skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


  • NSF Public Access
  • Search Results
  • Site and management factors determining the fate of hardwood trees planted on reclaimed coal mines in the Illinois Basin, USA

This content will become publicly available on March 1, 2026

Title: Site and management factors determining the fate of hardwood trees planted on reclaimed coal mines in the Illinois Basin, USA
Despite decades of research and practice restoring forests on surface coal mines, success is still variable, and failures often occur. To better understand how variation in site factors and management affects the success of restoration of coal mines, we conducted a survey of tree performance for mine sites in the Illinois Basin across Indiana, USA, reclaimed between 2008 and 2018. We explored the impacts of climate and soil conditions on the survival and growth of planted trees, as well as the cover of associated vegetation. Average overall survival (21%) was relatively low compared to typical unmined sites. Organic matter had one of the most consistent and largest effects on most oak species, with the highest performance between 3 and 5%. Soil phosphorus content was the most important factor determining whether a planting totally failed and affected the growth of White oak (Quercus alba) and Swamp white oak (Q. bicolor), though its effect on White oak was nonlinear. Rainfall in the year of planting had large positive effects on the survival and growth of Persimmon (Diospyros virginiana), and Black walnut (Juglans nigra) and temperature in the year of planting had large positive effects on the growth of Bur oak (Q. macrocarpa) and Persimmon. Planting a diverse mix of species is the best option both for approximating natural conditions, and for avoiding problems from the failure of individual species. While conditions vary, successful forest restoration on former coal mines can occur; this study reveals some of the most important factors affecting such success.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1916587
PAR ID:
10659992
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Restoration Ecology
Volume:
33
Issue:
3
ISSN:
1061-2971
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (, Frontiers in Microbiomes)
    Zhou, Jun (Ed.)
    IntroductionClimate change has increased the need for forest restoration, but low planting success and limited availability of planting materials hamper these efforts. Invasive plants and their soil legacies can further reduce restoration success. Thus, strategies that optimize restoration are crucial. Assisted migration and inoculation with native microbial symbiont communities have great potential to increase restoration success. However, assisted migrants can still show reduced survival compared to local provenances depending on transfer distance. Inoculation with mycorrhizal fungi, effective if well-matched to plants and site conditions, can have neutral to negative results with poor pairings. Few studies have examined the interaction between these two strategies in realistic field environments where native plants experience the combined effects of soil legacies left by invasive plants and the drought conditions that result from a warming, drying climate. MethodsWe planted two ecotypes (local climate and warmer climate) ofPopulus fremontii(Fremont cottonwoods), in soils with and without legacies of invasion byTamarixspp. (tamarisk), and with and without addition of native mycorrhizal fungi and other soil biota from the warmer climate. ResultsFour main results emerged. 1) First year survival in soil legacies left behind after tamarisk invasion and removal was less than one tenth of survival in soil without a tamarisk legacy. 2) Actively restoring soil communities after tamarisk removal tripled first year cottonwood survival for both ecotypes, but only improved survival of the warmer, assisted migrant ecotype trees in year two. 3) Actively restoring soil communities in areas without a tamarisk history reduced first year survival for both ecotypes, but improved survival of the warmer, assisted migrant ecotype trees in year two. 4) By the second year, inoculated assisted migrants survived at five times the rate of inoculated trees from the local ecotype. DiscussionResults emphasize the detrimental effects of soil legacies left after tamarisk invasion and removal, the efficacy of assisted migration and restoring soil communities alongside plants, and the need to thoughtfully optimize pairings between plants, fungi, and site conditions. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; ; ; ; (, Land Degradation & Development)
    Abstract Restoration techniques using passive management rely on natural plant community succession after reclamation to return disturbed areas to native ecosystems. This approach is often used in areas affected by mining activity, but effectiveness is variable and depends on the ability of native plants to establish in highly degraded soil and outcompete invasive species. We evaluated the restoration progress of three former surface mines where activity had exposed alkaline glacial till parent material. The mines underwent reclamation (grading, soil compaction, and planting fast‐growing herbaceous species) followed by passive management for 7, 28, and 35 years. At the time of initial restoration planning in the 1980s, native woody species were expected to recolonize the site within 10–20 years. Treating the sites as a chronosequence, we observed that woody vegetation increased inconsistently over this 35‐year timespan. Most of the woody plants present today are invasive species (Elaeagnus umbellataandRhamnus frangula) that are counterproductive to reestablishment of native forest. However, results were not entirely negative, with increased overall native species and decreased exotic species in the older sites, and plant community composition changing somewhat consistently over time. This suggests that succession has been slowed rather than completely arrested, and native herbaceous plants are establishing. The progression of restoration appears to be far slower than expectations during initial planning. Furthermore, native woody plants struggle to establish, whereas invasive woody plants are thriving, raising doubts that passively managed succession can lead to the desired outcome of a native species forest in this significantly degraded habitat. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; ; ; ; (, Restoration Ecology)
