An official website of the United States government
This dataset originates from a new CESM2 CAM6 perturbed parameter ensemble (PPE) designed to explore climate and hydroclimate dynamics under a wide range of sea surface temperature (SST) conditions. The SST varies from 4 degrees Celsius colder to 16 degrees Celsius warmer than preindustrial levels, encompassing a broad spectrum of mean temperatures spanning the past 65 million years. This dataset offers valuable insights into climate and hydroclimate responses, as well as weather and climate extremes under diverse conditions.The dataset includes results from nine PPE simulations with different SST scenarios: preindustrial (PREI), 4K cooler (M04K), and 4K, 8K, 12K, and 16K warmer (P04K to P16K). For SSTs exceeding 8K warming, sea ice was removed to improve numerical stability. Each PPE set consists of 250 ensemble members, with 45 parameters related to microphysics, convection, turbulence, and aerosols perturbed using Latin Hypercube Sampling. An additional simulation with default parameter settings brings the total to 251 simulations, each running for five years using CAM6.3 (https://github.com/ESCOMP/CAM/tree/cam6_3_026; with additional paleo modifications).Post-processing converted the data into compressed NetCDF-4 format. All 251 runs were concatenated using ncecat to minimize the number of files. For example, the following file contains monthly surface temperature data from the preindustrial PPE: f.c6.F1850.f19_f19.paleo_ppe.sst_prei.ens251/atm/proc/tseries/month_1/f.c6.F1850.f19_f19.paleo_ppe.sst_prei.ens251.cam.h0.TS.000101-000512.ncA detailed variable list [https://rda.ucar.edu/OS/web/datasets/d651038/docs/detailed_vars.txt] can be found in the Documentation Tab.Parameter values are provided in the PPE Parameter File. More details can be found in the paper: Zhu et al. (2025). Investigating the State Dependence of Cloud Feedback Using a Suite of Perturbed Parameter Ensembles, Journal of Climate.
more »
« less
Investigating the State Dependence of Cloud Feedback Using a Suite of Perturbed Parameter Ensembles
Abstract The state dependence of cloud feedback—its variation with the mean state climate—has been found in many paleoclimate and contemporary climate simulations. Previous results have shown inconsistencies in the sign, magnitude, and underlying mechanisms of state dependence. To address this, we utilize a perturbed parameter ensemble (PPE) approach with fixed sea surface temperature (SST) in the Community Atmosphere Model, version 6. Our suites of PPEs span a wide range of global mean surface temperatures (GMSTs), with spatially uniform SST perturbations of −4, 0, 4, 8, 12, and 16 K from the preindustrial. The results reveal a nonmonotonic variation with GMSTs: Cloud feedback increases under both cooler and warmer-than-preindustrial conditions, with a rise of ∼0.1 W m−2K−1under a 4-K colder climate and ∼0.4 W m−2K−1under a 12-K warmer climate. This complexity arises from differing cloud feedback responses in high and low latitudes. In high latitudes, cloud feedback consistently rises with warming, likely driven by a moist adiabatic mechanism that influences cloud liquid water. The low-latitude feedback increases under both cooler and warmer conditions, likely influenced by changes in the lower-tropospheric stability. This stability shift is tied to nonlinearity in thermodynamic responses, particularly in the tropical latent heating, alongside potential state-dependent changes in tropical circulations. Under warmer-than-preindustrial conditions, the increase in cloud feedback with warming is negatively correlated with its preindustrial value. Our PPE approach takes the model parameter uncertainty into account and emphasizes the critical role of state dependence in understanding past and predicting future climates. Significance StatementThis study focuses on how cloud feedback—one of the most uncertain aspects of climate change—varies as global temperatures rise. We found that the cloud feedback decreases at first with warming and then increases, showing significant variation. This complexity stems from nonlinear thermodynamics, such as the Clapeyron–Clausius relationship, which describes how temperature affects moisture in the atmosphere. Our results indicate that the cloud feedback depends on the level of global warming, which is a significant factor rooted in fundamental physics. Recognizing this dependence is important for studies that aim to interpret past climates and predict future climate changes.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10617501
- Publisher / Repository:
- American Meteorological Society
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of Climate
- Volume:
- 38
- Issue:
- 16
- ISSN:
- 0894-8755
- Format(s):
- Medium: X Size: p. 4063-4081
- Size(s):
- p. 4063-4081
