skip to main content

Title: The long and the short of it: Mechanisms of synchronous and compensatory dynamics across temporal scales

Synchronous dynamics (fluctuations that occur in unison) are universal phenomena with widespread implications for ecological stability. Synchronous dynamics can amplify the destabilizing effect of environmental variability on ecosystem functions such as productivity, whereas the inverse, compensatory dynamics, can stabilize function. Here we combine simulation and empirical analyses to elucidate mechanisms that underlie patterns of synchronous versus compensatory dynamics. In both simulated and empirical communities, we show that synchronous and compensatory dynamics are not mutually exclusive but instead can vary by timescale. Our simulations identify multiple mechanisms that can generate timescale‐specific patterns, including different environmental drivers, diverse life histories, dispersal, and non‐stationary dynamics. We find that traditional metrics for quantifying synchronous dynamics are often biased toward long‐term drivers and may miss the importance of short‐term drivers. Our findings indicate key mechanisms to consider when assessing synchronous versus compensatory dynamics and our approach provides a pathway for disentangling these dynamics in natural systems.

more » « less
Award ID(s):
2033292 1832221 2023474 1929393 2019528 1714195
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley Blackwell (John Wiley & Sons)
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    Phenology has long been hypothesized as an avenue for niche partitioning or interspecific facilitation, both promoting species coexistence. Tropical plant communities exhibit striking diversity in reproductive phenology, but many are also noted for large synchronous reproductive events. Here we study whether the phenology of seed fall in such communities is nonrandom, the temporal scales of phenological patterns, and ecological factors that drive reproductive phenology. We applied multivariate wavelet analysis to test for phenological synchrony versus compensatory dynamics (i.e., antisynchronous patterns where one species' decline is compensated by the rise of another) among species and across temporal scales. We used data from long‐term seed rain monitoring of hyperdiverse plant communities in the western Amazon. We found significant synchronous whole‐community phenology at multiple timescales, consistent with shared environmental responses or positive interactions among species. We also observed both compensatory and synchronous phenology within groups of species (confamilials) likely to share traits and seed dispersal mechanisms. Wind‐dispersed species exhibited significant synchrony at ~6‐month scales, suggesting these species might share phenological niches to match the seasonality of wind. Our results suggest that community phenology is shaped by shared environmental responses but that the diversity of tropical plant phenology may partly result from temporal niche partitioning. The scale‐specificity and time‐localized nature of community phenology patterns highlights the importance of multiple and shifting drivers of phenology.

    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Understanding the mechanisms governing ecological stability—why a property such as primary productivity is stable in some communities and variable in others—has long been a focus of ecology. Compensatory dynamics, in which anti‐synchronous fluctuations between populations buffer against fluctuations at the community level, are a key theoretical mechanism of stability. Classically, compensatory dynamics have been quantified using a variance ratio approach that compares the ratio between community variance and aggregate population variance, such that a lower ratio indicates compensation and a higher ratio indicates synchrony among species fluctuations. However, population dynamics may be influenced by different drivers that operate on different timescales, and evidence from aquatic systems indicates that communities can be compensatory on some timescales and synchronous on others. The variance ratio and related metrics cannot reflect this timescale specificity, yet have remained popular, especially in terrestrial systems. Here, we develop a timescale‐specific variance ratio approach that formally decomposes the classical variance ratio according to the timescales of distinct contributions. The approach is implemented in a new R package, called tsvr, that accompanies this paper. We apply our approach to a long‐term, multisite grassland community dataset. Our approach demonstrates that the degree of compensation vs. synchrony in community dynamics can vary by timescale. Across sites, population variability was typically greater over longer compared to shorter timescales. At some sites, minimal timescale specificity in compensatory dynamics translated this pattern of population variability into a similar pattern of greater community variability on longer compared to shorter timescales. But at other sites, differentially stronger compensatory dynamics at longer compared to shorter timescales produced lower‐than‐expected community variability on longer timescales. Within every site, there were plots that exhibited shifts in the strength of compensation between timescales. Our results highlight that compensatory vs. synchronous dynamics are intrinsically timescale‐dependent concepts, and our timescale‐specific variance ratio provides a metric to quantify timescale specificity and relate it back to the classic variance ratio.

