An official website of the United States government
Structural engineering is moving towards the design of enhanced performing buildings under earthquake events to improve the resiliency of urban communities. Buckling Restrained Braced Frames (BRBF) have been widely adopted to resist lateral loads. However, typical configurations could be subjected to drift concentration, leading to large story drifts and uneven utilization of the BRBs with building height. Studies have suggested that innovative configurations, such as pivoting or rocking frames, can provide a better distribution of the story drift by delaying or preventing story mechanisms and spreading the energy dissipation to adjacent stories across the building height. These types of bracing configurations utilize as essentially elastic spine, or strongback, to induce a global tilting mode. However, since the spine is designed to remain elastic, additional design considerations are needed to size the elements in strongbacks. This study presents a comparative study between traditional chevron BRBF and strongback BRBF systems for a set of buildings with different heights and tributary areas. Results show that the pivoting and rocking strongback result in reduced the peak story drift with more uniform distribution of drift demands. The cost of these alternatives, per frame, was similar to the chevron BRBF.
more »
« less
Higher-mode response of braced frames with elastic spines subjected to modal pushover analysis
Advancements in seismic hazard mitigation and resilience have spurred the exploration and development of lateral-force resisting systems with enhanced performance goals. In this context, brace frames coupled with elastic spines offer a more uniform drift distribution with building height that reduces the concentration of damage in a few stories and therefore reduces the likelihood of a story mechanism. However, properly sizing the spine, along with selecting and placing the energy dissipators, remains challenging and lacks standardized procedures due to 1) the kinematic and force compatibility between the pivoting spine and the energy dissipators and 2) the near-elastic higher-modes demands that are present in this type of system; both closely governed by the selection of the spine strength and stiffness. This study investigates the nonlinear static response of 8-story Strongback Braced Frames (i.e., brace frames where the elastic spine is composed of a pivoting truss called strongback) using a first and second-mode force pattern. The archetypes have different variations in the implementation of the strongback; e.g., keeping the strongback in a separate bay from the main brace frame or embedding the strongback into the frame. In pushing the archetypes with a first-mode force pattern, the strongback imposes more uniform drifts, without a significant increase in the system’s ultimate capacity. In pushing with a second-mode force pattern, the strongback delays the formation of a mechanism and increases the system’s ultimate capacity to values comparable to expected elastic demands under MCE intensities. The distribution of story shears between the main frame and the strongback is assessed, and the implications of higher-mode demands in sizing the brace and ties of the strongback are highlighted. It is expected that results from this paper may begin to inform future code-based provisions in adopting the use of near-elastic spines in enhanced performance systems.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2309829
- PAR ID:
- 10632048
- Publisher / Repository:
- 18th World Earthquake Engineering Conference (18WCEE)
- Date Published:
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Steel moment-resisting frames (MRFs) are widely used in the United States to resist seismic forces. MRFs have many advantages, including high ductility, architectural versatility, and vetted member and connection detailing requirements. However, MRFs require large members to meet story drift criteria. Moreover, strong-column-weak-beam requirements can result in significant member sizes, and – even in the cases where strong-column-weak-beam requirements are satisfied – MRFs can still be vulnerable to story mechanisms in one or a few stories. Recently, the concept of a strongback has been utilized successfully to delay or prevent story mechanism behavior in braced frames. The strongback is represented by a steel truss or column that is designed to remain essentially elastic, thus allowing the system to transfer inelastic demands across stories. Although systems including strongbacks exhibit more uniform story drift demands with building height and reduced peak drift response, the elastic nature of the strongback can also result in near-elastic higher-mode force demands. This study compares the dynamic response of a baseline MRF to that of a retrofit using a strongback column. Several ground motions are considered to determine which cases produce the largest drift, acceleration, and force demands.more » « less
-
Even with strong-column-weak-beam design requirements, story mechanisms have been observed in Moment Resisting Frames (MRF), resulting in concentrated drift demands that can result in severe structural damage to drift-sensitive components. Frame-Spine systems can redistribute demands with building height, but near-elastic higher-mode effects tend to contribute to floor accelerations, affecting damage to acceleration-sensitive nonstructural components. To mitigate this tradeoff, Force-Limiting Connections (FLCs) have been proposed to reduce accelerations through yielding components between the Frame and Spine, thereby limiting the magnitude of the forces. This study examines the sizing and placement of FLCs in a four-story Frame-Spine system using stochastic simulations. The T-shape yielding element dimensions in the FLC were modeled as random variables at each floor, and Monte Carlo simulations were used to explore their effect on drifts and accelerations. Results show the dominant role of the first-story FLC on balancing drifts and accelerations, while upper-story devices offered limited benefit. Design recommendations are provided to constrain first-story yielding element dimensions within effective bounds that reduce peak accelerations relative to the baseline Frame-Spine configuration.more » « less
-
Concentration of drifts due to story mechanisms can lead to severe structural damage and economic loss. Frame-Spine systems have been proposed to mitigate these effects by redistributing drift demands with building height; however, systems can also exhibit near-elastic higher-mode effects, resulting in forces and floor accelerations that remain largely unreduced by inelastic behavior, thereby adversely affecting acceleration-sensitive nonstructural components and occupants. To address near-elastic higher-mode effects, Force-Limiting Connections (FLCs) have been introduced limiting force transfer between the frame and the spine and reducing acceleration demands through controlled yielding components. This study presents observations from full-scale shake-table testing of a four-story Frame-Spine and a Frame-Spine-FLC specimen at E-Defense. Results highlight higher-mode effects under strong shaking, with emphasis on (1) story shear resisted by the spine, (2) force–deformation behavior of the spine-to-frame connections, and (3) vertical distribution of forces. These findings provide experimental evidence of higher-mode participation in Frame-Spine systems and support the development of improved design guidance and controlling mechanisms.more » « less
-
Mid-rise moment resisting frames (MRF) which utilize supplemental pinned-base spines (spine) to prevent the formation of story mechanisms experience higher mode accelerations at near elastic spectral values. Force Limiting Connections (FLC) can be introduced to reduce the floor accelerations from the higher mode responses while having small impact on first-mode response and maintaining the story mechanism prevention from the spine. Results from nonlinear response history analysis (NRHA) of a 4-story MRF-Spine system show how floor accelerations for higher modes are reduced with the addition of FLC placed between the MRF and spine. Peak effective pseudo accelerations are utilized to show how pseudo spectral accelerations are reduced by the introduction of FLC. Full-scale testing of the 4-storyMRF-Spine structure supports the numerical results of theMRF-Spine andMRF-Spine-FLC numerical analyses. These results show the potential benefits of adding FLC to MRF-Spine systems.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- The DOI is not currently available.
