skip to main content

Attention:

The NSF Public Access Repository (PAR) system and access will be unavailable from 11:00 PM ET on Friday, December 13 until 2:00 AM ET on Saturday, December 14 due to maintenance. We apologize for the inconvenience.


Title: Pricing Energy in the Presence of Renewables
The intermittent nature of renewable energy generation implies that renewable producers rely on non-renewable producers to ensure the aggregate power delivered meets the promised quality of service. Therefore, the intermittent nature of renewable energy generation affects the committed power and market price of energy. We consider an electricity market where renewable and non-renewable generators bid by proposing their asking price per unit of energy to an independent system operator (ISO). The ISO solves a dispatch optimization problem to minimize the cost of purchased energy on behalf of the consumers. We incorporate the notion of net-load variance using the Conditional Value-at-Risk (CVAR) measure in the dispatch optimization problem to ensure that the generators are able to meet the load within a desired confidence level. We analytically derive the market clearing price of energy and dispatched powers as a function of CVAR and show that a higher penetration of renewable energies may increase the market clearing price of energy. Finally, we present descriptive simulations to illustrate the impact of renewable energy penetration on the market price of energy.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1739295
PAR ID:
10076420
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
2018 Annual American Control Conference (ACC)
Page Range / eLocation ID:
3881 to 3886
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Power grid resource adequacy can be difficult to ensure with high penetrations of intermittent renewable energy. We explore enhancing resource adequacy by overbuilding renewables while modeling statistical correlations in renewable power at different sites. Overbuilding allows production during times of low power, and exploiting statistical correlations can reduce power variability and, subsequently, reduce needed renewable capacity. In this work, we present a stochastic optimization problem to size renewables and expand transmission while minimizing the expected dispatch cost. Our method uses statistical profiles of renewable production and embeds network constraints using the DC power flow equations. We assess our method’s effects on feasibility, load shedding, locational marginal prices, and generator curtailment. On the IEEE 9-bus system, we found that anti-correlation between generators reduced generation capacity needs with sufficient transmission. On the IEEE 30-bus system, we found that the optimal solution required significant overbuilding and curtailment of renewables regardless of the marginal cost of schedulable generation. 
    more » « less
  2. As the renewable penetration in the grid increases, the grid-takes-all-renewable paradigm will no longer be sustainable. We consider a day-ahead (DA) electricity market composed of a renewable generator, a natural gas power plant (NGPP) and a coal power plant (CPP). Each player provides the Independent System Operator (ISO) with their commitment and their asking price. The ISO schedules the generators using a least-cost strategy. Because of the intrinsic uncertainty of the renewable generation, the renewable player might be unable to meet its DA commitment. In the event of a shortfall, the renewable generator incurs a penalty so that the non-renewable sources are not forced to consume the cost of renewable intermittence. It has been recognized that such a penalty can lead to conservative bidding by the renewable generator, which may lead to lower than desired penetration of renewable energy in the grid. We formulate and analyze a contract between the renewable producer and the NGPP so that the NGPP reserves some amount of natural gas to hedge the renewable producer against shortfalls. Expressions for the optimal commitments of the players and for the optimal reserve contract are derived. When a reserve contract is established, we observe an increase both in the average profit of the players involved and in the renewable participation in the market. Thus, we show that a Pareto-optimal contract between market players can improve renewable penetration. 
    more » « less
  3. Enabling participation of demand-side flexibility in electricity markets is key to improving power system resilience and increasing the penetration of renewable generation. In this work we are motivated by the curtailment of near-zero-marginal-cost renewable resources during periods of oversupply, a particularly important cause of inefficient generation dispatch. Focusing on shiftable load in a multi-interval economic dispatch setting, we show that incompatible incentives arise for loads in the standard market formulation. While the system's overall efficiency increases from dispatching flexible demand, the overall welfare of loads can decrease as a result of higher spot prices. We propose a market design to address this incentive issue. Specifically, by imposing a small number of additional constraints on the economic dispatch problem, we obtain a mechanism that guarantees individual rationality for all market participants while simultaneously obtaining a more efficient dispatch. Our formulation leads to a natural definition of a uniform, time-varying flexibility price that is paid to loads to incentivize flexible bidding. We provide theoretical guarantees and empirically validate our model with simulations on real-world generation data from California Independent System Operator (CAISO). 
    more » « less
  4. There are growing concerns over the ability of current electricity market designs to adequately model and optimize against the stochastic nature of renewable resources such as wind and solar. In this paper, we consider an economic dispatch problem that explicitly accounts for said uncertainty and enforces network and generation limits using conditional value at risk. Our key contribution is the definition and analysis of risk-sensitive locational marginal prices (risk-LMPs) derived from such a market clearing problem. Risk-LMPs extend conventional LMPs to the uncertain setting. Settlements defined via risk-LMPs compensate resources for both energy and reserve schedules. We study these prices via sample average approximation (SAA) on example power networks to demonstrate their viability for electricity pricing with large-scale integration of renewables. 
    more » « less
  5. We study the market structure for emerging distribution-level energy markets with high renewable energy penetration. Renewable generation is known to be uncertain and has a close-to-zero marginal cost. In this paper, we use solar energy as an example of such zero-marginal-cost resources for our focused study. We first show that, under high penetration of solar generation, the classical real-time market mechanism can either exhibit significant price-volatility (when each firm is not allowed to vary the supply quantity), or induce price-fixing (when each firm is allowed to vary the supply quantity), the latter of which leads to extreme unfairness of surplus division. To overcome these issues, we propose a new rental-market mechanism that trades the usage-right of solar panels instead of real-time solar energy. We show that the rental market produces a stable and unique price (therefore eliminating price-volatility), maintains positive surplus for both consumers and firms (therefore eliminating price-fixing), and achieves the same social welfare as the traditional real-time market. A key insight is that rental markets turn uncertainty of renewable generation from a detrimental factor (that leads to price-volatility in real-time markets) to a beneficial factor (that increases demand elasticity and contributes to the desirable rental-market outcomes). 
    more » « less