Title: Persistent decadal differences in plant communities assembled under contrasting climate conditions
Abstract Plant community assembly outcomes can be contingent upon establishment year (year effects) due to variations in the environment. Stochastic events such as interannual variability in climate, particularly in the first year of community assembly, contribute to unpredictable community outcomes over the short term, but less is known about whether year effects produce transient or persistent states on a decadal timescale. To test for short‐term (5‐year) and persistent (decadal) effects of establishment year climate on community assembly outcomes, we restored prairie in an agricultural field using the same methods in four different years (2010, 2012, 2014, and 2016) that captured a wide range of initial (planting) year climate conditions. Species composition was measured for 5 years in all four restored prairies and for 9 and 11 years in the two oldest restored prairies established under average precipitation and extreme drought conditions. The composition of the four assembled communities showed large and significant differences in the first year of restoration, followed by dynamic change over time along a similar trajectory due to a temporary flush of annual volunteer species. Sown perennial species eventually came to dominate all communities, but communities remained distinct from each other in year five. Precipitation in June and July of the establishment year explained short‐term coarse community metrics (i.e., species richness and grass/forb cover), with wet establishment years resulting in a higher cover of grasses and dry establishment years resulting in a higher cover of forbs in restored communities. Short‐term differences in community composition, species richness, and grass/forb cover in restorations established under average precipitation and drought conditions persisted for 9–11 years, with low interannual variability in the composition of each prairie over the long term, indicating persistently different states on a decadal timescale. Thus, year effects resulting from stochastic variation in climate can have decadal effects on community assembly outcomes.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2025849
PAR ID:
10467505
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley Periodicals LLC
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Ecological Applications
Volume:
33
Issue:
3
ISSN:
1051-0761
Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract Year effects are contingencies in community assembly ascribed to differences among years in which communities begin to establish and add uncertainty to restoration outcomes. Year effects are often attributed to differences in climate, but no studies have captured enough natural variation in climate among years communities establish to evaluate how fully planting‐year climate may explain year effects.We restored prairie communities every other year for 12 years, capturing natural interannual variation in climate to test the hypothesis that dissimilarity in planting‐year climate predicts dissimilarity in developing plant community composition. We also examined the extent to which planting‐year precipitation and temperature explain cover of species and major compositional groups to interpret climate‐community dissimilarity relationships.Percent cover of each plant species was surveyed in each restoration for the first 3 years of community development. Community dissimilarity matrices were related to planting‐year climate dissimilarity matrices using multiple regression on distance matrices. The explanatory power of planting‐year climate variables on the cover of individual species and broad compositional groups was examined using linear and exponential models.Dissimilarities in planting‐year precipitation variables were typically the strongest statistical predictors of community dissimilarity, and differences in planting‐year precipitation received shortly after sowing remained a significant predictor of community dissimilarity into the third growing season.In first‐year communities, forb cover was dominated by volunteer species and positively related to annual average daily temperature, whereas total annual precipitation explained significant variation in sown C4grasses. In subsequent years, forb cover (increasingly sown species) was best predicted by and inversely related to the early growing season window of the variable (precipitation) that predicted C4grass cover in the establishment year. Likewise, C4grass cover in subsequent years was best predicted by and inversely related to the early season window of the variable (temperature) that predicted forb cover in the establishment year.Synthesis and applications. This study demonstrates planting‐year climate can predict the cover of frequently occurring species and major compositional groups in prairie developing from seed. Our results advance understanding of factors contributing to variable restoration outcomes, which is needed to achieve conservation goals. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract PremiseTallgrass prairies are important yet endangered ecosystems of central North America and subjects of many ecological restoration projects. Prairie restorations commonly succeed in establishing native grasses but can stagnate in the early stages of succession with limited diversity and composition of native forbs. Establishment of desirable forbs introduced into grass‐dominated restorations can be difficult because of intense competition. Late‐successional arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungi cultured from undisturbed, remnant prairies have been shown to improve restoration outcomes, with most previous tests introducing AM fungi during initial establishment of prairie restoration in post‐agricultural fields. Much less research has been performed on the benefits of AM fungi in older restorations. MethodsIn this experiment, we determined whether inoculation with native AM fungi would improve the establishment of 12 native prairie forb species in a decades‐old, restored prairie dominated by native grasses. We followed the survival and growth of uninoculated and AM fungi‐inoculated plants over two growing seasons. ResultsWe found that most species, including high‐conservation‐value species such as purple prairie clover (Dalea purpurea) and lead plant (Amorpha canescens) benefited in terms of increased survival and/or growth. ConclusionsBy showing that inoculation with native, late successional AM fungi improved establishment of desirable native plants even in a decades‐old restored prairie, this study adds to confidence in the benefits of native AM fungi to prairie restoration in general, and specifically demonstrates the potential value of native AM fungi to efforts to enrich existing grass‐dominated restored prairies with high conservation value plant species. