An official website of the United States government
Abstract BackgroundSelf-regulated learning (SRL) strategies can be domain specific. However, it remains unclear whether this specificity extends to different subtopics within a single subject domain. In this study, we collected data from 210 college students engaged in a computer-based learning environment to examine the heterogeneous manifestations of learning behaviors across four distinct subtopics in introductory statistics. Further, we explore how the time spent engaging in metacognitive strategies correlated with learning gain in those subtopics. ResultsBy employing two different analytical approaches that combine data-driven learning analytics (i.e., sequential pattern mining in this case), and theory-informed methods (i.e., coherence analysis), we discovered significant variability in the frequency of learning patterns that are potentially associated with SRL-relevant strategies across four subtopics. In a subtopic related to calculations, engagement in coherent quizzes (i.e., a type of metacognitive strategy) was found to be significantly less related to learning gains compared to other subtopics. Additionally, we found that students with different levels of prior knowledge and learning gains demonstrated varying degrees of engagement in learning patterns in an SRL context. ConclusionThe findings imply that the use—and the effectiveness—of learning patterns that are potentially associated with SRL-relevant strategies varies not only across contexts and domains, but even across different subtopics within a single subject. This underscores the importance of personalized, context-aware SRL training interventions in computer-based learning environments, which could significantly enhance learning outcomes by addressing the heterogeneous relationships between SRL activities and outcomes. Further, we suggest theoretical implications of subtopic-specific heterogeneity within the context of various SRL models. Understanding SRL heterogeneity enhances these theories, offering more nuanced insights into learners’ metacognitive strategies across different subtopics.
more »
« less
Building Learner Activity Models From Log Data Using Sequence Mapping and Hidden Markov Models
Open-ended learning environments (OELEs) involve high learner agency in defining learning goals and multiple pathways to achieve those goals. These tasks involve learners transitioning through self-regulated learning (SRL) phases by actively setting goals, applying different strategies for those goals, and monitoring performance to update their strategies. However, because of the flexibility, how learners react to impasses and errors has a critical influence on their learning. An intelligent pedagogical agent (IPA) continuously modeling learner activities could help support learners in these environments. However, this continuous comprehension of behaviors and strategies is difficult in OELEs with evolving goals, ill-defined problem structures, and learning sequences. In this paper, we draw from the literature on SRL phases and cognitive states to investigate the utility of two different methods, Sequence Mapping, and Hidden Markov Models, in building learner activity models from log data collected from a summer camp with 14 middle school girls in an open-design environment. We evaluate the effectiveness of these models separately, and combined, in identifying 7 states: Forethought, Engaged Concentration, Acting, Monitoring, Wheel Spinning, Mind Wandering, and Reflect and Repair. Lastly, we recommend dialogue intervention strategies for an IPA to support learning in OELEs.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1935801
- PAR ID:
- 10540995
- Editor(s):
- Benjamin, Paaßen; Carrie, Demmans Epp
- Publisher / Repository:
- International Educational Data Mining Society
- Date Published:
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Right(s):
- Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Researchers and educators have developed a variety of computer-based technologies intended to facilitate self-regulated learning (SRL), which refers to iterative learning processes wherein individuals set plans and goals, complete tasks, monitor their progress and outcomes, and adapt future efforts. This paper draws upon the SRL literature and related work to articulate two fundamental principles for designing SRL-promoting technologies: the Platform Principle and the Support Principle. The Platform Principle states that SRL-promoting technologies must incorporate clear platforms (i.e., tools and features) for engaging in planning, enacting, monitoring, and adapting. The Support Principle states that SRL-promoting technologies must include clear scaffolds for strategies, metacognition, motivation, and independence. These principles can be applied heuristically to formatively assess how and whether given learning technologies enable and scaffold self-regulation. More broadly, these assessments can empower educational technology creators and users to strategically design, communicate, and study technologies aligned with self-regulation. An exemplar application of the framework is presented using the PERvasive Learning System (PERLS) mobile SRL technology.more » « less
-
