Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


Title: North American barn swallows pair, mate, and interact assortatively
Abstract While female mate choice is well established, mutual choice may play a larger role in mate selection than currently recognized. Assortative mating is a common form of nonrandom mating in animals that can result from mutual choice. However, few studies address assortative patterns beyond the social pair, potentially overlooking assortativity in the mating pair and in the social environment that shapes reproductive decisions. We asked whether North American barn swallows (Hirundo rustica erythrogaster) breeding in a large colony form pairs, mate (through both within-pair and extra-pair fertilizations), and interact assortatively by ventral plumage color, wing length, and age. Social interactions were tracked using proximity loggers, which recorded close contact between tagged individuals when birds were mating and laying eggs. Barn swallows paired and mated assortatively by their ventral plumage color; however, the assortative patterns in mating pairs were not as strong as they were in social pairs. Barn swallows also interacted assortatively, associating more often with individuals of both sexes who had similar phenotypes relative to the other birds in the colony. Finally, older males and females with darker ventral plumage achieved the highest reproductive success. Investigation of assortative behavior beyond the level of the social pair provides a more complete understanding of mate choice and suggests a mechanism that may maintain the large variation in ventral plumage color in North American barn swallows.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1856266 1856254 1856229
PAR ID:
10628837
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ;
Editor(s):
Briffa, Mark
Publisher / Repository:
Oxford
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Behavioral Ecology
Volume:
36
Issue:
4
ISSN:
1045-2249
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (, Behavioral Ecology)
    Gil, Diego (Ed.)
    Abstract Reproductive senescence may affect mating decisions if older individuals produce fewer and lower-quality offspring, but the effect of reproductive senescence on mate choice decisions remains poorly understood. Mountain chickadees (Poecile gambeli) do not exhibit clear reproductive senescence within their natural lifespans and therefore offer a unique opportunity to test whether the absence or delay of reproductive senescence affects social mate choice for mates of certain ages. Given the lack of obvious reproductive senescence in this species, we predicted that older individuals would be preferred as social mates because pairing with an experienced mate is often associated with direct and indirect benefits. In apparent support of our predictions, we observed positive assortment for age within breeding pairs and older individuals were more likely to be paired with one another than expected by chance. However, assortative pairing also occurred within most younger age classes, and when we restricted our analyses to consider only new pairings, rates of assortative pairing within age classes were similar to those expected by chance. Thus, the observed pattern of age-related assortative mating in this system likely occurs due to longevity of some pair bonds rather than active assortment for age among individuals forming new pair bonds. Combined, our results suggest that choice of a social mate based on age may be constrained in socially monogamous mating systems when many individuals maintain long-term pair bonds. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; ; ; ; (, Ornithology)
    Abstract Many socially monogamous bird species engage in multiple mating through extra-pair (EP) fertilizations, yet the role of female plumage in EP outcomes is under studied. Sexual selection involving EP fertilization is hypothesized to influence female trait evolution if heritable plumage variation informs EP mating decisions and EP mating decisions affect fitness. Here, we test for 2 key prerequisite patterns of sexual selection through EP fertilizations by asking: (1) is female reproductive success associated with EP fertilizations, and (2) are EP fertilizations associated with female plumage traits? Studying these 2 patterns is essential for better understanding how the costs and benefits of EP fertilizations should translate to sexual selection on female plumage. We provide a conceptual diagram to highlight how plumage traits of both members of a social pair can influence fertilizations within and outside their pair bond from the perspective of each sex. In our sample of 47 Hirundo rustica erythrogaster (North American Barn Swallow) social pairs, females who engaged in EP mating tended to fledge more offspring, and females with longer tails were more likely to mate with EP sires. Furthermore, female traits were more strongly associated with EP fertilizations than male traits for predicting both female and male EP outcomes. Finally, we found that female traits were not correlated with fecundity (total eggs laid) and found no association between fecundity and EP fertilizations. Thus, sexual selection on EP fertilizations may be more important than selection on fecundity for understanding female plumage variation in our study population. Taken together, we provide evidence for multiple conditions necessary for sexual selection on female plumage traits in H. r. erythrogaster that are likely also relevant for understanding female trait evolution in other socially monogamous birds. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; (, Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology)
