skip to main content


Title: Change Point Models for Real-time V2I Cyber Attack Detection in a Connected Vehicle Environment
Connected vehicle (CV) systems are cognizant of potential cyber attacks because of increasing connectivity between its different components such as vehicles, roadside infrastructure and traffic management centers. However, it is a challenge to detect security threats in real-time and develop appropriate/effective countermeasures for a CV system because of the dynamic behavior of such attacks, high computational power requirement and a historical data requirement for training detection models. To address these challenges, statistical models, especially change point models, have potentials for real-time anomaly detections. Thus, the objective of this study is to investigate the efficacy of two change point models, Expectation Maximization (EM) and two forms of Cumulative Summation (CUSUM) algorithms (i.e., typical and adaptive), for real-time V2I cyber attack detection in a CV Environment. To prove the efficacy of these models, we evaluated these two models for three different type of cyber attack, denial of service (DOS), impersonation, and false information, using basic safety messages (BSMs) generated from CVs through simulation. Results from numerical analysis revealed that EM, CUSUM, and adaptive CUSUM could detect these cyber attacks, DOS, impersonation, and false information, with an accuracy of (99\%, 100\%, 100\%), (98\%, 100\%, 100\%), and (100\%, 98\%, 100\%) respectively.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1719501
NSF-PAR ID:
10092198
Author(s) / Creator(s):
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Transportation Research Board Annual Meeting 2019
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. False power consumption data injected from compromised smart meters in Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) of smart grids is a threat that negatively affects both customers and utilities. In particular, organized and stealthy adversaries can launch various types of data falsification attacks from multiple meters using smart or persistent strategies. In this paper, we propose a real time, two tier attack detection scheme to detect orchestrated data falsification under a sophisticated threat model in decentralized micro-grids. The first detection tier monitors whether the Harmonic to Arithmetic Mean Ratio of aggregated daily power consumption data is outside a normal range known as safe margin. To confirm whether discrepancies in the first detection tier is indeed an attack, the second detection tier monitors the sum of the residuals (difference) between the proposed ratio metric and the safe margin over a frame of multiple days. If the sum of residuals is beyond a standard limit range, the presence of a data falsification attack is confirmed. Both the ‘safe margins’ and the ‘standard limits’ are designed through a ‘system identification phase’, where the signature of proposed metrics under normal conditions are studied using real AMI micro-grid data sets from two different countries over multiple years. Subsequently, we show how the proposed metrics trigger unique signatures under various attacks which aids in attack reconstruction and also limit the impact of persistent attacks. Unlike metrics such as CUSUM or EWMA, the stability of the proposed metrics under normal conditions allows successful real time detection of various stealthy attacks with ultra-low false alarms. 
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    With the development of the emerging Connected Vehicle (CV) technology, vehicles can wirelessly communicate with traffic infrastructure and other vehicles to exchange safety and mobility information in real time. However, the integrated communication capability inevitably increases the attack surface of vehicles, which can be exploited to cause safety hazard on the road. Thus, it is highly desirable to systematically understand design-level flaws in the current CV network stack as well as in CV applications, and the corresponding security/safety consequences so that these flaws can be proactively discovered and addressed before large-scale deployment. In this paper, we design CVAnalyzer, a system for discovering design-level flaws for availability violations of the CV network stack, as well as quantifying the corresponding security/safety consequences. To achieve this, CVAnalyzer combines the attack discovery capability of a general model checker and the quantitative threat assessment capability of a probabilistic model checker. Using CVAnalyzer, we successfully uncovered 4 new DoS (Denial-of-Service) vulnerabilities of the latest CV network protocols and 14 new DoS vulnerabilities of two CV platoon management protocols. Our quantification results show that these attacks can have as high as 99% success rates, and in the worst case can at least double the delay in packet processing, violating the latency requirement in CV communication.We implemented and validated all attacks in a real-world testbed, and also analyzed the fundamental causes to propose potential solutions. We have reported our findings in the CV network protocols to the IEEE 1609 Working Group, and the group has acknowledged the discovered vulnerabilities and plans to adopt our solutions. 
    more » « less
  3. Controller Area Network (CAN) is the de-facto standard in-vehicle network system. Despite its wide adoption by automobile manufacturers, the lack of security design makes it vulnerable to attacks. For instance, broadcasting packets without authentication allows the impersonation of electronic control units (ECUs). Prior mitigations, such as message authentication or intrusion detection systems, fail to address the compatibility requirement with legacy ECUs, stealthy and sporadic malicious messaging, or guaranteed attack detection. We propose a novel authentication system called ShadowAuth that overcomes the aforementioned challenges by offering backward-compatible packet authentication to ECUs without requiring ECU firmware source code. Specifically, our authentication scheme provides transparent CAN packet authentication without modifying existing CAN packet definitions (e.g., J1939) via automatic ECU firmware instrumentation technique to locate CAN packet transmission code, and instrument authentication code based on the CAN packet behavioral transmission patterns. ShadowAuth enables vehicles to detect state-of-the-art CAN attacks, such as bus-off and packet injection, responsively within 60ms without false positives. ShadowAuth provides a sound and deployable solution for real-world ECUs. 
    more » « less
  4. Cyber-physical systems (CPS) are susceptible to physical attacks, and researchers are exploring ways to detect them. One method involves monitoring the system for a set duration, known as the time-window, and identifying residual errors that exceed a predetermined threshold. However, this approach means that any sensor attack alert can only be triggered after the time-window has elapsed. The length of the time-window affects the detection delay and the likelihood of false alarms, with a shorter time-window leading to quicker detection but a higher false positive rate, and a longer time-window resulting in slower detection but a lower false positive rate. While researchers aim to choose a fixed time-window that balances a low false positive rate and short detection delay, this goal is difficult to attain due to a trade-off between the two. An alternative solution proposed in this paper is to have a variable time-window that can adapt based on the current state of the CPS. For instance, if the CPS is heading towards an unsafe state, it is more crucial to reduce the detection delay (by decreasing the time-window) rather than reducing the false alarm rate, and vice versa. The paper presents a sensor attack detection framework that dynamically adjusts the time-window, enabling attack alerts to be triggered before the system enters dangerous regions, ensuring timely detection. This framework consists of three components: attack detector, state predictor, and window adaptor. We have evaluated our work using real-world data, and the results demonstrate that our solution improves the usability and timeliness of time-window-based attack detectors. 
    more » « less
  5. The bi-directional communication capabilities that emerged into the smart power grid play a critical role in the grid's secure, reliable and efficient operation. Nevertheless, the data communication functionalities introduced to Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) nodes end the grid's isolation, and expose the network into an array of cyber-security threats that jeopardize the grid's stability and availability. For instance, malware amenable to inject false data into the AMI can compromise the grid's state estimation process and lead to catastrophic power outages. In this paper, we explore several statistical spatio-temporal models for efficient diagnosis of false data injection attacks in smart grids. The proposed methods leverage the data co-linearities that naturally arise in the AMI measurements of the electric network to provide forecasts for the network's AMI observations, aiming to quickly detect the presence of “bad data”. We evaluate the proposed approaches with data tampered with stealth attacks compiled via three different attack strategies. Further, we juxtapose them against two other forecasting-aided detection methods appearing in the literature, and discuss the trade-offs of all techniques when employed on real-world power grid data, obtained from a large university campus. 
    more » « less