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract IntroductionMany prairie restorations lack the plant diversity seen in remnant prairies. Most restoration practices focus on reestablishing the plant community but overlook the soil microbial community even though microbes are critical for plant establishment and ecosystem functioning. Developing techniques that increase the similarity of soil microbial communities between restorations and remnants is critical to ensuring diverse and fully functional restored habitats. ObjectivesIn this study, we quantified differences in soil microbial communities between remnant and restored prairies and evaluated whether soil or compost “tea” could speed restored microbial community reassembly. We also present detailed instructions on how to brew and apply “tea” of prairie soil or municipal compost. MethodsFirst, we compared soil microbial communities between five remnant and five restored prairies in southeast Michigan, United States. Next, we investigated whether soil and compost teas could effectively introduce prairie soil microbes to restored prairies and whether the teas affected native plant establishment. ResultsWe found significant differences in bacterial community composition between remnant and restored prairies, despite at least 10 years of community development in the restorations. Although some microbial taxa appeared to proliferate in the teas, neither tea treatment effectively reintroduced microbes into the soil or increased native plant establishment. ConclusionsOur tea applications did not cause restored prairie soil microbial communities to become more similar to those in remnant prairies and did not improve native prairie plant establishment. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract Enhancing resilience in formerly degraded ecosystems is an important goal of restoration ecology. However, evidence for the recovery of resilience and its underlying mechanisms require long‐term experiments and comparison with reference ecosystems. We used data from an experimental prairie restoration that featured long‐term soil heterogeneity manipulations and data from two long‐term experiments located in a comparable remnant (reference) prairie to (1) quantify the recovery of ecosystem functioning (i.e., productivity) relative to remnant prairie, (2) compare the resilience of restored and remnant prairies to a natural drought, and (3) test whether soil heterogeneity enhances resilience of restored prairie. We compared sensitivity and legacy effects between prairie types (remnant and restored) and among four prairie sites that included two remnant prairie sites and prairie restored under homogeneous and heterogeneous soil conditions. We measured sensitivity and resilience as the proportional change in aboveground net primary productivity (ANPP) during and following drought (sensitivity and legacy effects, respectively) relative to average ANPP based on 4 pre‐drought years (2014–2017). In nondrought years, total ANPP was similar between remnant and restored prairie, but remnant prairie had higher grass productivity and lower forb productivity compared with restored prairie. These ANPP patterns generally persisted during drought. The sensitivity of total ANPP to drought was similar between restored and remnant prairie, but grasses in the restored prairie were more sensitive to drought. Post‐drought legacy effects were more positive in the restored prairie, and we attributed this to the more positive and less variable legacy response of forb ANPP in the restored prairie, especially in the heterogeneous soil treatment. Our results suggest that productivity recovers in restored prairie and exhibits similar sensitivity to drought as in remnant prairie. Furthermore, creating heterogeneity promotes forb productivity and enhances restored prairie resilience to drought. 
    more » « less
  5. Restoration outcomes are notoriously difficult to predict and often fall short of restoration goals. Post‐restoration management actions may help overcome barriers to successful establishment, such as dispersal limitations and competition. Layering these management actions to increase the intensity of disturbances may improve restoration outcomes, but they also can be expensive and laborious, depending on the intensity or number of actions implemented. We investigated a series of disturbance intensities on previously restored tallgrass prairies using a randomized block design. Combinations of seeding, harrowing (low intensity disturbance), disking (high intensity disturbance), and herbicide were implemented after a prescribed burn. After 11–14 years, we measured percent cover of all species present to determine long‐term effectiveness. We found that the high intensity disturbance treatment increased native species richness by over 40% and native species Shannon diversity by 15% when compared to control plots. Overall diversity and composition of the plots varied among sites that were treated in different years, indicating that seed mix composition and site conditions were still likely important determinants of community outcomes. Regardless, the consistency of the high intensity management actions to increase site richness and diversity after more than a decade may allow managers to achieve restoration goals, even if later management is limited, justifying the time and resources to enhance existing restorations. 
    more » « less