skip to main content


Title: On the Accuracy of Adiabaticity Parameter Estimations Using Magnetospheric Models
Abstract

Recent studies have found that even during quiet times, observed proton isotropic boundaries (IBs) are often projected to the region of high adiabaticity parameter (K≈30), whereis the ratio of magnetic field line radius of curvature to the particle gyroradius. This contradicts the accepted hypothesis that current sheet scattering (CSS) is the dominant mechanism of IB formation becauseK≈8 would be expected for this mechanism. We used magnetohydrodynamic simulations and empirical models to computeKfor 30‐keV proton IB observations within 3 hr of local midnight. We found that neither class of model reliably estimatesKunless supported by magnetic field observations in the current sheet. magnetohydrodynamic simulations produced higherKvalues than expected for CSS (K = 15–30), and empirical models gave lower values (K < 4). We obtained reliable estimates ofKby controlling for the accuracy of the normal component and the gradient of the radial component in the neutral sheet, using observations from three Time History of Events and Macroscale Interactions during Substorms satellites. For the first time, we demonstrated that both these variables should be taken into account for the accurate estimation of the curvature radius. This greatly reduced the spread ofKvalues, indicating that much of the previous spread was due to errors in the magnetic field but also that these errors can be controlled. Most of the corrected values fall within the expected range for CSS, supporting the hypothesis that the IB's were formed by CSS. Accounting for all model results, we obtain an average corrected value ofK = 6.0.

 
more » « less
Award ID(s):
1663770
PAR ID:
10480338
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics
Volume:
124
Issue:
3
ISSN:
2169-9380
Page Range / eLocation ID:
1785 to 1805
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    There is considerable evidence that current sheet scattering (CSS) plays an important role in isotropic boundary (IB) formation during quiet time. However, IB formation can also result from scattering by electromagnetic ion cyclotron waves, which are much more prevalent during storm time. The effectiveness of CSS can be estimated by the parameter, the ratio of the field line radius of curvature to the particle gyroradius. Using magnetohydrodynamic and empirical models, we estimated the parameterKassociated with storm time IB observations on the nightside. We used magnetic field observations from spacecraft in the magnetotail to estimate and correct for errors in theKvalues computed by the models. We find that the magnetohydrodynamic and empirical models produce fairly similar results without correction and that correction increases this similarity. Accounting for uncertainty in both the latitude of the IB and the threshold value ofKrequired for CSS, we found that 29–54% of the IB observations satisfied the criteria for CSS. We found no correlation between the correctedKand magnetic local time, which further supports the hypothesis that CSS played a significant role in forming the observed IBs.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    We present analysis of 17,043 proton kinetic-scale current sheets (CSs) collected over 124 days of Wind spacecraft measurements in the solar wind at 11 samples s−1magnetic field resolution. The CSs have thickness,λ,from a few tens to one thousand kilometers with typical values around 100 km, or within about 0.1–10λpin terms of local proton inertial length,λp. We found that the current density is larger for smaller-scale CSs,J0≈ 6 nAm−2· (λ/100 km)−0.56, but does not statistically exceed a critical value,JA,corresponding to the drift between ions and electrons of local Alvén speed. The observed trend holds in normalized units:J0/JA0.17·(λ/λp)0.51. The CSs are statistically force-free with magnetic shear angle correlated with CS spatial scale:Δθ19°·(λ/λp)0.5. The observed correlations are consistent with local turbulence being the source of proton kinetic-scale CSs in the solar wind, while the mechanisms limiting the current density remain to be understood.

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Previously, Tsurutani and Lakhina (2014,https://doi.org/10.1002/2013GL058825) created estimates for a “perfect” interplanetary coronal mass ejection and performed simple calculations for the response of geospace, including. In this study, these estimates are used to drive a coupled magnetohydrodynamic‐ring current‐ionosphere model of geospace to obtain more physically accurate estimates of the geospace response to such an event. The sudden impulse phase is examined and compared to the estimations of Tsurutani and Lakhina (2014,https://doi.org/10.1002/2013GL058825). The physics‐based simulation yields similar estimates for Dst rise, magnetopause compression, and equatorialvalues as the previous study. However, results diverge away from the equator.values in excess of 30 nT/s are found as low asmagnetic latitude. Under southward interplanetary magnetic field conditions, magnetopause erosion combines with strong region one Birkeland currents to intensify theresponse. Values obtained here surpass those found in historically recorded events and set the upper threshold of extreme geomagnetically induced current activity at Earth.

     
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    We analyze the drivers, distribution, and properties of the relativistic electron precipitation (REP) detected near midnight by the Polar Orbiting Environmental Satellites (POES) and Meteorological Operational (MetOp) satellites, critical for understanding radiation belt losses and nightside atmospheric energy input. REP is either driven by wave‐particle interactions (isolated precipitation within the outer radiation belt), or current sheet scattering (CSS; precipitation with energy dispersion), or a combination of the two. We evaluate the L‐MLT distribution for the identified REP events in which only one process evidently drove the precipitation (∼10% of the REP near midnight). We show that the two mechanisms coexist and drive precipitation in a broadL‐shell range (4–7). However, wave‐driven REP was also observed atL < 4, whereas CSS‐driven REP was also detected atL > 7. Moreover, we estimate the magnetotail stretching during each REP event using the magnetic field observations from the Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite (GOES). Both wave‐particle interactions and CSS drive REP in association with a stretched magnetotail, although CSS‐driven REP potentially shows more pronounced stretching. Wave‐driven REP events are localized inLshell and often occur on spatial scales of <0.3 L. Using either proton precipitation (observed by POES/MetOp during wave‐driven REP) as a proxy for electromagnetic ion cyclotron (EMIC) wave activity or wave observations (from GOES and the Van Allen Probes) at the conjugate event location, we find that ∼73% wave‐driven REP events are associated with EMIC waves.

     
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Magnetic field‐line curvature scattering (FLCS) of energetic particles in the equatorial magnetotail results in isotropization of pitch‐angle distributions, loss‐cone filling, and precipitation above a minimum energy at a given latitude. At a fixed energy, the lowest latitude of isotropization is the isotropy boundary (IB) for that energy. Nominally, the IB (latitude) exhibits a characteristic energy dependence due to the monotonic variation of the equatorial magnetic field intensity with radial distance. Deviations from this nominal IB dispersion can occur if the radial variation (spatial or temporal) is non‐mononotic and/or if other precipitation mechanisms prevail. With its sensitive and detailed measurements of electron spectra up to relativistic energies, ELFIN's recent observations reveal a variety of electron IBe patterns near magnetic midnight which are repeatable enough to warrant classification. This study aims to categorize the various IBe patterns observed by ELFIN's high‐fidelity but short lived dataset (a few months), compare them with simultaneous nearby POES observations, which are made with a limited energy coverage and resolution but last for decades, and discuss their possible interpretation. The general agreement between ELFIN and POES IB observations indicate a relatively large‐scale nature of IBe patterns. Surprisingly, there exists a large number (up to 2/3 of all events) of non‐monotonic‐or steep/multiple‐IB patterns. This suggest an abundance of non‐trivial tail current sheet structures or a mixed contribution of two mechanisms in the vicinity of IBe in these cases.

     
    more » « less