    Abstract Extra-pair mating is common in avian species and can modulate the strength of sexual selection. Mate searching behavior of female birds may be an important predictor of mating opportunities and extra-pair mating, yet important knowledge is lacking as we have little data on fine-scale movement of females during the peak fertilization period. Accordingly, much is still unknown about whether and how female phenotypes contribute to extra-pair mating. Here, we examined how female space use and female plumage color are associated with extra-pair mating outcomes in wild barn swallows (Hirundo rustica erythrogaster). We tracked 10 females breeding in Colorado, USA with GPS backpack tags for two hours each morning during their fertile period following an experimental nest failure. We then used low-coverage whole-genome sequencing to determine offspring paternity and to quantify extra-pair mating in the removed clutch and the replacement clutch. Plumage and movement did not correlate with changes in paternity between successive clutches, but movement did correlate with paternity in the replacement clutch. Females that spent more time away from the nest had a higher proportion and number of extra-pair offspring in the clutch laid immediately after the tracking period. These results suggest that differences in female space use contribute to differences in extra-pair fertilizations. In contrast to the historic emphasis on male traits, our study highlights female movement behavior as an important variable associated with mating outcomes in natural populations. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ; ; (, Animal Cognition)
    Abstract Many animals breed colonially, often in dense clusters, representing a complex social environment with cognitive demands that could ultimately impact individual fitness. However, the effects of social breeding on the evolution of cognitive processes remain largely unknown. We tested the hypothesis that facultative colonial breeding influences attention and decision-making. Barn swallows (Hirundo rustica) breed in solitary pairs or in a range of colony sizes, up to dozens of pairs. We tested for selective attention to social information with playbacks of conspecific alarm calls and for decision-making with simulated predator intrusions, across a range of colony sizes from 1 to 33 pairs. We also evaluated the adaptive value of both processes by measuring seasonal reproductive success. Swallows breeding in larger colonies were more selective in their attention to social information. Birds breeding in larger colonies were also less risk averse, deciding to return more quickly to their nests after a predator approach paradigm. Finally, birds that showed higher selective attention hatched more eggs and birds that returned to their nests more quickly after a predator intrusion had more nestlings. Although we cannot fully attribute these fitness outcomes to the cognitive measures considered in this study, our results suggest that social breeding plays a role in adaptively shaping both the acquisition of social information and decision-making. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; (, eLife)
    Birds are among the most colorful animals on Earth. The different patterns and colors displayed on their feathers help them to identify their own species, attract mates or hide from predators. The bright plumages of birds are achieved through either pigments (such as reds and yellows) or structures (such as blues, greens or ultraviolet) inside feathers, or through a combination of both pigments and structures. Variation in the diversity of color patterns over time can give a helpful insight into the rate of evolution of a species. For example, structural colors evolve more quickly than pigment-based ones and can therefore be a key feature involved in species recognition or mate attraction. Studying the evolution of plumage patterns has been challenging due to differences in the vision of humans and birds. However, recent advances in technology have enabled researchers to map the exact wavelengths of the colors that make up the patterns, allowing for rigorous comparison of plumage color patterns across different individuals and species. To gain a greater understanding of how plumage color patterns evolve in birds, Eliason et al. studied kingfishers, a group of birds known for their complex and variable color patterns, and their worldwide distribution. The experiments analyzed the plumage color patterns of 72 kingfisher species (142 individual museum specimens) from both mainland and island populations by quantifying the amount of different wavelengths of light reflecting from a feather and accounting for relationships among species and among feather patches. The analyzes showed that having more complex patterns leads to a greater accumulation of plumage colors over time, supporting the idea that complex plumages provide more traits for natural or sexual selection to act upon. Moreover, in upper parts of the bodies, such as the back, the plumage varied more across the different species and evolved faster than in ventral parts, such as the belly or throat. This indicates that sexual selection may be the evolutionary force driving variation in more visible areas, such as the back, while patterns in the ventral part of the body are more important for kin recognition. Eliason et al. further found no differences in plumage complexity between kingfishers located in island or mainland habitats, suggesting that the isolation of the island and the different selection pressures this may bring does not impact the complexity of color patterns. However, kingfisher species located on islands did display higher rates of color evolution. This indicates that, regardless of the complexity of the plumage, island-specific pressures are driving rapid color diversification. Using a new multivariate approach, Eliason et al. have unearthed a pattern in plumage complexity that may otherwise have been missed and, for the first time, have linked differences in color pattern on individual birds with evolutionary differences across species. In doing so, they have provided a framework for future studies of color evolution. The next steps in this research would be to better understand why the island species are evolving more rapidly even though they do not have more complex plumage patterns and how the observed color differences relate to rapid rates of speciation. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Text Encoded Conversion
  • XML
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email