skip to main content

Title: Experimental Seismic Test of Drywall Partition Walls with Improved Detailing for Damage Reduction
Drywall partition walls are susceptible to damage at low-level drifts, and hence reducing such damage is key to achieving seismic resiliency in buildings. Prior tests on drywall partition walls have shown that slip track connection detailing leads to better performance than other detailing, such as fully-fixed connections. However, in all prior testing, partition wall performance was evaluated using a unidirectional loading protocol (either in-plane or out-of-plane) or in shake table testing. Moreover, all details are susceptible to considerable damage to wall intersections. Two phases of the test have been performed at the Natural Hazards Engineering Research Infrastructure (NHERI) Lehigh Equipment Facility to develop improved details of drywall partition walls under bidirectional loading. The partition walls were tested alongside a cross-laminated timber (CLT) post-tensioned rocking wall subassembly, wherein the CLT system is under development as a resilient lateral system for tall timber buildings. In the Phase 1, the slip behavior of conventional slip-track detailing was compared to telescoping detailing (track-within-a-track deflection assembly). In the Phase 2, two details for reducing the wall intersection damage were evaluated on traditional slip-track C-shaped walls. First, a corner gap detail was tested. This detail incorporates a gap through the wall intersection to reduce the collision damage more » at two intersecting walls. Second, a distributed gap detail was tested. In this approach, the aim was to reduce damage by using more frequent control joints through the length of the wall. All walls were tested under a bidirectional loading protocol with three sub-cycles: in-plane, a bi-directional hexagonal load path, and a bi-directional hexagonal load path with an increase in the out-of-plane drift. This loading protocol allows for studying the bidirectional behavior of walls and evaluating the effect of out-of-plane drift on the partition wall resisting force. In the Phase 1, the telescoping detailing performed better than conventional slip track detailing because it eliminated damage to the framing. In Phase 2, the distributed gap detailing delayed damage to about 1% story drift. For the corner gap detailing, the sacrificial corner bead detached at low drifts, but the wall itself was damage-free until 2.5% drift. Bidirectional loading was found to have an insignificant influence on the in-plane resistance of the walls, and the overall resistance of the walls was trivial compared to the CLT rocking. « less
Authors:
;
Award ID(s):
1635363
Publication Date:
NSF-PAR ID:
10209234
Journal Name:
The 17th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering
Page Range or eLocation-ID:
2k-0054
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Drywall partition walls (DPW) could considerably affect the seismic resilience of tall cross-laminated timber (CLT) buildings due to cost and building downtime associated with repair. These drift sensitive components are susceptible to damage at low shaking intensities, and thus controlling or eliminating such damage in low to moderate earthquakes is key to seismic resilience. Conversely, post-tensioned CLT rocking walls have been shown to be a resilient lateral load resistant system for tall CLT building in high seismic areas. A series of tests will be performed at the NHERI Lehigh EF to compare the performance of DPWs with conventional slip-track detailingmore »and alternative telescoping slip-track detailing (track-within-a-track deflection assembly), and to evaluate different approaches for minimizing damage at the wall intersections through the use of gaps. Moreover, a configuration is examined with partition wall encapsulating the rocking wall for fire protection. This paper presents a summary of pre-test studies to design the best configuration of DPW to improve the overall resiliency of the structure.« less
  2. Nonlinear time history analyses were conducted for 5-story and 12-story prototype buildings that used post-tensioned cross-laminated timber rocking walls coupled with U-shaped flexural plates (UFPs) as the lateral force resisting system. The building models were subjected to 22 far-field and 28 near-fault ground motions, with and without directivity effects, scaled to the design earthquake and maximum considered earthquake for Seattle, with ASCE Site Class D. The buildings were designed to performance objectives that limited structural damage to crushing at the wall toes and nonlinear deformation in the UFPs, while ensuring code-based interstory drift requirements were satisfied and the post-tensioned rodsmore »remained linear. The walls of the 12-story building had a second rocking joint at midheight to reduce flexural demands in the lower stories and interstory drift in the upper stories. The interstory drift, in-plane wall shear and overturning moment, UFP deformation, and extent of wall toe crushing is summarized for each building. Near-fault ground motions with directivity effects resulted in the largest demands for the 5-story building, while the midheight rocking joint diminished the influence of ground motion directivity effects in the 12-story building. Results for both buildings confirmed that UFPs located higher from the base of the walls dissipated more energy compared to UFPs closer to the base.« less
