skip to main content

Explore Research Products in the NSF-PAR

  • NSF Public Access
  • Search Results
  • On the interface of enzyme and spatial confinement: The impacts of confinement rigidity, shape, and surface properties on the interplay of enzyme structure, dynamics, and function

This content will become publicly available on December 1, 2024

Title: On the interface of enzyme and spatial confinement: The impacts of confinement rigidity, shape, and surface properties on the interplay of enzyme structure, dynamics, and function

Confining proteins in synthetic nanoscale spatial compartments has offered a cell-free avenue to understand enzyme structure–function relationships and complex cellular processes near the physiological conditions, an important branch of fundamental protein biophysics studies. Enzyme confinement has also provided advancement in biocatalysis by offering enhanced enzyme reusability, cost-efficiency, and substrate selectivity in certain cases for research and industrial applications. However, the primary research efforts in this area have been focused on the development of novel confinement materials and investigating protein adsorption/interaction with various surfaces, leaving a fundamental knowledge gap, namely, the lack of understanding of the confined enzymes (note that enzyme adsorption to or interactions with surfaces differs from enzyme confinement as the latter offers an enhanced extent of restriction to enzyme movement and/or conformational flexibility). In particular, there is limited understanding of enzymes' structure, dynamics, translocation (into biological pores), folding, and aggregation in extreme cases upon confinement, and how confinement properties such as the size, shape, and rigidity affect these details. The first barrier to bridge this gap is the difficulty in “penetrating” the “shielding” of the confinement walls experimentally; confinement could also lead to high heterogeneity and dynamics in the entrapped enzymes, challenging most protein-probing experimental techniques. The complexity is raised by the variety in the possible confinement environments that enzymes may encounter in nature or on lab benches, which can be categorized to rigid confinement with regular shapes, rigid restriction without regular shapes, and flexible/dynamic confinement which also introduces crowding effects. Thus, to bridge such a knowledge gap, it is critical to combine advanced materials and cutting-edge techniques to re-create the various confinement conditions and understand enzymes therein. We have spearheaded in this challenging area by creating various confinement conditions to restrict enzymes while exploring experimental techniques to understand enzyme behaviors upon confinement at the molecular/residue level. This review is to summarize our key findings on the molecular level details of enzymes confined in (i) rigid compartments with regular shapes based on pre-formed, mesoporous nanoparticles and Metal–Organic Frameworks/Covalent-Organic Frameworks (MOFs/COFs), (ii) rigid confinement with irregular crystal defects with shapes close to the outline of the confined enzymes via co-crystallization of enzymes with certain metal ions and ligands in the aqueous phase (biomineralization), and (iii) flexible, dynamic confinement created by protein-friendly polymeric materials and assemblies. Under each case, we will focus our discussion on (a) the way to load enzymes into the confined spaces, (b) the structural basis of the function and behavior of enzymes within each compartment environments, and (c) technical advances of our methodology to probe the needed structural information. The purposes are to depict the chemical physics details of enzymes at the challenging interface of natural molecules and synthetic compartment materials, guide the selection of enzyme confinement platforms for various applications, and generate excitement in the community on combining cutting-edge technologies and synthetic materials to better understand enzyme performance in biophysics, biocatalysis, and biomedical applications.

