skip to main content


Title: In-process monitoring and prediction of droplet quality in droplet-on-demand liquid metal jetting additive manufacturing using machine learning
Abstract

In droplet-on-demand liquid metal jetting (DoD-LMJ) additive manufacturing, complex physical interactions govern the droplet characteristics, such as size, velocity, and shape. These droplet characteristics, in turn, determine the functional quality of the printed parts. Hence, to ensure repeatable and reliable part quality it is necessary to monitor and control the droplet characteristics. Existing approaches for in-situ monitoring of droplet behavior in DoD-LMJ rely on high-speed imaging sensors. The resulting high volume of droplet images acquired is computationally demanding to analyze and hinders real-time control of the process. To overcome this challenge, the objective of this work is to use time series data acquired from an in-process millimeter-wave sensor for predicting the size, velocity, and shape characteristics of droplets in DoD-LMJ process. As opposed to high-speed imaging, this sensor produces data-efficient time series signatures that allows rapid, real-time process monitoring. We devise machine learning models that use the millimeter-wave sensor data to predict the droplet characteristics. Specifically, we developed multilayer perceptron-based non-linear autoregressive models to predict the size and velocity of droplets. Likewise, a supervised machine learning model was trained to classify the droplet shape using the frequency spectrum information contained in the millimeter-wave sensor signatures. High-speed imaging data served as ground truth for model training and validation. These models captured the droplet characteristics with a statistical fidelity exceeding 90%, and vastly outperformed conventional statistical modeling approaches. Thus, this work achieves a practically viable sensing approach for real-time quality monitoring of the DoD-LMJ process, in lieu of the existing data-intensive image-based techniques.