  3. Blass, Hans (Ed.)
    Wood buildings in North American has been predominantly constructed using light-framed wood systems since early 1900’s, with only limited exception of heavy timber construction in some non-residential applications. This situation is likely to change in the future with the growing acceptance of mass timber construction in the region. In fact, a number of mass timber buildings have been constructed in recent years in the U.S. and Canada, including low- to mid-rise mixed-use buildings (e.g. UMass Student Center, T3 building) and tall towers (e.g. Brocks Commons at UBC). Most of these buildings utilized cross laminated timber (CLT) or nail laminated timbermore »(NLT) floors and heavy timber framing systems to support gravity loads, and a non-wood lateral system such as concrete shear walls or a braced steel frame to resist wind and seismic loads. Although CLT material and glulam products have been recognized in the U.S. and Canada (IBC (2018) and NBCC (2015), there is currently no mass timber lateral systems in the U.S. and only one system (platform style panelized CLT shear wall) in Canada that is currently recognized by the building codes. As a result, special design procedures and review/approval processes must be followed for any building intended to use a mass timber lateral system. There is a need to promote codification of mass timber lateral systems in order to help further develop mass timber building market in North American. At the time of this paper, there has been an on-going effort to devel-op seismic design parameters for panelized CLT shear walls in the U.S. (ref) following the FEMA P695 procedure for platform construction. The other lateral system that at-tracted significant attention and research resources is post-tensioned CLT rocking wall system, which has the potential to be applicable to balloon framed low-rise to tall wood buildings. This paper will focus on recent research development on CLT rocking wall system in the U.S. and the effort to develop a seismic design procedure for this system for inclusion in the NDS Special Design Provisions for Wind and Seismic (SPDWS)(2008). While the expensive and time consuming process of the FEMA P695 process would provide the ability to use the equivalent lateral force method for design purposes, this path is not part of the discussion included here.« less
  4. Modern seismic resistant design has been focusing on development of cost effective structural systems which experience minimal damage during an earthquake. Unbonded post-tensioned precast concrete walls provide a suitable solution due to their self-centering behavior and their ability to undergo large nonlinear deformation with minimal damage. Several experimental and analytical investigation focusing on lateral load resisting behavior of unbonded post-tensioned precast walls has been carried out in the past two decades. These investigations have primarily focused on lateral load resistance, self-centering capacity, energy dissipation and extent of damage in confined concrete region of the wall system. Past experimental results havemore »shown that self-centering capacity of the wall system decreases at higher lateral drifts. Particularly, rocking walls with higher energy dissipation capacity, sustain considerable residual displacement. This residual displacement in the wall system may affect the ability of the entire structure to re-center. Though increasing initial prestressing force helps in reducing residual drift, it also subjects concrete to increased axial compressive stress which may lead to premature strength degradation of confined concrete in rocking corners. Accurate prediction of expected concrete strains in confined regions during increasing drift cycle is critical in design of such wall systems. Simplified design procedures available in literature assume different values for plastic hinge length to estimate critical concrete strain values. The results from the experimental tests available in literature were analyzed, to understand the effects of energy dissipating elements on residual drift and to examine the accuracy of simplified design procedures in predicting critical concrete strain. Based on the findings, recommendations are made on design of energy dissipating elements and plastic hinge length for unbonded post-tensioned precast rocking walls.« less
  5. This paper presents a shake-table test study to investigate the displacement capacity of shear-dominated reinforced masonry wall systems and the influence of wall flanges and planar walls perpendicular to the direction of shaking (out-of-plane walls) on the seismic performance of a wall system. Two full-scale, single-story, fully grouted, reinforced masonry wall specimens were tested to the verge of collapse. Each specimen had two T-walls as the seismic force-resisting elements and a stiff roof diaphragm. The second specimen had six additional planar walls perpendicular to the direction of shaking. The two specimens reached maximum roof drift ratios of 17% and 13%,more »without collapsing. The high displacement capacities can be largely attributed to the presence of wall flanges and, for the second specimen, also the out-of-plane walls, which provided an alternative load path to carry the gravity load when the webs of the T-walls had been severely damaged. The second specimen developed a higher lateral resistance than the first owing to the additional axial compression exerted on the T-walls by the out-of-plane walls when the former rocked. The shear resistance of the T-walls evaluated with the design code formula matches the test result well when this additional axial compression is taken into account. However, it must be understood that the beneficial influence of the wall flanges depends on the magnitude of the gravity load because of the P-Δeffect and the severity of damage induced in the wall flanges when the wall system is subjected to bidirectional ground motions.« less