skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


Title: Fitness differences override variation‐dependent coexistence mechanisms in California grasslands
Abstract While most studies of species coexistence focus on the mechanisms that maintain coexistence, it is equally important to understand the mechanisms that structure failed coexistence. For example, California annual grasslands are heavily invaded ecosystems, where non‐native annuals have largely dominated and replaced native communities. These systems are also highly variable, with a high degree of rainfall seasonality and interannual rainfall variability—a quality implicated in the coexistence of functionally distinct species. Yet, despite the apparent strength of this variation, coexistence between native and non‐native annuals in this system has faltered.To test how variation‐dependent coexistence mechanisms modulate failed coexistence, we implemented a competition experiment between two previously common native forbs and three now‐dominant non‐native annual grasses spanning a conservative‐acquisitive range of traits. We grew individuals from each species under varying densities of all other species as competitors, under either wetter or drier early season rainfall treatments. Using subsequent seed production, we parameterized competition models, assessed the potential for coexistence among species pairs and quantified the relative influence of variation‐dependent coexistence mechanisms.As expected, we found little potential for coexistence. Competition was dominated by the non‐native grassAvena fatua, while native forbs were unable to invade non‐native grasses. Mutual competitive exclusion was common across almost all species and often contingent on rainfall, suggesting rainfall‐mediated priority effects. Among variation‐dependent mechanisms, the temporal storage effect had a moderate stabilizing effect for four of five species when averaged across competitors, while relative nonlinearity in competition was largely destabilizing, except for the most conservative non‐native grass, which benefited from a competitive release under dry conditions.Synthesis: Our findings suggest that rainfall variability does little to mitigate the fitness differences that underlie widespread annual grass invasion in California, but that it influences coexistence dynamics among the now‐dominant non‐native grasses.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2047239
PAR ID:
10586254
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Journal of Ecology
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Ecology
Volume:
113
Issue:
1
ISSN:
0022-0477
Page Range / eLocation ID:
194 to 205
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; ; ; (, Ecology)
    Abstract Reordering of abundances among species is a common response in communities whether affected by anthropogenic drivers or natural disturbance. However, understanding how competitive relationships drive community dynamics under global environmental change remains limited, primarily due to uncertainties related to changes in species interactions and the scarcity of long‐term observations. By combining long‐term data and time series analysis tools, we quantified the compositional dynamics and causal interactions among functional groups of an arid grassland community under chronic nutrient enrichment for 15 years following wildfire. We hypothesized that chronic nutrient addition would promote species reordering among dominant grasses and subordinate annual forbs after wildfire, thereby increasing biomass and compositional variation over the long term. Contrary to expectations, while the abundance of the dominant grassBouteloua eriopoda(black grama) declined immediately after the wildfire, the increase in annual forbs under N addition did not occur until a decade later. Convergent cross‐mapping revealed that annuals were causally influenced by black grama abundance and maintained relatively lower abundance in control plots. However, with N addition, this causal interaction from black grama to annuals disappeared. Accordingly, temporal variability of biomass and community composition increased as the abundance of annuals rose. Combined with evidence of precipitation response, these results imply that the competitive advantage of perennial plants over annual forbs could serve as a stabilizing mechanism for community variability by limiting the response of annuals to precipitation fluctuations. However, this stabilizing process is disrupted by the cumulative effects of chronic nitrogen addition. This long‐term experiment provides new insights into the destabilizing effects of community reordering, without changes in species richness, in response to anthropogenic nutrient loading. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; (, Journal of Ecology)
    Abstract Plant‐microbial‐herbivore interactions play a crucial role in the structuring and maintenance of plant communities and biodiversity, yet these relationships are complex. In grassland ecosystems, herbivores have the potential to greatly influence the survival, growth and reproduction of plants. However, few studies examine interactions of above‐ and below‐ground grazing and arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) mycorrhizal symbiosis on plant community structure.We established experimental mesocosms containing an assemblage of eight tallgrass prairie grass and forb species in native prairie soil, maintained under mycorrhizal and nonmycorrhizal conditions, with and without native herbivorous soil nematodes, and with and without grasshopper herbivory. Using factorial analysis of variance and principal component analysis, we examined: (a) the independent and interacting effects of above‐ and below‐ground herbivores on AM symbiosis in tallgrass prairie mesocosms, (b) independent and interacting effects of above‐ and below‐ground herbivores and mycorrhizal fungi on plant community structure and (c) potential influences of mycorrhizal responsiveness of host plants on herbivory tolerance and concomitant shifts in plant community composition.Treatment effects were characterized by interactions between