skip to main content

Title: Comparative Analysis of Silicon Carbide and Silicon Switching Devices for Multilevel Cascaded H-Bridge Inverter Application with Battery Energy storage
This paper investigates the use of power semiconductor devices in a nine - level cascaded H-bridge (CHB) multilevel inverter topology with an integrated battery energy storage system (BESS) for a 13.8kV medium voltage distribution system. In this topology, the bulky conventional step-up 60 Hz transformer is not used. The purpose of this study is to analyze the use of SiC MOSFET and Si IGBT devices in the inverter system to evaluate their respective performances. SiC MOSFET and Si IGBT switching devices are modeled and characterized using Saber® modeling software. The switching losses, thermal performance, and efficiency of the inverter system are investigated, and measurements are obtained from the simulation. Saber® provides a good capability for characterizing semiconductor models in the real world, with great features of computation. A three-phase SiC power MOSFET-based multilevel CHB inverter prototype is presented for experimental verification. In the investigation, better performances of SiC MOSFET devices are recorded. SiC devices demonstrate promising performance at different switching frequency and temperature ranges.
; ; ; ; ;
Award ID(s):
Publication Date:
Journal Name:
2018 9th IEEE International Symposium on Power Electronics for Distributed Generation Systems (PEDG)
Page Range or eLocation-ID:
1 to 5
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. This paper presents the study and evaluation of a medium-voltage grid-tied cascaded H-bridge (CHB) three-phase inverter for battery energy storage systems using SiC devices as an enabling technology. The high breakdown voltage capability of SiC devices provide the advantage to significantly minimize the complexity of the CHB multilevel converter, with less power loss compared to when Silicon (Si) devices are used. The topology in this study has been selected based on high voltage SiC devices. In order to reach 13.8 kV, a nine-level CHB is needed when using 6.5 kV SiC MOSFETs. However, if 10 kV SiC MOSFETs are used, only five-levels of the CHB are required. The controls were developed, simulated and verified through an experimental prototype. The results from the scaled-down prototype proved the controls and the verification of the performance of five-level CHB three-phase inverter. For the system reliability, both open-loop and short-circuit faults are analyzed.
  2. This paper describes a study evaluating 1.2 kV SiC MOSFETs in modular multilevel cascaded H-bridge (CHB) threephase inverter for medium voltage ac grid applications. The main purpose of this topology is to remove the need of a bulk 60 Hz transformer that is normally used to step up the output signal of a voltage source inverter to the medium voltage level. Using SiC devices (1.2 kV ~ 6.5 kV SiC MOSFETs), with their high breakdown voltage, enables the system to meet and withstand the medium voltage stress, with a minimized number of cascaded modules. The SiC-based power electronics, when used in the presented topology, they significantly reduce the complexity usually faced when Si devices are used to meet the medium voltage level and the power scalability. The simulation and preliminary experimental results, on a low-voltage prototype, verifies the ninelevel CHB topology that is presented in this paper.
  3. Driving solutions for power semiconductor devices are experiencing new challenges since the emerging wide bandgap power devices, such as silicon carbide (SiC), with superior performance become commercially available. Generally, high switching speed is desired due to the lower switching loss, yet high dv/dt and di/dt can result in elevated electromagnetic interference (EMI) emission, false-triggering, and other detrimental effects during switching transients. Active gate drivers (AGDs) have been proposed to balance the switching losses and the switching speed of each switching transient. The review of the in-existence AGD methodologies for SiC devices has not been reported yet. This review starts with the essence of the slew rate control and its significance. Then a comprehensive review categorizing the state-of-the-art AGD methodologies is presented. It is followed by a summary of the AGDs control and timing strategies. In this work, using AGD to reduce the EMI noise of a 10 kV SiC MOSFET system is reported. This work also highlights other capabilities of AGDs including reliability enhancement of power devices and rebalancing the mismatched electrical parameters of parallel- and series-connected devices. These application scenarios of AGDs are validated via simulation and experimental results.
  4. Wide band gap (WBG) devices feature high switching frequency operation and low switching loss. They have been widely adopted in tremendous applications. Nevertheless, the manufacture cost for SiC MOSFET greater than that of the Si IGBT. To achieve a trade off between cost and efficiency, the hybrid switch, which includes the paralleling operation of Si IGBT and SiC MOSFET, is proposed. In this article, an active gate driver is used for the hybrid switch to optimize both the switching and thermal performances. The turn-on and turn-off delays between two individual switches are controlled to minimize the switching loss of traditional Si IGBT. In this way, a higher switching frequency operation can be achieved for the hybrid switch to improve the converter power density. On the other hand, the gate source voltages are adjusted to achieve an optimized thermal performance between two individual switches, which can improve the reliability of the hybrid switch. The proposed active gate driver for hybrid switch is validated with a 2 kW Boost converter.
  5. This paper describes the study of a topology of modular multilevel converters for integrating battery energy storage into a medium (13.8 kV) distribution system. The main benefit of this topology is to remove the need for a bulk 60 Hz transformer that is normally used to step up the output of a voltage source inverter to the medium voltage level. A SiC-based power electronics interface presented in this paper provides an efficient solution without the large and costly transformer. Using medium voltage SiC devices (≥ 10 kV SiC MOSFETs), with their high breakdown voltage, enables the system to meet and withstand medium voltage application, using a minimized number of cascaded modules. This SiC-based power electronics interface significantly reduces the complexity usually faced when Si devices are used directly in medium voltage applications. The voltage and state of charge balancing control for battery modules is also simplified and performs well. The simulation and experimental results, performed on a low-voltage prototype, verify the proposed topology that is presented in this paper.