Self-regulated learning (SRL) is an essential factor in academic success. Self-regulated learning is a process where learners set clear goals, monitor progress toward attainment of those goals, and adapt their strategies to improve their learning. Because SRL is often not explicitly integrated into the classroom, students struggle to identify and use learning techniques empirically proven to be more successful than others. SRL is a learned skill students can develop over time that has been found to be related to high achievement and self-efficacy. This paper examines the effects of introducing SRL strategies into an undergraduate introductory physics classroom. The degree to which the students were self-regulated learners was correlated with their test averages (r = 0.23, p < 0.05). Students reported that they found the SRL instruction helpful (3.5 out of 5.0 on a 5-point scale) and 86% of the students felt the time spent on the instruction was generally appropriate. Students’ preferred study methods changed over the course of the semester, indicating that students applied SRL by adapting their learning processes based on which methods were most effective in helping them study for an upcoming exam and opting not to use techniques no longer perceived as useful. Higher achieving students were more likely to settle on highly effective techniques by the end of the semester, while lower achieving students continued to modify their learning processes.more » « less
-
Benjamin, Paaßen; Carrie, Demmans Epp (Ed.)Open-ended learning environments (OELEs) have become an important tool for promoting constructivist STEM learning. OELEs are known to promote student engagement and facilitate a deeper understanding of STEM topics. Despite their benefits, OELEs present significant challenges to novice learners who may lack the self-regulated learning (SRL) processes they need to become effective learners and problem solvers. Recent studies have revealed the importance of the relationship between students' affective states, cognitive processes, and performance in OELEs. Yet, the relations between students' use of cognitive processes and their corresponding affective states have not been studied in detail. In this paper, we investigate the relations between studentsż˝f affective states and the coherence in their cognitive strategies as they work on developing causal models of scientific processes in the XYZ OELE. Our analyses and results demonstrate that there are significant differences in the coherence of cognitive strategies used by high- and low-performing students. As a result, there are also significant differences in the affective states of the high- and low-performing students that are related to the coherence of their cognitive activities. This research contributes valuable empirical evidence on studentsż˝f cognitive-affective dynamics in OELEs, emphasizing the subtle ways in which students' understanding of their cognitive processes impacts their emotional reactions in learning environments.more » « less
-
Self-regulated learning (SRL) is the ability to regulate cognitive, metacognitive, motivational, and emotional states while learning and is posited to be a strong predictor of academic success. It is therefore important to provide learners with effective instructions to promote more meaningful and effective SRL processes. One way to implement SRL instructions is through providing real-time SRL scaffolding while learners engage with a task. However, previous studies have tended to focus on fixed scaffolding rather than adaptive scaffolding that is tailored to student actions. Studies that have investigated adaptive scaffolding have not adequately distinguished between the effects of adaptive and fixed scaffolding compared to a control condition. Moreover, previous studies have tended to investigate the effects of scaffolding at the task level rather than shorter time segments—obscuring the impact of individual scaffolds on SRL processes. To address these gaps, we (a) collected trace data about student activities while working on a multi-source writing task and (b) analyzed these data using a cutting-edge learning analytic technique— ordered network analysis (ONA)—to model, visualize, and explain how learners' SRL processes changed in relation to the scaffolds. At the task level, our results suggest that learners who received adaptive scaffolding have significantly different patterns of SRL processes compared to the fixed scaffolding and control conditions. While not significantly different, our results at the task segment level suggest that adaptive scaffolding is associated with earlier engagement in SRL processes. At both the task level and task segment level, those who received adaptive scaffolding, compared to the other conditions, exhibited more task-guided learning processes such as referring to task instructions and rubrics in relation to their reading and writing. This study not only deepens our understanding of the effects of scaffolding at different levels of analysis but also demonstrates the use of a contemporary learning analytic technique for evaluating the effects of different kinds of scaffolding on learners' SRL processes.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.12729890
