More Like this

1. Titanite petrochronology records multiphase construction of the Little Cottonwood stock, Utah U.S.A. accommodated by an upper crustal shear zone

   Stearns, M.A.; Bartley, J.M.; Bowman, J.R.; Beno, C.J.; Udy, N.D.; Garber, J.M. (January 2022, Transactions American Geophysical Union)

   The Wasatch Mountains expose an oblique profile through the Alta and Little Cottonwood stocks (LCS) owing to 20° eastward tilt in the footwall of the Wasatch Fault. The cross section spans the upper 11 km of the crust beneath the Eocene paleosurface exposed in Park City, UT. Previous titanite and zircon U-Pb petrochronology established 10 Myr of simultaneous magmatism and hydrothermal metamorphism both in the deeper LCS and in the shallower Alta stock which likely was the conduit between the LCS and cogenetic Keetley volcanic deposits. Hydrothermal metamorphism within and surrounding the Alta stock was synchronous with and most likely driven by emplacement of LCS and migrated from within the Alta stock and contact aureole to margins of the stock suggesting an evolving permeability structure during and after the crystallization of the LCS. New titanite U-Pb petrochronology from the LCS and stock-bounding Wasatch Fault Zone indicate that 1) the LCS was constructed in two phases, an earlier ~36–34 Ma and a younger ~32–25 Ma phase, 2) the presence of both magmatic and hydrothermal titanite as recorded by trace element chemistry, and 3) a pre-Wasatch Fault ductile shear zone likely accommodated magma emplacement at crustal strain rates beginning around 32 Ma. Principal component analysis of LCS trace element data distinguishes two end-member titanite populations along the first component axis: a magmatic population with high REE and a metamorphic population with low REE and high Sr, Sc, V, Cr, Fe, Al, Pb, and particularly W. The second principal component is defined by variance in the REE interpreted to record fractionation by titanite crystallization from melt. The initial ~36–34 Ma phase of LCS construction overlaps with magmatism within the Alta stock conduit and Keetley volcanic rocks and is only found on the western, deepest portion of the LCS. Trace element chemistry of ~36–34 Ma titanites lacks the low REE, high W population suggesting that hydrothermal water released by crystallizing magma did not percolate through these rocks. Low REE, high W titanites are restricted to the structurally higher second phase of the LCS. Despite this relationship, not all samples in the second LCS phase contain the hydrothermal population, which suggests spatially complex magma emplacement and/or later hydrothermal permeability structure. 

   more » « less
2. Titanite geochemistry and textures: Implications for magmatic and post-magmatic processes in the Notch Peak and Little Cottonwood granitic intrusions, Utah

   https://doi.org/10.2138/am-2022-8241  

   Henze, Porter K.; Christiansen, Eric H.; Kowallis, Bart J.; Dorais, Michael J.; Mosher, Haley D.; Franzen, Lauren M.; Martin, Alec J.; Nabelek, Peter I. (February 2023, American Mineralogist)

   Abstract Textural and compositional variations in titanite constrain the roles of magma mixing and hydrothermal alteration in two plutons in central Utah: the Jurassic Notch Peak and the Oligocene Little Cottonwood stocks. In the Notch Peak intrusion, magmatic titanite grains usually have oscillatory zones combined with BSE-bright sector zones, in some cases surrounding simple unzoned cores. These grains are frequently overprinted by hydrothermal titanite with low concentrations of high field strength elements (HFSE). Magmatic titanite has an average δ18O of 6.0‰ and post-magmatic titanite is 6.2‰, as analyzed by SIMS. Average Zr-in-titanite temperatures are also similar, with 718 °C for magmatic and 711 °C for hydrothermal titanite. These observations indicate simple magmatic growth, followed by hydrothermal alteration by magmatic fluids. Titanite in aplite dikes and sills has lower concentrations of all trace elements except F. Many titanite grains in the aplites have late overgrowths of high-Fe titanite. This high-Fe titanite has δ18O of 6‰ and an average Zr-in-titanite temperature of 718 °C and likely precipitated from a last flush of exsolved magmatic water enriched in Cl and Fe. Titanite in the Little Cottonwood stock typically has distinct patchy cores with rounded and embayed ilmenite inclusions. Mafic enclaves have abundant titanite that is similar in texture and δ18O (5.1‰) to titanite in the host (δ18O = 4.9‰), but it has a slightly higher average Zr-in-titanite temperature (731 vs. 717 °C). The patchy cores in the enclaves have the highest average Zr-in-titanite temperature (759 °C) and distinctive REE patterns. The textural and compositional data indicate that a hotter, more reduced, ilmenite-bearing mafic magma mixed into an oxidized felsic magma, destabilizing existing ilmenite and allowing crystallization of titanite. In the granodiorite and in the enclaves, hydrothermal growth of titanite is evidenced by distinct narrow rims as well as anhedral titanite that grew between sheets of chloritized biotite. Secondary hydrothermal titanite typically has lower concentrations of most HFSE, but is relatively enriched in F, Mg, Mo, and U, and it has higher Nb/Ta and lower Th/U ratios. Post-magmatic titanite also has strikingly different REE patterns than magmatic titanite, including the absence of pronounced Eu anomalies and lower REE abundances. These chemical features are controlled by element solubilities in aqueous fluids. In most cases, hydrothermal titanite has δ18O values similar to magmatic titanite, indicating alteration and recrystallization from exsolved magmatic fluids. The involvement of meteoric water with low δ18O is evident locally; individual spots have δ18O as low as 1.7‰ in the Little Cottonwood stock. Titanite compositions and textures provide important insights into the origins of granitic rocks and can be used to distinguish separate batches of magma, gauge the evolution of magmatic rocks, assess mixing processes, and infer compositions of mixing components. Because titanite also forms hydrothermally, it retains hints about the composition, temperature, and oxygen fugacity of the hydrothermal fluids and reveals details about titanite-forming reactions. However, the Al-in-titanite geobarometer does not yield realistic pressures of crystallization and the use of titanite as a geochronometer is compromised by the development of U-rich hydrothermal titanite. 