 
more » « less
Award ID(s):
1752069 2020246
NSF-PAR ID:
10370559
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Springer Science + Business Media
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing
Volume:
33
Issue:
7
ISSN:
0956-5515
Page Range / eLocation ID:
p. 2093-2117
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Liquid droplet impact is a subject that has been investigated in both engineering and non-engineering applications to understand and to control this phenomenon. Spray cooling, ink-jet printing, spray coating and painting, soil erosion prevention, pesticide application, and impact erosion are merely a few examples in which droplet impact is involved. Erosion caused by droplet impact on a solid surface is important in numerous elements of industrial equipment, such as pipelines, steam turbines, and wind turbine blades. Though experimental and modeling studies have been performed on this topic, most failed to perform quantitative investigation especially when it came to the erosion of wind turbine blades. Moreover, most approaches assume that the impacting droplets are completely spherical and unaffected by any local turbulence or vortex shedding. As the droplet erosion process could be affected by several parameters, such as the impact velocity, shape and size of the droplets, this study focuses on investigating droplet properties and movement in a controlled lab environment. High speed imaging and Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) methods are used for this purpose. PIV is used to measure the velocity, circularity, and size of the falling droplets in both disturbed and un-disturbed flow conditions. High-speed camera imaging provides additional insight to the path of the droplets’ movement in the presence of any turbulence. Experiments are performed at a variety of flow rates utilizing a range of blunt needle gauge sizes to create different droplet sizes. It is observed that the blunt needles produce a train of droplets that are different in size following each leading droplet. This is a crucial observation as it will have a direct impact on the magnitude of erosion and should be considered in the future modeling efforts. 
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    Condensation figure (CF) is a simple and cost-effective method to inspect patterns and defects on product surfaces. This inspection method is based on energy differentials on surfaces. Due to wettability contrast, water droplets are preferentially nucleated and grown on hydrophilic regions. The formed CF can further be segmented for the recognition and measurement of the patterns on the surfaces. The state-of-the-art CF methods are closeenvironmental, while controlled open-environmental CF has broader applications in manufacturing and quality inspection. The lack of open-environmental CF for such applications is mostly because of the unavailable droplet size control methods. In this paper, we designed a high-resolution optical surface inspection system based on open environment droplet-size-controlled CFs. This is done by real-time imaging and recognizing the condensed droplet sizes and densities on surfaces, and accordingly tuning the vaporization and evaporation of droplets on the surface by the vapor flow rate. Our experimental results show that the average diameter of droplets can be controlled below 3.5 µm in a laboratory setup for different metal substrates. We also test the system for inspecting self-assembled monolayer patterns with linewidth of 5 µm on a gold surface; this can be promisingly used for online quality monitoring and in-process control of printed patterns in flexible devices manufacturing. 
    more » « less
  3. Droplet impacts on solid surfaces produce a wide variety of phenomena such as spreading, splashing, jetting, receding, and rebounding. In microholed surfaces, downward jets through the hole can be caused by the high impact inertia during the spreading phase of the droplet over the substrate as well as the cavity collapse during recoil phase of the droplet. We investigate the dynamics of the jet formed through the single hole during the impacting phase of the droplet on a micro-holed hydrophilic substrate. The sub-millimeter circular holes are created on the 0.2 mm-thickness hydrophilic plastic films using a 0.5 mm punch. Great care has been taken to ensure that the millimeter-sized droplets of water dispensed by a syringe pump through a micropipette tip can impact directly over the micro-holes. A high-speed video photography camera is employed to capture the full event of impacting and jetting. A MATLAB code has been developed to process the captured videos for data analysis. We study the effect of impact velocity on the jet formation including jet velocity, ejected droplet volume, and breakup process. We find that the Weber number significantly affects outcomes of the drop impact and jetting mechanism. We also examine the dynamic contact angle of the contact line during the spreading and the receding phase. 
    more » « less
  4. null (Ed.)
    Binder Jetting (BJ) is a low-cost Additive Manufacturing (AM) process that uses inkjet technology to selectively bind particles in a powder bed. BJ relies on the ability to control, not only the placement of binder on the surface but also its imbibition into the powder bed. This is a complex process in which picoliter-sized droplets impact powder beds at velocities of 1–10 m/s. However, the effects of printing parameters such as droplet velocity, size, spacing, and inter-arrival time on saturation level (fraction of pore space filled with binder) and line formation (merging of droplets to form a line) are unknown. Prior attempts to predict saturation levels with simple measurements of droplet primitives and capillary pressure assume that droplet/powder interactions are dominated by static equilibrium and neglect the impact of printing parameters. This study analyzes the influence of these parameters on the effective saturation level and conditions for line formation when printing single lines into powder beds of varied materials (316 stainless steel, 420 stainless steel, and alumina) and varied particle size (d50=10–47 µm). Results show that increasing droplet velocity or droplet spacing decreases effective saturation while droplet spacing, velocity, and inter-arrival time affect line formation. At constant printing velocity, the conditions for successful line printing are shown to be a function of droplet spacing and square root of the droplet inter-arrival time analogous to the Washburn model for infiltration into a porous media. The results have implications to maximizing build rates and improving quality of small features in BJ. 
    more » « less
  5. null (Ed.)
    Abstract

    Inkjet 3D printing has broad applications in areas such as health and energy due to its capability to precisely deposit micro-droplets of multi-functional materials. However, the droplet of the inkjet printing has different jetting behaviors including drop initiation, thinning, necking, pinching and flying, and they are vulnerable to disturbance from vibration, material inhomogeneity, etc. Such issues make it challenging to yield a consistent printing process and a defect-free final product with desired properties. Therefore, timely recognition of the droplet behavior is critical for inkjet printing quality assessment. In-situ video monitoring of the printing process paves a way for such recognition. In this paper, a novel feature identification framework is presented to recognize the spatiotemporal feature of in-situ monitoring videos for inkjet printing. Specifically, a spatiotemporal fusion network is used for droplet printing behavior classification. The categories are based on inkjet printability, which is related to both the static features (ligament, satellite, and meniscus) and dynamic features (ligament thinning, droplet pinch off, meniscus oscillation). For the recorded droplet jetting video data, two streams of networks, the frames sampled from video in spatial domain (associated with static features) and the optical flow in temporal domain (associated with dynamic features), are fused in different ways to recognize the droplet evolving behavior. Experiments results show that the proposed fusion network can recognize the droplet jetting behavior in the complex printing process and identify its printability with learned knowledge, which can ultimately enable the real-time inkjet printing quality control and further provide guidance to design optimal parameter settings for the inkjet printing process.

     
    more » « less