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract General Circulation Model (GCM) simulations with prescribed observed sea surface temperature (SST) over the historical period show systematic global shortwave cloud radiative effect (SWCRE) variations uncorrelated with global surface temperature (known as “pattern effect”). Here, we show that a single parameter that quantifies the difference in SSTs between regions of tropical deep convection and the tropical or global average (Δconv) captures the time‐varying “pattern effect” in the simulations using the PCMDI/AMIPII SST recommended for CMIP6. In particular, a large positive trend in the 1980s–1990s in Δconvexplains the change of sign to a strongly negative SWCRE feedback since the late 1970s. In these decades, the regions of deep convection warm about +50% more than the tropical average. Such an amplification is rarely observed in forced coupled atmosphere‐ocean GCM simulations, where the amplified warming is typically about +10%. During the post 2000 global warming hiatus Δconvshows little change, and the more recent period of resumed global warming is too short to robustly detect trends. In the prescribed SST simulations, Δconvis forced by the SST difference between warmer and colder regions. An index thereof (SST#) evaluated for six SST reconstructions shows similar trends for the satellite era, but the difference between the pre‐ and the satellite era is substantially larger in the PCMDI/AMIPII SSTs than in the other reconstructions. Quantification of the cloud feedback depends critically on small changes in the shape of the SST probability density distribution. These sensitivities underscore how essential highly accurate, persistent, and stable global climate records are to determine the cloud feedback.more » « less
-
Abstract A global climate model is run in radiative‐convective equilibrium including a slab ocean with a specified ocean heat transport analogous to what is seen in the tropical Pacific. The insolation is varied to create a range of global mean equilibrium temperatures. These results are compared with experiments that do not include a specified ocean heat transport. The ocean heat transport cools the coldest Sea Surface Temperatures (SSTs) and increases the SST contrast. The warmest SSTs change much less with the addition of ocean heat transport because increased atmospheric transport moves energy away from the warm region. The ocean heat transport also increases the efficiency of cooling by outgoing longwave radiation in the subsiding region, allowing for a cooler global mean SST. At colder global mean temperatures ocean heat transport creates a high‐contrast state in which abundant low clouds play a strong role in maintaining the SST contrast. This high‐contrast state abruptly transitions to a warmer, low‐SST‐contrast state as the climate is warmed by increasing insolation. At warmer temperatures comparable to the current tropics, the low cloud response is less important than longwave emission in maintaining the SST contrast. Although ocean heat transport cools the climate, it does not much affect the sensitivity of the model climate to increasing insolation. Comparison of the model results to ERA5 reanalysis data shows that mechanisms responsible for the SST distribution and energy budget changes in this idealized model are analogous to variability that occurs over the tropical Pacific Ocean.more » « less
-
Global Radiative Convective Equilibrium With a Slab Ocean: SST Contrast, Sensitivity and CirculationAbstract Warming experiments with a uniformly insolated, non‐rotating climate model with a slab ocean are conducted by increasing the solar irradiance. As the global mean surface temperature is varied across the range from 289 to 319K, the sea surface temperature (SST) contrast at first declines, then increases then declines again. Increasing SST contrast with global warming is associated with reduced climate sensitivity, while decreasing SST contrast is associated with enhanced climate sensitivity. The changing SST contrast and climate sensitivity are both related fundamentally to the effect of water vapor on clear‐sky radiative cooling. The clouds in the convective region are always more reflective than those in the subsiding region and so always act to reduce the SST contrast. At lower temperatures between 289 and 297 K the shortwave suppression of SST contrast increases faster than the longwave enhancement of SST contrast. At warmer temperatures between 297 and 309 K the longwave enhancement of SST contrast with warming is stronger than the shortwave suppression of SST contrast, so that the SST contrast increases. Above 309 K the greenhouse effect in the subsiding region begins to grow, the SST contrast declines and the climate sensitivity increases. The transitions at 297 and 309 K can be related to the increasing vapor pressure path with warming. The mass circulation rate between warm and cool regions consists of shallow and deep cells. Both cells increase in strength with SST contrast. The lower cell remains connected to the surface, while the upper cell rises to maintain a roughly constant temperature.more » « less
-
Abstract During the early‐to‐middle Miocene, global mean surface temperature (GMST) was approximately 8°C warmer than preindustrial, with a greater temperature increase in polar regions than the tropics. However, existing Miocene simulations underestimate this warmth, particularly in northern high latitudes. To address this discrepancy, we investigate the potential role of cloud phase. Using the Community Earth System Model, we conduct a paleoclimate sensitivity study focused on modifying ice nucleation and cloud phase partitioning schemes. These modifications increase the GMST, with a strong temperature rise in high latitudes and a muted increase in the tropics. These increases are driven by enhanced longwave cloud forcing, resulting from increased ice cloud amounts and cloud water content, and are amplified by water vapor and lapse rate feedbacks in the Arctic. Our study highlights that the improved parameterizations of cloud phase processes enhance models' capability to simulate Miocene high‐latitude warmth and potentially other warm climates.more » « less