   more » « less
3. Titanite zonation records magmatic to autometamorphic transition in the Little Cottonwood stock, Utah

   Bartley, J.M.; Stearns, M.A.; Bowman, J.R.; Beno, C.J.; Saunders, E.; Nicholas, S. (April 2023, Abstracts Geological Society of America)

   Granite textures are usually assumed to be unmodified igneous features, but titanite petrochronoloy records a progression from magmatic crystallization to fluid-mediated automorphism in the Little Cottonwood stock (LCS). The Wasatch Mountains expose a profile through the 36-25 Ma Wasatch Igneous Belt owing to 20° eastward tilt in the footwall of the Wasatch Fault. The LCS, Alta stock (AS) and their contact aureoles form an integrated magmatic-hydrothermal system that underpinned the cogenetic Keetley Volcanics (KV). The AS (~3-5 km depth) likely formed a conduit from the deeper LCS (~6-11 km) to the KV. The LCS formed in two phases: 1) ~36–33 Ma, coeval with the AS and KV, and 2) ~32–25 Ma, younger than KV and AS but at this time hydrothermal fluid infiltrated the AS­ to form endoskarn. LCS titanite was analyzed by LASS-ICP-MS in 16 samples of unaltered granite (s.l.) collected along transects from the roof on the east to the deepest exposures on the west and from the northern wall to the southern wall. Principal component analysis of titanite trace-element data distinguishes a magmatic group with high REE and a metamorphic group with low REE and high W, Sr, Sc, V, Cr, Fe, Al, and Pb. The metamorphic group forms BSE-dark rims that are variably developed but present in every sample. U-Pb dates indicate that, across the sample suite, there is nearly complete age overlap between magmatic and metamorphic titanite. We interpret chemical zoning of the titanite to record magmatic crystallization followed by hydrothermal modification of primary minerals. The age overlap suggests that solidified increments were infiltrated by fluid released by crystallization of nearby later increments. Infiltrating fluids also affected the feldspars: although apparently intact when examined optically, CL images reveal the feldspars to have been shattered, then healed by dissolution-reprecipitation. Exsolution of Ab component from K-feldspar to form albite selvages against adjacent plagioclase probably was part of the same process, as were biotite chloritization and exsolution of Ti from primary titanomagnetite to grow metamorphic titanite. Taken together, observations from titanite and major phases are consistent with fluid-mediated submagmatic re-equilibration throughout incremental assembly of the LCS. 

   more » « less
4. Petrochronologic Constraints on the Timing and Duration of Sill and Dike Emplacement and Associated Contact Metamorphism of Hornfels in the Alta Aureole, Utah, from Zircon and Monazite LA(SS)-ICP-MS

   Bowman, J.R.; Beno, C.J.; Stearns, M.A.; Bartley, J.M.; Fernandez, D.P.; Kylander-Clark, A.C. (January 2022, Transactions American Geophysical Union)