    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Winters are changing rapidly across the globe but the implications for aquatic productivity and food webs are not well understood. In addition, the degree to which winter dynamics in aquatic systems respond to large‐scale climate versus ecosystem‐level factors is unclear but important for understanding and managing potential changes. We used a unique winter data set from the Upper Mississippi River System to explore spatial and temporal patterns in phytoplankton biomass (chlorophylla, CHL) and associated environmental covariates across 25 years and ∼1,500 river km. To assess the role of regional climate versus site‐specific drivers of winter CHL, we evaluated whether there were coherent long‐term CHL dynamics from north to south and across lotic‐lentic areas. We then estimated the degree to which these patterns were associated with climate variability (i.e., the Multivariate El Nino‐Southern Oscillation Index), winter severity (freezing degree days), river discharge, or site‐specific environmental variables (ice depth, snow depth, and nutrient concentrations). We found that winter CHL was typically highest in ice‐free reaches and backwater lakes, occasionally exceeding summer values. We did not find highly synchronous CHL dynamics across the basin, but instead show that temporal trends were independent among river reaches and lotic‐lentic areas of the river. Moreover, after accounting for these spatial dynamics, we found that CHL was most responsive to winter air temperature, being consistently higher in years with warmer winters across the basin. These results indicate that although productivity dynamics are highly dynamic within large river ecosystems, changes in the duration and severity of winter may uniformly increase wintertime productivity.

    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Vegetation optimizes its geochemical environment for resource management via root exudation. We refer to the soil zone where biogeochemical behavior is significantly influenced, directly or indirectly, by root processes as the vegetation induced reactive zone (VIRZ). Root exudates react with VIRZ soil substrates creating temporally variable chemical environments through depth that extend below the rooting zone, impacting weathering, and releasing solutes and gases. We present a new framework, REWTCrunch, to capture VIRZ dynamics by integrating three modeling advances: the multicomponent reactive transport model CrunchFlow, the root exudation model REWT, and the multilayer canopy‐root ecohydrologic model MLCan. REWTCrunch's high‐resolution, process‐based simulation of root exudation, and the transport and transformation of carbon (C) and nutrients according to mass‐balanced and charge‐balanced reaction networks gives new insight into vertically resolved root‐soil‐microbe‐water interactions and their influence on solute fluxes at a daily timescale. We benchmark REWT and CrunchFlow, illustrate coupling mechanisms, and present REWTCrunch simulations for an agricultural site in the US Midwest. Results demonstrate root‐sourced reactive C can augment or reduce solute concentrations in the soil by several orders of magnitude. Silicate weathering products illustrate after‐harvest effects of plant C inputs in leaching patterns. Calcium simulations reveal the development of a stable weathering front. Aluminum concentrations are particularly responsive to root‐sourced reactivity, and analysis of leaching concentration versus leaching flux indicates hysteresis behavior. REWTCrunch significant improves our ability to simulate the link between root processes and soil biogeochemistry, thereby filling an important gap in the numerical simulation of root processes, weathering, and long‐term soil health.

    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Seagrasses form productive marine ecosystems that serve as important foraging grounds for grazers. Meadow productivity is vulnerable to environmental change, however, because environmental factors often strongly regulate seagrass growth. Understanding effects of grazing and environmental driver interactions on growth dynamics is therefore needed to ensure the long‐term sustainability of seagrass meadow foraging habitats. We simulated natural green turtle (Chelonia mydas) grazing by experimentally clipping seagrass for 16 months in aThalassia testudinummeadow and measured how responses in linear growth, production, the production‐to‐biomass ratio (P : B; compensatory growth), and leaf area index differed between clipped and unclipped seagrass in response to in situ changes in temperature and salinity. While increasing temperature and salinity had positive and negative effects, respectively, on growth rates, clipping did not alter the relationship between these abiotic drivers and seagrass growth. Simulated grazing did, however, alter effects of temperature on seagrass P : B ratio and leaf area index dynamics. Each increased significantly with temperature; however, P : B ratios only increased in experimentally clipped seagrass, whereas leaf area index only increased in unclipped seagrass. These results suggest that, given temperature‐stimulated growth, grazed seagrass prioritizes increasing biomass production, whereas ungrazed seagrass prioritizes increasing photosynthetic surface area. In addition, our results demonstrate that the strength of the compensatory growth response to grazing inT. testudinumis seasonally dependent, highlighting the importance of biotic‐abiotic interactions in driving growth dynamics. In a future with increasing grazer abundance and climate‐driven stressors, understanding these types of interactions will be critical for long‐term sustainability of seagrass ecosystems.

    more » « less