    As coastal regions experience accelerating land loss, artificial substrates may be useful in restoration efforts to replenish sediment and facilitate plant colonization. Recycled glass sand is a potential artificial substrate for marsh building due to its sustainability, availability, and similarity to natural substrates. However, differences in texture and availability of microbiota necessitate investigating how it affects plant growth. We tested the effect of three substrates (conventionally used dredged river sand, recycled glass sand, and a mix) and inoculation with natural soil microbes on the biomass and root architecture of Black mangrove (Avicennia germinans) in a greenhouse experiment. We found neither substrate nor inoculum affected biomass; however, survival was lower in mixed substrate compared to dredged and glass sand, and live inoculum increased survival from 70 to 93%. Substrate affected root architecture: mangroves grown in glass sand had 55% lower fine root length, 51% lower specific root length (length/mass), and 26% larger average root diameter than mangroves grown in dredged sand. Although an unintended fungal infection byGeotrichum candidumkilled nearly 90% of infected propagules before the experiment, surviving plants had 81% higher biomass than uninfected plants. These findings suggest that while glass sand does not affect biomass, it may affect root architecture in ways that compromise soil stability. Furthermore, inoculation with live soil may boost restoration planting success across substrates, likely by reintroducing mutualists. Overall, recycled glass sand may be a viable restoration strategy with the caveat that the developing root architecture may differ from that in more natural substrates. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; (, Frontiers in Marine Science)
    Ecological restoration is emerging as an important strategy to improve the recovery of degraded lands and to combat habitat and biodiversity loss worldwide. One central unresolved question revolves around the optimal spatial design for outplanted propagules that maximizes restoration success. Essentially, two contrasting paradigms exist: the first aims to plant propagules in dispersed arrangements to minimize competitive interactions. In contrast, ecological theory and recent field experiments emphasize the importance of positive species interactions, suggesting instead clumped planting configurations. However, planting too many propagules too closely is likely to waste restoration resources as larger clumps have less edges and have relatively lower spread rates. Thus, given the constraint of limited restoration efforts, there should be an optimal planting distance that both is able to harness positive species interactions but at the same time maximizes spread in the treated area. To explore these ideas, here we propose a simple mathematical model that tests the influence of positive species interactions on the optimal design of restoration efforts. We model the growth and spatial spread of a population starting from different initial conditions that represent either clumped or dispersed configurations of planted habitat patches in bare substrate. We measure the spatio-temporal development of the population, its relative and absolute growth rates as well as the time-discounted population size and its dependence on the presence of an Allee effect. Finally, we assess whether clumped or dispersed configurations perform better in our models and qualitatively compare the simulation outcomes with a recent wetland restoration experiment in a coastal wetland. Our study shows that intermediate clumping is likely to maximize plant spread under medium and high stress conditions (high occurrence of positive interactions) while dispersed designs maximize growth under low stress conditions where competitive interactions dominate. These results highlight the value of mathematical modeling for optimizing the efficiency of restoration efforts and call for integration of this theory into practice. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; (, Restoration Ecology)
    Tree plantings have the potential to increase species diversity and sequester carbon, yet planting failure and early mortality pose significant barriers to their success. Biodiversity‐ecosystem function theory suggests that diverse tree plantings could improve survival outcomes through either the portfolio or facilitation effect, yet there remain few tests of this hypothesis. Here, we use a large‐scale tree‐diversity experiment (BiodiversiTREE), with monitoring of nearly 8,000 individual trees to test whether (1) tree species diversity increases survival rates, (2) tree diversity stabilizes the risk of planting failure, and/or (3) diversity effects are important relative to other common drivers of seedling mortality (e.g. herbivory and soil moisture). We found that only species identity significantly impacted the likelihood of survival, not plant functional diversity nor plot species richness nor phylogenetic diversity. There were minor effects of elevation and soil moisture on survival, but both explained a very small amount of variation in the data (r2marg ≤ 0.011). Higher tree diversity did, however, strongly reduce variation in survival across plots, with nearly 2‐fold higher coefficients of variation in monocultures (30.4%, 28.4–32.6% 95% bootstrapped confidence interval) compared to 4‐ (16.3%, 13.8–18.7%) and 12‐species plots (12.8%, 10.8–14.7%). Ultimately, our results suggest that employing diverse species can lower the risk of planting failure (i.e. the portfolio effect), but that species selection still plays a large role in early establishment. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email