-Levi, healthcare management. Funding: J. Dong was partially supported by the Division of Civil, Mechanical and Manufacturing Innovation [Grant CMMI-1944209]. Supplemental Material: The data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2021.02781 .
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1944209
- PAR ID:
- 10574554
- Publisher / Repository:
- INFORMS
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Management Science
- ISSN:
- 0025-1909
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
When having access to demand forecasts, a crucial question is how to effectively use this information to make better resource allocation decisions, especially during demand surges like the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite the emergence of various advanced prediction models for hospital resources, there has been a lack of prescriptive solutions for hospital managers seeking concrete decision support, for example, guidance on whether to allocate beds from other specialties to meet the surge demand from COVID-19 patients by postponing elective surgeries. In their paper “Optimal Routing under Demand Surge: the Value of Future Arrival Rate,” the authors present a systematic framework to incorporate future demand into routing decisions in parallel server systems with partial flexibility and quantify the benefits of doing so. They propose a simple and interpretable two-stage index-based policy that explicitly incorporates demand forecasts into real-time routing decisions. Their analytical and numerical results demonstrate the policy’s effectiveness, even in the presence of large prediction errors.more » « less
-
Nursing homes (NHs) are critical facilities for caring frail older adults with around-the-clock formal care and personal assistance. To ensure quality of care for NH residents, an adequate staffing level is of great importance. Current NH staffing practice is mainly based on experience and regulation. The objective of this paper is to investigate the viability of experience-based and regulation-based strategies, as well as alternative staffing strategies to meet the heterogeneous service demand of NH residents at reduced labor cost under various scenarios of census compositions. We propose a predictive analytics integrated computer simulation model to characterize the heterogeneous service demand of NH residents, and further evaluate and identify promising staffing strategies at the facility level. Specifically, we propose a predictive model based on latent survival analysis to characterize diverse length-of-stay (LOS) with multiple discharge dispositions among NH residents. Further, we develop a simulation model with the incorporation of predictive analytics and domain knowledge to characterize the heterogeneous service demand of NH residents on different types of caregivers over time. Based on the simulation model, we develop a graphical user interface for the simulator to evaluate different staffing strategies at the facility level and inform NH administrators about promising strategies. We use real NH data to validate the proposed model and demonstrate its effectiveness. The proposed predictive LOS model considering multiple discharge dispositions exhibits superior prediction performance and offers better staffing decisions at reduced costs than those without the consideration. With the improved modeling fidelity via integrating predictive analytics with computer simulation, the proposed model is flexible to evaluate various staffing strategies using total labor cost as a performance metric, and can identify promising staffing strategies to meet the service demand of NH residents. Promising staffing strategies with the suggested staff-to-resident (SR) ratio can significantly reduce the total labor cost of multiple types of caregivers, as compared to the benchmark strategies, such as the SR ratios based on industrial practice or minimum requirement of state regulation. Moreover, we construct multiple scenarios of different census compositions of NH residents to demonstrate the capability of the proposed model. Our proposed model can facilitate NH staffing decision making to meet the heterogeneous service demand of NH residents at reduced labor costs.more » « less
-
Wastewater treatment plants are large, energy-intensive loads that can be optimally controlled to support grid reliability and reduce operational costs. This paper presents a multi-stage robust optimization framework to control a wastewater treatment plant equipped with a biogas generator and storage tank for participation in California’s day-ahead and real-time frequency regulation markets while managing biogas production and regulation signal uncertainty. We solve for day-ahead regulation capacity in the first stage and real-time regulation capacity over the day as the uncertainty is progressively revealed. We propose affine control policies to determine the real-time regulation capacity based on partial uncertainty realizations. This results in a tractable affinely adjustable robust counterpart. In a case study, we evaluate our proposed approach against a day-ahead-only robust formulation and found that our approach increases regulation capacity provision and lowers operational costs.more » « less
-
This work considers the incorporation of renewable ammonia manufacturing sites into existing ammonia supply chain networks while accounting for ammonia price uncertainty from existing producers. We propose a two-stage stochastic programming approach to determine the optimal investment decisions such that the ammonia demand is satisfied and the net present cost is minimized. We apply the proposed approach to a case study considering deploying in-state renewable ammonia manufacturing in Minnesota’s supply chain network. We find that accounting for price uncertainty leads to supply chains with more ammonia demand met via renewable production and thus lower costs from importing ammonia from existing producers. These results show that the in-state renewable production of ammonia can act as a hedge against the volatility of the conventional ammonia market.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2021.02781