  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1942596 2306137 2217474
NSF-PAR ID:
10477358
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
AIP Publishing
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Chemical Physics Reviews
Volume:
4
Issue:
4
ISSN:
2688-4070
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ( , Green chemistry)
    null (Ed.)
    Metal–organic frameworks/materials (MOFs/MOMs) are advanced enzyme immobilization platforms that improve biocatalysis, materials science, and protein biophysics. A unique way to immobilize enzymes is co-crystallization/co-precipitation, which removes the limitation on enzyme/substrate size. Thus far, most enzyme@MOF composites rely on the use of non-sustainable chemicals and, in certain cases, heavy metals, which not only creates concerns regarding environmental conservation but also limits their applications in nutrition and biomedicine. Here, we show that a dimeric compound derived from lignin, 5,5′-dehydrodivanillate (DDVA), co-precipitates with enzymes and low-toxicity metals, Ca2+ and Zn2+, and forms stable enzyme@Ca/Zn–MOM composites. We demonstrated this strategy on four enzymes with different isoelectric points (IEPs), molecular weights, and substrate sizes. Furthermore, we found that all enzymes displayed slightly different but reasonable catalytic efficiencies upon immobilization in the Ca–DDVA and Zn–DDVA MOMs, as well as reasonable reusability in both composites. We then probed the structural basis of such differences using a representative enzyme and found enhanced restriction of enzymes in Zn–DDVA than in Ca–DDVA, which might have caused the activity difference. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first aqueous-phase, one-pot synthesis of a lignin-derived “green” enzyme@MOF/MOM platform that can host enzymes without any limitations on enzyme IEP, molecular weight, and substrate size. The different morphologies and crystallinities of the composites formed by Ca–DDVA and Zn–DDVA MOMs broaden their applications depending on the problem of interest. Our approach of enzyme immobilization not only improves the sustainability/reusability of almost all enzymes but also reduces/eliminates the use of non-sustainable resources. This synthesis method has a negligible environmental impact while the products are non-toxic to living things and the environment. The biocompatibility also makes it possible to carry out enzyme delivery/release for nutritional or biomedical applications via our “green” biocomposites. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; ; ; ; ; ( , Chem catalysis)
    null (Ed.)
    Site-directed spin labeling (SDSL) in combination with electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy probes the otherwise inaccessible structural information in complex biological systems. We recently extended SDSL-EPR to reveal the relative orientation and backbone dynamics of enzymes upon encapsulation in mesoporous nanostructures, which set the structural basis underlying the observed biocatalytic activity. Our strategy had generated interest in the biocatalysis community, and thus in this resource article, we contribute an introduction to the principles and experimental procedure that generalize SDSL-EPR to heterogeneous biocatalysis. We will focus on enzymes in mesoporous materials with examples demonstrating the methods and cautions of potential pitfalls. The ultimate goal is to provide the biocatalysis community with a powerful resource to fill in a long-standing knowledge gap in heterogeneous biocatalysis and the structure-function relationship of enzymes at the interface of enzyme-mesoporous materials and utilize the structural insights to guide the rational design of porous platforms for enzyme immobilization. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; ; ( , Transactions of the Society for Biomaterials)
    Statement of Purpose Hybrid nanoparticles in which a polymer is used to stabilize the secondary structure of enzyme provide a means to preserve its activity in non-native environments. This approach is illustrated here with horseradish peroxidase (HRP), an important heme enzyme used in medical diagnostic, biosensing, and biotechnological applications. Polymer chaperones in these polymer-enzyme complex (PEC) nanoparticles can enhance the utility of enzymes in unfavorable environments. Structural analysis of the PECs is a crucial link in the machine-learning driven iterative optimization cycle of polymer synthesis and testing. Here, we discuss the utility of small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCMD) for evaluating PECs. Materials and Methods Six polymers were synthesized by automated photoinduced electron/energy transfer-reversible addition-fragmentation chain-transfer (PET-RAFT) polymerization directly in 96-well plates.1 Multiple molar ratios of enzyme:polymer (1:1, 1:5, 1:10, and 1:50) were characterized. HRP was mixed with the polymer and heated to 65 °C for 1 hr to form PECs. Enzyme assay and circular dichroism measurements were performed along with SAXS and QCMD to understand polymer-protein interactions. SAXS data were obtained at NSLS-II beamline 16-ID. Results and Discussion