   Two generations of dikes and sills (earlier granodiorite, later leucogranite) have intruded quartzofeldspathic to semi-pelitic hornfels in the innermost ~200 meters of the southern contact aureole of the Alta stock. Both zircon and monazite are present in the older granodiorite intrusions, and monazite alone is present in the younger leucogranite intrusions, and in biotite-rich reaction selvages formed by hydrothermal contact metamorphism in hornfels adjacent to these dikes and sills. U-Pb dates for zircon (n=532) range from ~38 to 32 Ma, with error on individual measurements of ±1–1.5 Ma, and define a KDE peak at 34.5 Ma. These zircon dates are slightly older than, but consistent with, existing zircon data from the Alta stock (35 to 32 Ma; Stearns et al., 2020), suggesting that the construction of the Alta stock began by emplacement of these granodiorite sills and dikes. Monazite Th-Pb dates (n = 888) range from ~41 to 28 Ma with error on individual measurements of ± 1–1.5 Ma. These dates are complicated by disturbances to the U/Th-Pb systematics by common Pb (Pbc) and excess 206Pb due to 230Th. Dates >38 Ma are disturbed by significant Pbc and do not represent crystallization ages. Dates from the granodiorites range from ~38–32 Ma. In individual samples of granodiorite where the disturbance from excess 206Pb can be rigorously evaluated, the monazite data sets yield concordant 232Th-208Pb and 207Pb/206Pb-corrected dates centered at ~35 Ma, consistent with zircon dates from these same samples. Monazite dates from the leucogranites are younger (<33 Ma), consistent with cross-cutting relationships (leucogranites cross-cut granodiorites). The monazite data from the leucogranite sills and dikes do not record magmatic or hydrothermal activity after ~29 Ma, in contrast to the titanite record of hydrothermal activity to as late as ~23 Ma in the border zone of the Alta stock and its endoskarns (Stearns et al., 2020). This absence suggests that once magma injection and associated contact metamorphism in the hornfels ceased, permeability in the hornfels decreased sufficiently by ~29 Ma to prevent subsequent infiltration of significant fluxes of hydrothermal fluid into these hornfels lithologies in the aureole. 

   more » « less
5. Interplay of Cretaceous transpressional deformation and continental arc magmatism in a long-lived crustal boundary, central Fiordland, New Zealand

   https://doi.org/10.1130/GES02251.1  

   Blatchford, Hannah J.; Klepeis, Keith A.; Schwartz, Joshua J.; Jongens, Richard; Turnbull, Rose E.; Miranda, Elena A.; Coble, Matthew A.; Kylander-Clark, Andrew R. (August 2020, Geosphere)

   null (Ed.)

   Abstract Recovering the time-evolving relationship between arc magmatism and deformation, and the influence of anisotropies (inherited foliations, crustal-scale features, and thermal gradients), is critical for interpreting the location, timing, and geometry of transpressional structures in continental arcs. We investigated these themes of magma-deformation interactions and preexisting anisotropies within a middle- and lower-crustal section of Cretaceous arc crust coinciding with a Paleozoic boundary in central Fiordland, New Zealand. We present new structural mapping and results of Zr-in-titanite thermometry and U-Pb zircon and titanite geochronology from an Early Cretaceous batholith and its host rock. The data reveal how the expression of transpression in the middle and lower crust of a continental magmatic arc evolved during emplacement and crystallization of the ∼2300 km2 lower-crustal Western Fiordland Orthogneiss (WFO) batholith. Two structures within Fiordland’s architecture of transpressional shear zones are identified. The gently dipping Misty shear zone records syn-magmatic oblique-sinistral thrust motion between ca. 123 and ca. 118 Ma, along the lower-crustal WFO Misty Pluton margin. The subhorizontal South Adams Burn thrust records mid-crustal arc-normal shortening between ca. 114 and ca. 111 Ma. Both structures are localized within and reactivate a recently described >10 km-wide Paleozoic crustal boundary, and show that deformation migrated upwards between ca. 118 and ca. 114 Ma. WFO emplacement and crystallization (mainly 118–115 Ma) coincided with elevated (>750 °C) middle- and lower-crustal Zr-in-titanite temperatures and the onset of mid-crustal cooling at 5.9 ± 2.0 °C Ma−1 between ca. 118 and ca. 95 Ma. We suggest that reduced strength contrasts across lower-crustal pluton margins during crystallization caused deformation to migrate upwards into thermally weakened rocks of the mid-crust. The migration was accompanied by partitioning of deformation into domains of arc-normal shortening in Paleozoic metasedimentary rocks and domains that combined shortening and strike-slip deformation in crustal-scale subvertical, transpressional shear zones previously documented in Fiordland. U-Pb titanite dates indicate Carboniferous–Cretaceous (re)crystallization, consistent with reactivation of the inherited boundary. Our results show that spatio-temporal patterns of transpression are influenced by magma emplacement and crystallization and by the thermal structure of a reactivated boundary. 

   more » « less