Attention:The NSF Public Access Repository (PAR) system and access will be unavailable from 11:00 PM ET on Thursday, November 12th until 12:00 AM ET on Friday, November 13th due to maintenance. We apologize for the inconvenience.


Title: Building Contextualized Trust Profiles in Conditionally Automated Driving
Trust is crucial for ensuring the safety, security, and widespread adoption of automated vehicles (AVs), and if trust is lacking, drivers and the general public may hesitate to embrace this technology. This research seeks to investigate contextualized trust profiles in order to create personalized experiences for drivers in AVs with varying levels of reliability. A driving simulator experiment involving 70 participants revealed three distinct contextualized trust profiles (i.e., confident copilots, myopic pragmatists, and reluctant automators) identified through K-means clustering, and analyzed in relation to drivers' dynamic trust, dispositional trust, initial learned trust, personality traits, and emotions. The experiment encompassed eight scenarios where participants were requested to take over control from the AV in three conditions: a control condition, a false alarm condition, and a miss condition. To validate the models, a multinomial logistic regression model was constructed using the shapley additive explanations explainer to determine the most influential features in predicting contextualized trust profiles, achieving an F1-score of 0.90 and an accuracy of 0.89. In addition, an examination of how individual factors impact contextualized trust profiles provided valuable insights into trust dynamics from a user-centric perspective. The outcomes of this research hold significant implications for the development of personalized in-vehicle trust monitoring and calibration systems to modulate drivers' trust levels, thereby enhancing safety and user experience in automated driving.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2138274
PAR ID:
10581359
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
IEEE Transactions on Human-Machine Systems
Date Published:
Journal Name:
IEEE Transactions on Human-Machine Systems
Edition / Version:
1
Volume:
54
Issue:
6
ISSN:
2168-2291
Page Range / eLocation ID:
658 to 667
Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
Automated vehicles (AVs), emotion, personality traits, contextualized trust profiles.
Format(s):
Size: 2.4 Other: pdf
Size(s):
2.4
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Trust calibration poses a significant challenge in the interaction between drivers and automated vehicles (AVs) in the context of human-automation collaboration. To effectively calibrate trust, it becomes crucial to accurately measure drivers’ trust levels in real time, allowing for timely interventions or adjustments in the automated driving. One viable approach involves employing machine learning models and physiological measures to model the dynamic changes in trust. This study introduces a technique that leverages machine learning models to predict drivers’ real-time dynamic trust in conditional AVs using physiological measurements. We conducted the study in a driving simulator where participants were requested to take over control from automated driving in three conditions that included a control condition, a false alarm condition, and a miss condition. Each condition had eight takeover requests (TORs) in different scenarios. Drivers’ physiological measures were recorded during the experiment, including galvanic skin response (GSR), heart rate (HR) indices, and eye-tracking metrics. Using five machine learning models, we found that eXtreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) performed the best and was able to predict drivers’ trust in real time with an f1-score of 89.1% compared to a baseline model of K -nearest neighbor classifier of 84.5%. Our findings provide good implications on how to design an in-vehicle trust monitoring system to calibrate drivers’ trust to facilitate interaction between the driver and the AV in real time. 
    more » « less
  2. Personalized driving styles (DS) in automated vehicles (AVs) can improve drivers’ trust and acceptance. However, little is known about how drivers identify and communicate their preferred DSs to AVs. Also, most studies have focused on normal driving situations, without considering risky or off-nominal scenarios. This study examined how drivers find their preferred DS by allowing participants to adjust the AV’s driving behavior. A study was conducted whereby drivers experienced one of four predefined DSs, categorized by their level of conservativeness in terms of safety and speed in navigating road obstacles. Participants completed 10 driving trials where they provided feedback to an AV regarding whether to change or maintain its DS. Drivers preferred to maintain the same DS from previous trials and a DS that was neither too aggressive nor too conservative. Findings can help inform the development of adaptive algorithms that preemptively adjust DS without drivers’ explicit inputs. 
    more » « less
  3. As autonomous vehicles (AVs) increasingly operate in unpredictable environments, their function is shifting from simply being modes of transportation to becoming active collaborators alongside human drivers. In turn, drivers must assume a cooperative role, working effectively with autonomous systems to achieve shared goals, most importantly, ensuring human safety. Despite considerable progress, real-world usage and testing of AVs continue to highlight vulnerabilities, particularly in safety-critical situations. This study examines how vehicle failure, the type of failure (security vs. mechanical), and the scenario context influence drivers’ trust and risk perception toward AVs. Initially, six categories of failure scenarios were identified using data from the California Department of Motor Vehicles’ disengagement reports. Subsequently, an online experiment was conducted, where participants experienced both baseline (normal operation) and failure drives. In the failure drive, participants encountered one specific failure type and scenario. The results revealed a substantial decrease in driver trust following the failure drive across all conditions. Higher perceived risk was associated with reduced trust and lower risk-taking behaviors. Scenarios were classified into high- and low-risk categories, with control-related issues having the most pronounced effect on increasing perceived risk. The experiment found no difference in trust or risk perception whether the failure was caused by a malicious intervention or a mechanical issue. These findings suggest that AV design should incorporate mechanisms for assessing and appropriately responding to varying risk levels in critical situations. Enhancing this capability will strengthen the collaborative relationship between humans and AVs, ultimately improving safety and reliability in human-machine teaming contexts. 
    more » « less
  4. null (Ed.)
    Autonomous Vehicle (AV) technology has the potential to significantly improve driver safety. Unfortunately, driver could be reluctant to ride with AVs due to the lack of trust and acceptance of AV’s driving styles. The present study investigated the impact of driver’s driving style (aggressive/defensive) and the designed driving styles of AVs (aggressive/defensive) on driver’s trust, acceptance, and take-over behavior in fully autonomous vehicles. Thirty-two participants were classified into two groups based on their driving styles using the Aggressive Driving Scale and experienced twelve scenarios in either an aggressive AV or a defensive AV. Results revealed that drivers’ trust, acceptance, and takeover frequency were significantly influenced by the interaction effects between AV’s driving style and driver’s driving style. The findings implied that driver’s individual differences should be considered in the design of AV’s driving styles to enhance driver’s trust and acceptance of AVs and reduce undesired take over behaviors. 
    more » « less
  5. Objective This study investigated drivers’ subjective feelings and decision making in mixed traffic by quantifying driver’s driving style and type of interaction. Background Human-driven vehicles (HVs) will share the road with automated vehicles (AVs) in mixed traffic. Previous studies focused on simulating the impacts of AVs on traffic flow, investigating car-following situations, and using simulation analysis lacking experimental tests of human drivers. Method Thirty-six drivers were classified into three driver groups (aggressive, moderate, and defensive drivers) and experienced HV-AV interaction and HV-HV interaction in a supervised web-based experiment. Drivers’ subjective feelings and decision making were collected via questionnaires. Results Results revealed that aggressive and moderate drivers felt significantly more anxious, less comfortable, and were more likely to behave aggressively in HV-AV interaction than in HV-HV interaction. Aggressive drivers were also more likely to take advantage of AVs on the road. In contrast, no such differences were found for defensive drivers indicating they were not significantly influenced by the type of vehicles with which they were interacting. Conclusion Driving style and type of interaction significantly influenced drivers’ subjective feelings and decision making in mixed traffic. This study brought insights into how human drivers perceive and interact with AVs and HVs on the road and how human drivers take advantage of AVs. Application This study provided a foundation for developing guidelines for mixed transportation systems to improve driver safety and user experience. 
    more » « less