AM fungi and both above‐ground and below‐ground herbivores, while herbivore effects were additive. The dominance of mycorrhizal‐dependent C4grasses in the presence of AM symbiosis was increased (p < 0.0001) by grasshopper herbivory but reduced (p < 0.0001) by nematode herbivory. Cool‐season C3grasses exhibited a competitive release in the absence of AM symbiosis but this effect was largely reversed in the presence of grasshopper herbivory. Forbs showed species‐specific responses to both AM fungal inoculation and the addition of herbivores. Biomass of the grazing‐avoidant, facultatively mycotrophic forbBrickellia eupatorioidesincreased (p < 0.0001) in the absence of AM symbiosis and with grasshopper herbivory, while AM‐related increases in the above‐ground biomass of mycorrhizal‐dependent forbsRudbeckia hirtaandSalvia azureawere eradicated (p < 0.0001) by grasshopper herbivory. In contrast, nematode herbivory enhanced (p = 0.001) the contribution ofSalvia azureato total biomass.Synthesis. Our research indicates that arbuscular mycorrhizal symbiosis is the key driver of dominance of C4grasses in the tallgrass prairie, with foliar and root herbivory being two mechanisms for maintenance of plant diversity. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (, New Phytologist)
    Summary Evolutionary history plays a key role driving patterns of trait variation across plant species. For scaling and modeling purposes, grass species are typically organized into C3vs C4plant functional types (PFTs). Plant functional type groupings may obscure important functional differences among species. Rather, grouping grasses by evolutionary lineage may better represent grass functional diversity.We measured 11 structural and physiological traitsin situfrom 75 grass species within the North American tallgrass prairie. We tested whether traits differed significantly among photosynthetic pathways or lineages (tribe) in annual and perennial grass species.Critically, we found evidence that grass traits varied among lineages, including independent origins of C4photosynthesis. Using a rigorous model selection approach, tribe was included in the top models for five of nine traits for perennial species. Tribes were separable in a multivariate and phylogenetically controlled analysis of traits, owing to coordination of important structural and ecophysiological characteristics.Our findings suggest grouping grass species by photosynthetic pathway overlooks variation in several functional traits, particularly for C4species. These results indicate that further assessment of lineage‐based differences at other sites and across other grass species distributions may improve representation of C4species in trait comparison analyses and modeling investigations. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ; (, Journal of Ecology)
    Major theories regarding microbe‐mediated plant community dynamics assume that plant species cultivate distinct microbial communities. However, few studies empirically assess the role of species‐associated microbial community dissimilarity in plant competitive dynamics. In this study, we paired a competition experiment between eight annual forbs with characterisation of species‐associated fungal communities to assess whether mycobiome dissimilarity is associated with pairwise competitive dynamics. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; (, Functional Ecology)
    Abstract Despite multiple ecological and evolutionary hypotheses that predict patterns of phenotypic relationships between plant growth, reproduction and constitutive and/or induced resistance to herbivores, these hypotheses do not make any predictions about the underlying molecular genetic mechanisms that mediate these relationships.We investigated how divergent plant life‐history strategies in the yellow monkeyflower and a life‐history altering locus,DIV1, influence plasticity of phytochemical herbivory resistance traits in response to attack by two herbivore species with different diet breadth.Life‐history strategy (annual vs. perennial) and theDIV1locus significantly influenced levels of constitutive herbivory resistance, as well as resistance induction following both generalist and specialist herbivory. Perennial plants had higher total levels of univariate constitutive and induced defence than annuals, regardless of herbivore type. Annuals induced less in response to generalist herbivory than did perennials, while induction response was equivalent across the ecotypes for specialist herbivory.The effects of theDIV1locus on levels of constitutive and induced defence were dependent on genetic background, the annual versus perennial haplotype ofDIV1and herbivore identity. The patterns of univariate induction due toDIV1were non‐additive and did not always match expectations based on patterns of divergence for annual/perennial parents. For example, perennial plants had higher levels of constitutive and induced defence than did annuals, but when the annualDIV1was present in the perennial genetic background induction response to herbivory was higher than for the perennial parent lines.Patterns for multivariate defence arsenals generally echoed those of univariate, with annual and perennial monkeyflowers and those with alternative versions ofDIV1differing significantly in constitutive and induced resistance. Like univariate resistance, induced multivariate defence arsenals were affected by herbivore identity.Our results highlight the complexity of the genetic mechanisms underlying plastic response to herbivory. While a genetic locus underlying substantial phenotypic variation in life‐history strategy and constitutive defence also influences defence plasticity, the induction response also depends on genetic background. This result demonstrates the potential for some degree of evolutionary independence between constitutive and induced defence, or induced defence and life‐history strategy, in monkeyflowers. Read the freePlain Language Summaryfor this article on the Journal blog. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Text Encoded Conversion
  • XML
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email