skip to main content

This content will become publicly available on April 7, 2023

Title: All-dry free radical polymerization inside nanopores: Ion-milling-enabled coating thickness profiling revealed “necking” phenomena

Conformal coating of nanopores with functional polymer nanolayers is the key to many emerging technologies such as miniature sensors and membranes for advanced molecular separations. While the polymer coatings are often used to introduce functional moieties, their controlled growth under nanoconfinement could serve as a new approach to manipulate the size and shape of coated nanopores, hence, enabling novel functions like molecular separation. However, precise control of coating thickness in the longitudinal direction of a nanopore is limited by the lack of a characterization method to profile coating thickness within the nanoconfined space. Here, we report an experimental approach that combines ion milling (IM) and high-resolution field emission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM) for acquiring an accurate depth profile of ultrathin (∼20 nm or less) coatings synthesized inside nanopores via initiated chemical vapor deposition (iCVD). The enhanced capability of this approach stems from the excellent x–y resolution achieved by FESEM (i.e., 4.9 nm/pixel), robust depth ( z) control enabled by IM (step size as small as 100 nm with R2 = 0.992), and the statistical power afforded by high-throughput sampling (i.e., ∼2000 individual pores). With that capability, we were able to determine with unparalleled accuracy and precision the depth profile of coating thickness and iCVD more » kinetics along 110-nm-diameter nanopores. That allowed us to uncover an unexpected coating depth profile featuring a maximum rate of polymerization at ∼250 nm underneath the top surface, i.e., down the pores, which we termed “necking.” The necking phenomenon deviates considerably from the conventionally assumed monotonous decrease in thickness along the longitudinal direction into a nanopore, as predicted by the diffusion-limited kinetics model of free radical polymerization. An initiator-centric collision model was then developed, which suggests that under the experimental conditions, the confinement imposed by the nanopores may lead to local amplification of the effective free radical concentration at z ≤ 100 nm and attenuation at z ≥ 500 nm, thus contributing to the observed necking phenomenon. The ion-milling-enabled depth profiling of ultrathin coatings inside nanopores, along with the initiator-mediated coating thickness control in the z-direction, may serve to enhance the performance of size-exclusion filtration membranes and even provide more flexible control of nanopore shape in the z dimension.

« less
Authors:
 ;  ;  
Award ID(s):
1719875 2144171
Publication Date:
NSF-PAR ID:
10365007
Journal Name:
Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology A
Volume:
40
Issue:
3
Page Range or eLocation-ID:
Article No. 033406
ISSN:
0734-2101
Publisher:
American Vacuum Society
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Zeolitic-imidazole framework-8 (ZIF-8) membranes have shown exceptional propylene/propane separation performances. Their commercial applications have, however, been impeded by several challenges. One such challenge is the difficulty of managing microstructural defects ( i.e. , grain boundary defects) in a consistent manner, leading to poor membrane performances and ultimately to a reproducibility issue. Herein, we introduce a new effective strategy to seal the microstructural defects of polycrystalline ZIF-8 membranes using post-synthetic surface polymerization which consists of two steps: (1) introduction of initiator ligands on the membrane surface by post-synthetic ligand exchange and (2) in situ polymerization of poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) via atom transfer radical polymerization. The ZIF-8 membranes were fully covered with ultra-thin PMMA layers of sub-10 nm thickness, increasing the propylene/propane separation factor from ∼60 to ∼106 with unexpectedly increased propylene permeance, effectively improving the membrane reproducibility. The enhanced separation properties of the PMMA-coated ZIF-8 membranes were attributed to the ultra-thin PMMA layers as well as to the possible facilitated propylene transport by Cu ions in the PMMA layers.
  2. Initiated Chemical Vapor Deposition (iCVD) is a free-radical polymerization technique used to synthesize functional polymer thin films. In the context of drug delivery, the conformality of iCVD coatings and the variety of functional chemical moieties make them excellent materials for encapsulating pharmaceutics. Poly(4-aminostyrene) (PAS) belongs to a class of functionalizable materials, whose primary amine allows decoration of the delivery vehicles with biomolecules that enable targeted delivery or biocompatibility. Understanding kinetics of PAS polymerization in iCVD is crucial for such deployments because drug release kinetics in thin-film encapsulation have been shown to be determined by the film thickness. Nevertheless, the effects of deposition conditions on PAS growth kinetics have not been studied systematically. To bridge that knowledge gap, we report the kinetics of iCVD polymerization as a function of fractional saturation pressure of the monomer (i.e., P m /P sat ) in a dual-regime fashion, with quadratic dependence under low P m /P sat and linear dependence under high P m /P sat . We uncovered the critical P m /P sat value of 0.2, around which the transition also occurs for many other iCVD monomers. Because existing theoretical models for the iCVD process cannot fully explain the dual-regime polymerization kinetics,more »we drew inspiration from solution-phase polymerization and proposed updated termination mechanisms that account for the transition between two regimes. The reported model builds upon existing iCVD theories and allows the synthesis of PAS thin films with precisely controlled growth rates, which has the potential to accelerate the deployment of iCVD PAS as a novel biomaterial in controlled and targeted drug delivery with designed pharmacokinetics.« less
  3. Abstract