SAXS data were analyzed to determine the radius of gyration (Rg), Porod exponent and pair distance distribution functions (P(r)) (Figure 1). Rg, which corresponds to the size of the PEC nanoparticles, is sensitive to the polydispersity of the solution and does not change significantly in the presence of the polymer GEP1. Notably, the maximal dimension does not change as significantly upon heating to denaturation in the case of the PEC as it does with HRP alone. The effect of denaturation induced by heating seems to depend on the molar ratio of the polymer to enzyme. The Porod exponent, which is related to roughness, decreased from about 4 to 3 upon complexation indicating polymer binding to the enzyme’s surface. These were confirmed by modeling the structures of the HRP, the polymer and the PEC were modeled using DAMMIF/DAMMIN and MONSA (ATSAS software). The changes observed in the structure could be correlated to the measured enzymatic activity. Figure 2 shows the evolution of the PEC when the polymer is deposited onto the enzyme immobilized on Figure 1. P(r) plots for PEC vs. HRP before and after heating, illustrating the increased enzymatic stability due to polymer additives. gold-coated QCM sensors. The plots show the changes in frequency (f) and dissipation (D) with time as HRP is first deposited and is followed by the adsorption of the polymer. Large f and D show that the polymer forms a complex with HRP. Such changes were not observed with negative controls, Pluronics and poly(ethylene glycol). Comparison of the data from free particles in solution with QCM data from immobilized enzymes, shows that the conformation of the complexes in solution and surface-bound HRP could be different. This way, we were able to explore the various states of complex formation under different conditions with different polymers. Figure 2. QCMD data showing the interaction between the immobilized HRP and the polymer. 3rd and 5th harmonics are plotted (blue -f; red-D). Conclusion SAXS and QCMD data show that stabilization of the enzyme activity by inhibiting the unraveling of the secondary structure as seen in size, surface roughness, pair distribution function and percent helicity. Acknowledgment This work was supported by NSF grant 2009942. References [1] Tamasi, M, et al. Adv Intell Syst 2020, 2(2): 1900126. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; et al ( , Cell reports physical science)
    null (Ed.)
    Protein transfer into nanoscale compartments is critical for many cellular/life processes, yet there are few reports on how compartment properties impact the protein orientation during a transfer. Such a knowledge gap limits a deeper understanding of the protein transfer mechanism, which could be bridged using nanoporous materials. Here, we use a mesoporous silica, a covalent organic framework, and a metal-organic framework with charged, hydrophobic, and neutral surfaces, respectively, to elucidate the impact of channel properties on the transfer of a model protein, lysozyme. Using site-directed spin labeling and time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, we reveal that the transfer can be a multi-step process depending on channel properties and depict the relative orientation changes of lysozyme upon transfer into each channel. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first structural insight into protein orientation upon transfer into different compartments, meaningful for the rational design of synthetic materials to host enzymes or mimic the cellular compartments. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ( , Small)
    Abstract

    Enzyme immobilization is an essential technology for commercializing biocatalysis. It imparts stability, recoverability, and other valuable features that improve the effectiveness of biocatalysts. While many avenues to join an enzyme to solid phases exist, protein‐mediated immobilization is rapidly developing and has many advantages. Protein‐mediated immobilization allows for the binding interaction to be genetically coded, can be used to create artificial multienzyme cascades, and enables modular designs that expand the variety of enzymes immobilized. By designing around binding interactions between protein domains, they can be integrated into functional materials for protein immobilization. These materials are framed within the context of biocatalytic performance, immobilization efficiency, and stability of the materials. In this review, supports composed entirely of protein are discussed first, with systems such as cellulosomes and protein cages being discussed alongside newer technologies like spore‐based biocatalysts and forizymes. Protein‐composite materials such as polymersomes and protein–inorganic supraparticles are then discussed to demonstrate how protein‐mediated strategies are applied to many classes of solid materials. Critical analysis and future directions of protein‐based immobilization are then discussed, with a particular focus on both computational and design strategies to advance this area of research and make it more broadly applicable to many classes of enzymes.

     
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email