skip to main content


Title: Deep Reinforcement Learning with Uncertain Data for Real-Time Stormwater System Control and Flood Mitigation
Flooding in many areas is becoming more prevalent due to factors such as urbanization and climate change, requiring modernization of stormwater infrastructure. Retrofitting standard passive systems with controllable valves/pumps is promising, but requires real-time control (RTC). One method of automating RTC is reinforcement learning (RL), a general technique for sequential optimization and control in uncertain environments. The notion is that an RL algorithm can use inputs of real-time flood data and rainfall forecasts to learn a policy for controlling the stormwater infrastructure to minimize measures of flooding. In real-world conditions, rainfall forecasts and other state information are subject to noise and uncertainty. To account for these characteristics of the problem data, we implemented Deep Deterministic Policy Gradient (DDPG), an RL algorithm that is distinguished by its capability to handle noise in the input data. DDPG implementations were trained and tested against a passive flood control policy. Three primary cases were studied: (i) perfect data, (ii) imperfect rainfall forecasts, and (iii) imperfect water level and forecast data. Rainfall episodes (100) that caused flooding in the passive system were selected from 10 years of observations in Norfolk, Virginia, USA; 85 randomly selected episodes were used for training and the remaining 15 unseen episodes served as test cases. Compared to the passive system, all RL implementations reduced flooding volume by 70.5% on average, and performed within a range of 5%. This suggests that DDPG is robust to noisy input data, which is essential knowledge to advance the real-world applicability of RL for stormwater RTC.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1735587
NSF-PAR ID:
10290843
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Water
Volume:
12
Issue:
11
ISSN:
2073-4441
Page Range / eLocation ID:
3222
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Real-time control of stormwater systems can reduce flooding and improve water quality. Current industry real-time control strategies use simple rules based on water quantity parameters at a local scale. However, system-level control methods that also incorporate observations of water quality could provide improved control and performance. Therefore, the objective of this research is to evaluate the impact of local and system-level control approaches on flooding and sediment-related water quality in a stormwater system within the flood-prone coastal city of Norfolk, Virginia, USA. Deep reinforcement learning (RL), an emerging machine learning technique, is used to learn system-level control policies that attempt to balance flood mitigation and treatment of sediment. RL is compared to the conventional stormwater system and two methods of local-scale rule-based control: (i) industry standard predictive rule-based control with a fixed detention time and (ii) rules based on water quality observations. For the studied system, both methods of rule-based control improved water quality compared to the passive system, but increased total system flooding due to uncoordinated releases of stormwater. An RL agent learned controls that maintained target pond levels while reducing total system flooding by 4% compared to the passive system. When pre-trained from the RL agent that learned to reduce flooding, another RL agent was able to learn to decrease TSS export by an average of 52% compared to the passive system and with an average of 5% less flooding than the rule-based control methods. As the complexity of stormwater RTC implementations grows and climate change continues, system-level control approaches such as the RL used here will be needed to help mitigate flooding and protect water quality. 
    more » « less
  2. Many coastal cities are facing frequent flooding from storm events that are made worse by sea level rise and climate change. The groundwater table level in these low relief coastal cities is an important, but often overlooked, factor in the recurrent flooding these locations face. Infiltration of stormwater and water intrusion due to tidal forcing can cause already shallow groundwater tables to quickly rise toward the land surface. This decreases available storage which increases runoff, stormwater system loads, and flooding. Groundwater table forecasts, which could help inform the modeling and management of coastal flooding, are generally unavailable. This study explores two machine learning models, Long Short-term Memory (LSTM) networks and Recurrent Neural Networks (RNN), to model and forecast groundwater table response to storm events in the flood prone coastal city of Norfolk, Virginia. To determine the effect of training data type on model accuracy, two types of datasets (i) the continuous time series and (ii) a dataset of only storm events, created from observed groundwater table, rainfall, and sea level data from 2010–2018 are used to train and test the models. Additionally, a real-time groundwater table forecasting scenario was carried out to compare the models’ abilities to predict groundwater table levels given forecast rainfall and sea level as input data. When modeling the groundwater table with observed data, LSTM networks were found to have more predictive skill than RNNs (root mean squared error (RMSE) of 0.09 m versus 0.14 m, respectively). The real-time forecast scenario showed that models trained only on storm event data outperformed models trained on the continuous time series data (RMSE of 0.07 m versus 0.66 m, respectively) and that LSTM outperformed RNN models. Because models trained with the continuous time series data had much higher RMSE values, they were not suitable for predicting the groundwater table in the real-time scenario when using forecast input data. These results demonstrate the first use of LSTM networks to create hourly forecasts of groundwater table in a coastal city and show they are well suited for creating operational forecasts in real-time. As groundwater table levels increase due to sea level rise, forecasts of groundwater table will become an increasingly valuable part of coastal flood modeling and management. 
    more » « less
  3. null (Ed.)
    Abstract Flooding in coastal cities is increasing due to climate change and sea-level rise, stressing the traditional stormwater systems these communities rely on. Automated real-time control (RTC) of these systems can improve performance, and creating control policies for smart stormwater systems is an active area of study. This research explores reinforcement learning (RL) to create control policies to mitigate flood risk. RL is trained using a model of hypothetical urban catchments with a tidal boundary and two retention ponds with controllable valves. RL's performance is compared to the passive system, a model predictive control (MPC) strategy, and a rule-based control strategy (RBC). RL learns to proactively manage pond levels using current and forecast conditions and reduced flooding by 32% over the passive system. Compared to the MPC approach using a physics-based model and genetic algorithm, RL achieved nearly the same flood reduction, just 3% less than MPC, with a significant 88× speedup in runtime. Compared to RBC, RL was able to quickly learn similar control strategies and reduced flooding by an additional 19%. This research demonstrates that RL can effectively control a simple system and offers a computationally efficient method that could scale to RTC of more complex stormwater systems. 
    more » « less
  4. Low-lying coastal cities across the world are increasingly seeing flooding due to climate change and accompanying sea-level rise. Many such cities rely on old and passive stormwater infrastructure which cannot cope up with the increasing flood risk. One potential solution for addressing coastal flooding is implementing active control strategies in stormwater systems. Active stormwater control relies on rule-based strategies, which is not able to manage the increasing flood risk. Model predictive control (MPC) for stormwater flood management is getting attention over the past decade. However, building physics-based models for MPC in stormwater management is cost and time prohibitive. In this paper, we develop a data-driven approach, which utilizes unstructured state-space models for system identification and predictive control implementation. We demonstrate our results using two real stormwater network configurations, one from the Norfolk, VA region and another model of Ann Arbor region, MI, respectively. Our results indicate that MPC outperforms rule-based strategies by up to 60% of the Norfolk model and up to 90% of the Ann Arbor model in flood management. 
    more » « less
  5. Compared with capital improvement projects, real-time control of stormwater systems may be a more effective and efficient approach to address the increasing risk of flooding in urban areas. One way to automate the design process of control policies is through reinforcement learning (RL). Recently, RL methods have been applied to small stormwater systems and have demonstrated better performance over passive systems and simple rule-based strategies. However, it remains unclear how effective RL methods are for larger and more complex systems. Current RL-based control policies also suffer from poor convergence and stability, which may be due to large updates made by the underlying RL algorithm. In this study, we use the Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) algorithm and develop control policies for a medium-sized stormwater system that can significantly mitigate flooding during large storm events. Our approach demonstrates good convergence behavior and stability, and achieves robust out-of-sample performance. 
    more » « less