    In the context of sensing and characterizing single proteins with synthetic nanopores, lipid bilayer coatings provide at least four benefits: first, they minimize unwanted protein adhesion to the pore walls by exposing a zwitterionic, fluid surface. Second, they can slow down protein translocation and rotation by the opportunity to tether proteins with a lipid anchor to the fluid bilayer coating. Third, they provide the possibility to impart analyte specificity by including lipid anchors with a specific receptor or ligand in the coating. Fourth, they offer a method for tuning nanopore diameters by choice of the length of the lipid’s acyl chains. The work presented here compares four properties of various lipid compositions with regard to their suitability as nanopore coatings for protein sensing experiments: (1) electrical noise during current recordings through solid-state nanopores before and after lipid coating, (2) long-term stability of the recorded current baseline and, by inference, of the coating, (3) viscosity of the coating as quantified by the lateral diffusion coefficient of lipids in the coating, and (4) the success rate of generating a suitable coating for quantitative nanopore-based resistive pulse recordings. We surveyed lipid coatings prepared from bolaamphiphilic, monolayer-forming lipids inspired by extremophile archaea andmore »compared them to typical bilayer-forming phosphatidylcholine lipids containing various fractions of curvature-inducing lipids or cholesterol. We found that coatings from archaea-inspired lipids provide several advantages compared to conventional phospholipids; the stable, low noise baseline qualities and high viscosity make these membranes especially suitable for analysis that estimates physical protein parameters such as the net charge of proteins as they enable translocation events with sufficiently long duration to time-resolve dwell time distributions completely. The work presented here reveals that the ease or difficulty of coating a nanopore with lipid membranes did not depend significantly on the composition of the lipid mixture, but rather on the geometry and surface chemistry of the nanopore in the solid state substrate. In particular, annealing substrates containing the nanopore increased the success rate of generating stable lipid coatings.

    « less
  4. Many small proteins move across cellular compartments through narrow pores. In order to thread a protein through a constriction, free energy must be overcome to either deform or completely unfold the protein. In principle, the diameter of the pore, along with the effective driving force for unfolding the protein, as well as its barrier to translocation, should be critical factors that govern whether the process proceeds via squeezing, unfolding/threading, or both. To probe this for a well-established protein system, we studied the electric-field–driven translocation behavior of cytochrome c (cyt c ) through ultrathin silicon nitride (SiN x ) solid-state nanopores of diameters ranging from 1.5 to 5.5 nm. For a 2.5-nm-diameter pore, we find that, in a threshold electric-field regime of ∼30 to 100 MV/m, cyt c is able to squeeze through the pore. As electric fields inside the pore are increased, the unfolded state of cyt c is thermodynamically stabilized, facilitating its translocation. In contrast, for 1.5- and 2.0-nm-diameter pores, translocation occurs only by threading of the fully unfolded protein after it transitions through a higher energy unfolding intermediate state at the mouth of the pore. The relative energies between the metastable, intermediate, and unfolded protein states are extractedmore »using a simple thermodynamic model that is dictated by the relatively slow (∼ms) protein translocation times for passing through the nanopore. These experiments map the various modes of protein translocation through a constriction, which opens avenues for exploring protein folding structures, internal contacts, and electric-field–induced deformability.« less
  5. Initiated chemical vapor deposition (iCVD) was used to coat two porous substrates (i.e., hydrophilic cellulose acetate (CA) and hydrophobic polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE)) with a crosslinked fluoropolymer to improve membrane wetting resistance. The coated CA membrane was superhydrophobic and symmetric. The coated PTFE membrane was hydrophobic and asymmetric, with smaller pore size and lower porosity on the top surface than on the bottom surface. Membrane performance was tested in membrane distillation experiments with (1) a high-salinity feed solution and (2) a surfactant-containing feed solution. In both cases, the coated membranes had higher wetting resistance than the uncoated membranes. Notably, wetting resistances were better predicted by LEP distributions than by minimum LEP values. When LEP distributions were skewed towards high LEP values (i.e., when small pores with high LEP were greater in number), significant (measurable) salt passage did not occur. For the high-salinity feed solution, the coated PTFE membrane had greater wetting resistance than the coated CA membrane; thus, reduced surface pore size/porosity (which may reduce intrapore scaling) was more effective than increased surface hydrophobicity (which may reduce surface nucleation) in preventing scaling-induced wetting. Reduced pore size/porosity was equally as effective as increased hydrophobicity in resisting surfactant-induced wetting. However, reduced porosity can negativelymore »impact water flux; this represents a permeability/wetting resistance tradeoff in membrane distillation – especially for high-salinity applications. Membrane and/or membrane coating properties must be optimized to overcome this permeability/wetting resistance tradeoff and make MD viable for the treatment of challenging streams. Then, increasing hydrophobicity may not be necessary to impart high wetting resistance to porous membranes. These results are important for future membrane design, especially as manufacturers seek to replace perfluorinated materials with environmentally friendly alternatives.« less